• Images
  • Text
  • Find a Couple + Registry
GO
99 Quaker Meeting House Rd Farmingdale, NY | (516) 501-9700
| www.carlylecatering.com
swipe or click to view more
Carlyle on the Green 5 of 5 1 28

28 total reviews

show reviews by reviewer type:

Results 1 - 20 of 28
avatar
ErinB627
Wedding: 8/15/2014
verified review
The Best Decision We Made!! posted 8/27/2014

I got married at Carlyle on the Green on 8/15/14 and it was everything I dreamed of and more. The venue itself is beautiful, but it goes far beyond that. The staff is excellent. Cynthia was amazing and so easy to work with. All of her recommendations for vendors, food choices, etc. were on point. She answered all of our questions and was extremely helpful throughout the planning process. There were no worries the day of the wedding. I don't know if I can put into words how awesome the bridal attendant, Janet, is. She is the most wonderful person I have ever met. She was so well prepared and made sure I had everything I needed. She was so attentive. I can't thank her enough. My guests are still raving about the Carlyle. They said the service was impeccable and the food was amazing! Choosing the Carlyle as our ceremony/reception venue was the best decision we ever made!!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
tacb13
Wedding: 7/12/2014
verified review
Beyond Amazing posted 8/27/2014

The level of service exceeded every expectation I could have had! The food was out of this world and my guests couldn't stop gushing about the whole experience! Sue (our coordinator) was a huge help in setting everything up and responded to every question I had along the way in a swift and meaningful manner. Janet, my bridal attendant, was so attentive and on top of everything that I was completely blown away by how well I was treated and looked after. The whole experience was top notch and I would recommend them to anyone/everyone I could!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
Stephi1231
Wedding: 7/26/2014
verified review
Amazing experience posted 8/18/2014

The staff at Carlyle on the Green are simply amazing. They are kind, caring, professional, flexible and responsive. I booked with Sue P. She was my main point of contact and I always felt like I was her priority. I know she probably has dozens of other brides but she never shows it. She went out of her way to book Tee times for my parents!

Everyone from the maître d (Jonathan) to my lovely bridal attendant (who held ice cubes wrapped in white silk on my back when I looked hot!) was attentive and absolutely wonderful. I would recommend this venue to anyone. The food was the major hit at the wedding. My guests are still raving about it!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
schobekf
Wedding: 10/3/2014
verified review
Best Day of My Life posted 10/20/2014

In addition to being gorgeous, Carlyle on the Green employs the most helpful, patient and caring staff ever. Elyse assisted me in planning my big day from day one and Janet & Monty made sure the reception went perfectly smoothly. Literally everyone who attended our wedding has been raving about it for weeks. Everything was amazing, but the food was the biggest hit. My favorite part was the very end of the night, when the staff set out plates of dessert for my new husband and I to enjoy by ourselves after all of our guests had left. The truly make sure the bride and groom enjoy their reception -- which is something so many people told me I wouldn't do. If I could do it over, I'd pick Carlyle again in a heart beat!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
salw15
Wedding: 9/21/2014
verified review

Words cannot express how amazing Carlyle on the Green was for our wedding! The venue is stunning, the food (kosher - and same price as non-kosher menu) was incredible, and our contact person Sue was so helpful and responsive throughout the entire process. Janet, the bridal attendant, was incredible - besides being such a lovely person to spend the day with, she kept us hydrated, well fed, came to the dance floor to change my shoes, and toweled us off with ice water when we got hot. Our maitre d was okay, it didn't seem like he had done a jewish wedding before which slowed down the rehearsal and caused our wedding to start a few minutes late as he did not direct the necessary people to the ketubah signing. Our guests were raving throughout the day about how gorgeous the venue was and how delicious everything was that they ate. We also really enjoyed the Jamaican band at our after party and would highly recommend this as a way to decompress and end the evening. We would recommend Carlyle on the Green to anyone in a heartbeat!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
TaraR215
Wedding: 12/7/2013
verified review
Beautiful location, great food, close to perfect posted 1/13/2014 (modified 1/14/2014)

