• Images
  • Text
  • Find a Couple + Registry
GO

Bakery Gingham

The Knot Best of Weddings
189 Thurman Ave Columbus, OH map | (614) 449-2253
| www.bakerygingham.com
Bakery Gingham 5 of 5 1 22

22 total reviews

show reviews by reviewer type:

Results 1 - 20 of 22
avatar
blakkenhorse
Wedding: 6/30/2012
verified review
Delicious and flexible posted 7/27/2012

I got cupcake centerpieces for my wedding. The staff was super helpful in choosing flavors, we could have as many flavors as we wanted and they were delicious (a month later we still are getting comments about their deliciousness). My only small problem with them was that, for whatever reason not all the stands arrived at the reception location, so some of the cupcakes were not on stands in the center of the table. If you are looking for amazing tastiness, however, this is the place to go. Make sure to taste the Buckeye cupcakes!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
kad8986
Wedding: 7/6/2012
verified review
The BEST cake I've EVER had! posted 7/23/2012

Bakery Gingham did such a wonderful job of making our dream wedding cake display a reality (and it tasted even better than it looked)! We wanted to have lots of variety for our guests, so went with a cake/cupcake combination. We ended up with seven different cake flavors that all tasted amazing! They also let us borrow a cake stand and six matching cupcake stands to make it all come together. They were so flexible with our indecisiveness and made everything look and taste great in the end! Looking forward to visiting them every year for a cupcake on our anniversary :)

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
teamfutler
Wedding: 10/29/2011
verified review

I am SO happy we went with Bakery Gingham for our wedding reception! I wanted a lot of variety in the cake at our wedding, so I thought it would be perfect to do cupcakes! We went back and forth between companies, but we loved the flavors available at Bakery Gingham. We had a fall wedding and chose Buckeye Nation, Twice Chai, Apple Streusel, and Pumpkin Roll for our flavors. Before the wedding, they called us and discusses what kinds of colors and decorations we wanted for our cupcakes. Bakery Gingham delivered the cupcakes and brought cupcake pedestals and set up the whole cake table for us. It was BEAUTIFUL! We were so happy with the set up. And our guests loved the cupcakes! Would recommend them to anyone!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
JECass
Wedding: 8/31/2012
verified review
Unaccommodating and rude! posted 6/17/2012

I contacted Bakery Gingham to schedule a cake tasting. The hours they provide are unaccommodating for anyone who works full time. When I said it was difficult for me to schedule something before 6 PM I was told 'most people make planning their wedding a priority!'. We have decided to go with Piece of Cake in the Short North which makes fabulous cakes and has been very easy to work with and accommodating.

avatar
lnbigha
Wedding: 5/12/2012
verified review
Best Ever!! posted 6/13/2012

After speeches, I was expecting a lot of people on the dance floor ready to get down (we had a live band and that usually gets people dancing) however, I looked out onto a sea of people actually sitting down and eating the cake!!! Guests said to me "you shouldn't have had such a delicious cake if you wanted people to get up and dance right away!" It was delicious cake :)

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
snapir
Wedding: 4/14/2013
verified review
Best Bakery in Columbus! posted 3/25/2012

I have been to this bakery several times for their cupcakes, and loved them. This was in my top 2 for my wedding cake, and my #1 lost out before I even scheduled a tasting because of their attitude. I scheduled 4 tasting, and this was the second and last stop. I wanted a non-traditional flavor cake, and had come up with 2 flavors I really wanted. When I walked in the door the staff was extremely helpful and friendly, and to my amazement... one of their cupcake flavor that day was one of the flavors I wanted for my cake, Destiny! Their price for a custom flavor was the same as everyone else's traditional flavors, and their cakes were absolutely delicious. if you can try the Short & Stout. Chocolate stout cake with a chocolate stout ganache with bailey's buttercream frosting.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
pam22pamela
Wedding: 3/26/2011
verified review
Superb! posted 12/16/2011

We have had nothing but amazing service w Bakery Gingham, from the first few emails to the wedding cake to now placing various cake orders for other events. We went for our tasting and tasted some extremely scrumptious flavors. We are now lifelong fans! We have stopped by numerous times just to get some cupcakes We had a themed wedding cake (fire truck) and it was a hit at our wedding!! Bakery Gingham did a great job w all the fine details and the presentation was superb. We received many compliments on the cake and the taste too! Best wedding cake I've ever tasted.
We were extremely pleased w our wedding cake from Bakery Gingham and would highly recommend them!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
melmcclew
Wedding: 9/24/2011
verified review
Best Bite of Cake! posted 10/17/2011

Although my husband and I only had the bite of cake during the cutting, it was everything we had hoped for. We did the traditional look of a cake but the cake/icing was like a pumpkin roll, all of our guests loved it! Cant wait for our first anniversary to eat a whole piece :) Definetely have it delivered, it was well worth it, and it looked perfect!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
jse2006
Wedding: 8/6/2011
verified review
wedding cake posted 10/4/2011

great tasting cakes and cupcakes, but the pricetag was too high for us

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
nettylow
Wedding: 6/18/2011
verified review
delicious posted 7/4/2011

We spoke with Amanda and she was so helpful and recreated something we saw in a magazine. In fact, she did it better!! the cake was so good and actually we had three different flavors in our cake and the coconut with coconut buttercream... DELICIOUS! would recommend for sure!

