• Images
  • Text
  • Find a Couple + Registry
GO

Cupcake Crazy / Top Tier Custom Cakes

3899 West Lake Mary Blvd, Suite 139 Lake Mary, FL map | (407) 804-0229
| www.cupcakecrazy.com
Cupcake Crazy / Top Tier Custom Cakes 5 of 5 1 24

24 total reviews

show reviews by reviewer type:

Results 1 - 20 of 24
avatar
daniellelilja
Wedding: 1/19/2014
verified review
Beautiful AND Delicious posted 2/5/2014 (modified 2/6/2014)

Karen at Cupcake Crazy was a delight to work with. I had a very specific vision for our cupcakes, and she really really nailed it. Also, we went and tried like, 7 different cupcake stores and everything tasted mostly fine - except for Cupcake Crazy. They were honestly the tastiest cupcake I've ever had. Perfection.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2006
Wedding: 3/16/2013
verified review
Made my vision come to life! posted 9/30/2013

Karen is absolutely incredible -- and her cakes are to die for! In my first meeting with Karen, she asked questions and sketched out ideas as she listened. By the time we left, I had a beautiful sketch of my amazing cake and a stomach full of tasty cupcakes we had sampled. Amaretto cake? Yes, please!

It also made for great breakfast the day after my wedding! ;)

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2012
verified review

Cupcake Crazy provided my daughter's wedding with not only a "must see to believe" wedding cake, BUT the cake itself was one of the best tasting cakes ever!

The sugar flowers were unbelievably realistic looking. We didn't want to cut through them. Then, we tasted the cake and, well, the cake was history!

Karen R. is a master baker, a master cake decorator, and a master visionary as well. When my daughter and I met with Karen we weren't sure what we wanted. Yet, Karen took out her pen and drew my daugher's wishes on to paper. Everything from the sunflowers and pearls to the blue lovebirds on top!

The cake was a showstopper. But, Karen did not sacrifice taste for looks. The cake was moist, flavorful, and unforgeettable. Our guests were talking about the cake at the "morning after" breakfast...a culinary delight for sure!

Don't let the name "cupcake" fool you....Cupcake Crazy can serve up an unforgettable wedding cake as well. It's worth the drive to Longwood, FL, just to sample Karen's varied creations.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
tanyatsho
Wedding: 4/12/2013
verified review
Decandent cake! posted 4/30/2013

We met the Cupcake crazy team at a vendor show months before the wedding. It only took me a bite of cake to know that they would be making our wedding cake. The cake was simply decadent. It was an almond cake dipped in a Baileys Irish Cream Soak with chocolate mousse and a thin ganache! Absolutely delicious! Everyone asked for seconds!

The other great thing with Cupcake crazy is that on your 1st year anniversary you get a free cake! How great is that!! :)

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
kerikae
Wedding: 3/16/2013
verified review
AMAZING cake posted 4/2/2013

In addition to being absolutely beautiful, the cake tasted AWESOME. I definitely had wedding cake for brunch the next day! Karen's amazing and you're crazy if you don't go check out her storefront! She'll let you test cupcakes until you find your perfect match. (Ours was amaretto!)

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
JessMKennedy
Wedding: 1/26/2013
verified review
Wedding 1/26/13 posted 2/12/2013

We loved Karen from cupcake crazy! She was so great! The cakes were delicious, the designs were great, and she was so amenable to all of our requests! She is so fun, you'll love her! Her cakes are also an amazing value! Lifetime customer for all of occasions.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
LDAVILA4151
Wedding: 10/27/2012
verified review
5 stars is not enough! posted 11/14/2012

I think the best desciption of how amazing our wedding cake was is the simple fact that there were 7 pieces left. We had a cake that would serve 144 but we only had 110 people that attended the wedding. One guest we spoke with had 3 pieces of cake, my wife and I both had 2 and to this day....nearly a month after our wedding, the cake is still being talked about by our guest. Karen was amazing and made a beautiful cake but the look of the cake was quickly overshadowed by the taste!!! It was nice to actually be at a wedding where the cake was absolutely beautiful and a highlight of the room and the flavor was even more of a conversation. Can't wait to have more cakes from Karen!!!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
stasiasweety
Wedding: 5/18/2012
verified review