Carlyle on the Green is GORGEOUS! I couldn't imagine a more perfect venue for our wedding. I loved the hominess of the coctail hour and the reception hall is windowed on all sides with a huge dance floor. Food is wonderful. Service is mostly great. I just can't give it 5 stars because they didn't deliver everything the promised. Some of the food we were given didn't coincide with what we picked for cocktail hour. They promised us no one would be able to walk through our reception and they left the door to the restauarnt wide open with people coming through (took several conversations to get this corrected). Waiter service was either spectacular or dismal. Some guests said it was the best service they ever had while others said they never saw their server. In general, these things were minimal and we loved our wedding, but the fact is they oversold a little.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
NehaK127
Wedding: 8/17/2013
The Most Beautiful Day of Our Lives posted 1/11/2014 (modified 1/13/2014)

The Carlyle was the last venue we saw in our search and it was worth every penny! Cynthia was amazing! Janet my Bridal attendant was always making sure my family and I were comfortable. Everyone was always respectful, available and very professional. Being a bride that is super busy with work, Cynthia always knew how to keep me at ease and made sure my vision was executed perfectly. I am from a small town in upstate NY and wanted to recreate an elegant affair with the surroundings of natural beauty. I got everything I ever dreamed of and my guests were delighted. The venue has only 1 wedding at a time and every room is beautiful, so I didn't even mind if I had rain on my wedding day and had to go inside--luckily the weather was perfect! I highly reccommend it to everyone.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
mjk25
Wedding: 9/6/2014
Worst services ever posted 9/7/2013

The worst service ever! Our planner was very full of herself, dismissive and made tons of mistakes on the wedding day!!! The menu that we picked and tasted was changed without consulting us and we ended up getting chicken while paid for filet mignon. When we contacted the catering after the wedding, they hang up on us.
I would NOT recommend their service!!!! And please don't fall for everything that they promise--you will NOT get half of it!!!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
ht4365
Wedding: 8/11/2013
The best! posted 8/15/2013

I don't even know where to begin! Carlyle is amazing, besides the beautiful venue and amazing food, the staff is awesome. From start to finish Cynthia was so accommodating. She even came to see us the day of the wedding! Monty and Janet had everything covered, they were constantly getting us food and drinks without us even asking. Janet is prepared for everything- she sewed on my husband's button in two seconds while we were taking pictures! They all gave us an unbelievably perfect day... I definitely recommend the after hours- it gave us another hour to party and dance!

Thank you Carlyle for everything:)

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
RadhikaV
Wedding: 6/16/2013
verified review
Loved it! posted 7/12/2013

While this place is a drive from our wedding venue and a bit expensive, it was worth it. Sue and the entire staff was so accommodating. I also have never met a bridal attendant, like Janet, who has been so helpful! She literally was reapplying my lipstick for me throughout the night! and brought me and my husband food when she saw that we didn't have a second to breathe!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
renanarabinovich
Wedding: 6/23/2013
verified review
June wedding posted 7/10/2013

Had my june wedding at carlye. Sue was quite accommodating and easy to deal with. The only real issue was that they lied to us about the chairs. When we booked the hall the chairs they had were the gross old fashioned chairs with the gaudy floral print. They told us that the new more modern looking charais were ordered and will for sure be in fr our wedding. In the end the chair we had at our wedding were the ugly ones. I wonder if they just tell people that there will be new chairs or if it is a reality. They did nothing to accommodate us besides offer to put these horrible white socks over the chairs which would have just made it worse. Besides for that the hall was beautiful, staff was friendly, and bar well stocked. we had a 350 person wedding (capacity at the hall) and all ran smooth. The bridal attendant (janet) was truly amazing.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
legoldmann
Wedding: 6/2/2013
verified review
Beautiful Venue posted 6/17/2013

COTG is a beautiful venue. We had lovely weather and a beautiful outdoor ceremony. Our rep Elyse was kind and attentive throughout the process and worked hard to make sure everything we wanted would be realized.
A few things that can be worked out on their end. They promised 4 attendants and we only had 1. They were also supposed to get new chairs in and in the 10 months we waited they never arrived. So we had to spend 3k additional to rent them.
We did feel that they were a bit disorganized for a wedding of our size, but in the end we loved the place and would recommend them.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
SuperRoz
Wedding: 8/5/2012
verified review
Absolutely Wonderful! posted 8/23/2012 (modified 8/23/2012)

I recently held my ceremony and reception at the Carlyle on the Green, with 160 guests, and could not have been happier. The ambiance was elegant and classy. The staff was incredibly attentive; Robert J was my Maître D'. My bridal attendant Janet was AMAZING! She knew what I needed even before I did! My guests can not stop raving about the food. Everything was delicious and prepared perfectly. From start to finish Sue, our wedding coordinator at the Carlyle, helped make this an easy and smooth ride. Our wedding wasn't kosher, but she did an incredible job coordinating Glatt Kosher meals for family members in need. The cake is included in your wedding package but is baked outside at Dortoni's on Hempstead Turnpike in Levittown. It was delicious! We were able to take home leftovers and we ate a slice each night until our honeymoon and it was still fresh!