Value
Service
Quality
avatar
mallannie33
Wedding: 6/18/2011
verified review
Wonderful! posted 7/3/2011

Our cake was beautiful and delicious! And the owner and staff couldn't have been more helpful. Highly recommend!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
kangaryoo
Wedding: 5/29/2011
verified review
Yummy! posted 6/13/2011

The cupcakes were a hit and they were very easy to work with!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
twilt36
Wedding: 4/9/2011
verified review
amazing cupcake tower! posted 5/7/2011

We loved our cupcake tower! 5 different flavors. Colors were beautifully matched and tasted amazing!

Value
Service
Quality
avatar
rr323163
Wedding: 5/14/2010
LOVE posted 4/22/2011

Amanda is amazing. My husband and I had called a few other locations and none were nearly as friendly and helpful as Amanda. She is extremely talented and was able to work within our budget. Our wedding was in May 2010 and we still receive tons of compliments on our cake. It was absolutely beautiful...it fit our rustic theme perfectly :)

I can't forget to mention the taste...the cake is as delicious as her cupcakes...just yum!

I appreciated the fact that I was able to check "cake" off my list after one, short meeting. Bakery Gingham took care of everything for this super picky bride.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
jesswatson24
Wedding: 10/9/2010
verified review
The best ever! posted 1/3/2011

We used Bakery Gingham for our wedding that was this past October! Bakery Gingham was the first bakery that I met with and I didn't want to go anywhere else! As soon as I met Amanda, the owner, I knew that this where i wanted our wedding cake to be made. She was very flexible, fun and personable! Amanda's personality was very down to earth and easy to get along with:) Not only was she great to work with, but the cake tastes amazing!!! The cake is very moist and flavorful and the icing is creamy and very delicious! We still go back and get the cupcakes to get our Bakery Gingham fix! I recommend Bakery Gingham not only for a wedding but any occasion that you have going on!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2009
Wedding: 12/11/2010
verified review
Best frosting ever....... posted 1/1/2011

Our event coordinator at COSI had suggested Bakery Gingham. So we went there after at consult/tour at COSI and feel in LOVE. Our cupcakes/cake were the first thing we secured for the wedding. We had themed tables so we got themed cupcakes to match them! They were amazing! We had a little cake made for us to cut into. When we fed cake to each other we both commented on how great the frosting was. Bakery Gingham is always a favorite to stop into when we are up in Columbus. Highly recommended for any event, wedding, or if you are in the mood for a cupcake!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
aubreysean
Wedding: 10/9/2010
verified review
DELICIOUS! posted 11/8/2010

I had cupcakes for our wedding and they were amazing!... great customer service.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
rvnnicole
Wedding: 9/11/2010
verified review
All I can say is Yumm-O!!! posted 9/28/2010

This bakery is known for their cupcakes but their wedding cakes are to die for as well. I did my research and this bakery was not only better tasting but the price tag was nice as well!! They now have two locations one off of Thurman Ave and one in the Short North... call and schedule a taste testing and you will be SOLD!!!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
hockeygirl27
Wedding: 8/20/2010
verified review

Amanda Ellis is the owner of this wonderful bakery and the nicest person you will ever meet!! Her cakes are even more amazing! I have been to hundreds of weddings and dozens of bridal shows and none of the cake I have ever had could hold a candle to flavor & freshness of her cakes. She completely designed my cake just as I wished it to be no problem! The price was also VERY reasonable. I had several guests at my reception ask me where I had purchased my cake because it was the best tasting wedding cake that they had ever had. I would HIGHLY recommend her to any Bride or anyone else needing a wonderful cake for a special occasion!!
-Christy Stuhldreher Turner, Columbus, OH

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
mruddle.1
Wedding: 6/4/2010
verified review
Amazing Bakers posted 8/24/2010

When deciding on a desert for my wedding I was pretty clueless about what I wanted expect for the fact that I wanted cupcakes. They made the most delicious cupcakes I've ever had, and when it came to designing our personal cake I told them I liked birds and would like something like two sparrows on top, and gave them our wedding colors and they created the cutest cake I've ever seen! Very memorable.

Quality
Service
Value

Results 1 - 20 of 22

awards and affiliations

  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2013The Knot Best Of Weddings 2013
  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2011The Knot Best Of Weddings 2011