This review doesn't truly capture how impressed and satisfied I was with the quality and service of this establishment. I recommend this venue with the highest regard and hope that one of my friends will get married there so I can enjoy it as a guest!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
Jen71412
Wedding: 7/14/2012
verified review
Beautiful grounds and view posted 7/6/2012

Breathtaking views from the ballroom.

avatar
jaimy213
Wedding: 4/21/2012
verified review
Best wedding ever! posted 5/17/2012

That's what everyone said to me as they were leaving the Carlyle after my wedding. The food was great and the service was beyond amazing. They were on point the entire night and they went beyond our expectations. I couldn't have been happier and everyone is still raving about the food from my wedding!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
Yalanomata
Wedding: 6/26/2011
verified review
AMAZING!! posted 10/7/2011 (modified 10/7/2011)

This place is so beautiful, inside and out; there are many places for photographs so no need to go to another location. The food was delicious (cocktail hour, main course and dessert). The service we received there was unbelieveable. We felt like we were treated like royalty. And not just specific attention paid to us or our parents, but to all our guests. We felt so lucky we found an available date for our wedding! Also - they have updated their chairs (someone below wrote that they needed covers - they have since bought new chairs).
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
jsiegel87
Wedding: 7/30/2011
verified review
Excellent!!!!! posted 9/3/2011

This place was amazing. Not only was the venue stunning, but the people that work there are amazing! They really made everyone feel like they had their own personal assistant the entire night.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
nflubin
Wedding: 8/12/2011
verified review
LOVE THIS PLACE posted 7/8/2011

My wedding is on August 5th but I love this place so much that I decided to write a review early. Sue is AMAZING. She's been so helpful in getting things moving and making sure we're on top of everything. I can't wait for my wedding in 5 weeks. I'll write an additional review at that time.

avatar
mbk1115
Wedding: 3/5/2011
verified review
The Best posted 3/31/2011

Carlyle was amazing from the beginning. They are beyond accommodating and the service is incredible. The staff truly made our night unforgettable

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
SammyJC
Wedding: 9/10/2010
verified review
Absolutely amazing posted 9/28/2010

Every single thing the Carlyle did was perfect. From the bridal assisant to the beautiful ballroom and food. People told me this wedding was the best wedding they've ever been to.


Results 1 - 20 of 28

Expect The Extraordinary

Carlyle on the Green combines the richness of Long Island's glorious heritage with the finest service and ambiance offered in today's modern times. Dine and rejoice in the magnificent Grand Conservatory Ballroom featuring Palladian windows overlooking our sun-drenched landscape and the world famous


  • Price Range: $$$
  • Amenities: Indoor Ceremony Area, Kosher Available, Liquor License, Onsite Catering, Onsite Parking, Outdoor Ceremony Area, Outdoor Reception Area, Outside Caterers Allowed, Valet Parking, Wheelchair Accessible
  • Capacity: More than 400
  • Style: Banquet/Reception Hall, Country Club, Mansion/Historic Site

awards and affiliations

  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2013The Knot Best Of Weddings 2013
  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2011The Knot Best Of Weddings 2011

Carlyle on the Green's twitter

RT @CarlyleonGreen: Happy Halloween and Congrats our bride & groom tonight! #HalloweenWedding pic.twitter.com/7aRRjt38BC


12 Hours ago from @CarlyleCatering


Announcing Sunday Brunch at Deco 1600 beginning November 2nd! Call 516-756-1600 to make your reservations today.


13 Hours ago from @CarlyleCatering


TOMORROW..."The Best Halloween Party On Long Island"! Music by Troy Curtis of Menudo! Get your tickets in advance: hb4.eventbrite.com


28 Oct from @CarlyleCatering


Announcing Sunday Brunch and Italian Wednesdays Buffet at Deco 1600 in Plainview beginning in November! Call 516-756-1600 for reservations.


24 Oct from @CarlyleCatering


Now booking Holiday Parties at all our locations! Have a small office? Join our Small Office Holiday Party on 12/16 @ 7pm. Call 516-756-1600


22 Oct from @CarlyleCatering