The cake was beautiful and delicious! Karen did a great job designing the cake and making it look just like the sketch that she drew. We are excited to have her make us a fresh cake on our 1 year anniversary, as she offers it free in exchange for a photo of the cake at the reception :)

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
PrincessJamo
Wedding: 4/21/2012
verified review
Delcious Buttercream Cake! posted 5/9/2012

Karen was truly an angel. I was very adamant about not having fondant on my wedding cake and was afraid I would never find someone that could do it, until I met Karen. She has numerous flavors and each one of them were just as delicious as the next. And her frosting tastes just as incredible as the cakes! She is an artist when it comes to frosting!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
lineybean
Wedding: 4/14/2012
verified review
Incredible Cakes posted 5/1/2012

My only regret was being so full of adrenaline on my wedding day that I only had one bite of cake! Karen does amazing work, I loved the way the cake came out. The silver cake stand was well worth $25, it really added something special. People raved about the cake, both the look and the taste. When I saw it at the reception it met and beat my expectations. I would certainly use them again for any other special occasion cake... and cupcakes. YuM!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
garciagi
Wedding: 3/17/2012
verified review
I loved Karen posted 4/12/2012

I really loved the taste of the cake. I expected the cake to look different but it was still very pretty. The owner karen really tries to work with your budget and I loved that she was very personable.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
jaminprice
Wedding: 2/18/2012
verified review
YUM! posted 3/5/2012

Instead of the traditional wedding cake, we decided to have cupcakes. From the tasting to the night of, we were blown away! Cupcakes were not only beautiful but tasty!! She was also able to construct a wonderful helicopter cake for my hubby!!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
lindseystults1
Wedding: 3/23/2013
verified review
Fun Cupcakes posted 2/6/2012

We ordered cupcakes for our wedding instead of the traditional cake and I liked them but was not over the moon crazy about them. My mother had to do all of the planning/trying for me since we live out of state and the color scheme was beautiful but I was not wild about the flavors we chose and the frosting.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
kep08g
Wedding: 8/12/2011
verified review

I could not be happier about having chosen our Cupcake Crazy to make our wedding cake! Cake tasting was wonderful and Karen was so patient as my husband (fiance at the time) and I discussed what we both wanted. From each of our ideas she helped design a perfect cake for us and even helped plan a cupcake anniversary surprise for our parents! Karen was both professional and sweet and caring through the whole experience. She also took care of our extra details (like the table cloth that my kindergarten class signed and colored flower petals). Finally, we were on a relatively tight budget for our guest list and the price was wonderful! I would highly recommend Cupcake Crazy to anyone planning on having a wedding cake!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
Missing
Wedding: 10/23/2011
verified review
Wedding cake 10/23// posted 11/29/2011

My cake turned out so beautiful. The flowers were made out of sugar and air brushed to look real. Karen has a very talented team of staff.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
thelembrees
Wedding: 9/17/2011
verified review
Perfect!! posted 9/25/2011

For having no idea what I wanted besides cupcakes Karen did an amazing job at making it exactly what I wanted!! She also was accommodating to my egg and wheat allergy. She was amazing!!! Thank you again for my perfect day!!!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
cwiceangel
Wedding: 6/18/2011
verified review
posted 7/5/2011 (modified 7/26/2011)

They made our cake absolutely beautiful. They made handmade peacocks to help adorn our cake and it tasted wonderful. It's just a shame I was too full to eat much of it. They will give you a new top tier on your one year anniversary so you don't have to save the top... Just bring them a picture of the cake at the reception. :)

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
pedsrn2006
Wedding: 6/11/2011
verified review
Wedding Cake posted 7/4/2011

Karen at cupcake crazy is wonderful! She made us a beautiful wedding cake and a very affordable price. The cake was delicious and I look forward to her making me a duplicate at our 1 year wedding anniversary!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
laralati
Wedding: 5/14/2011
verified review
Different and perfect! posted 6/16/2011

Not much of a cake person, I wanted something special and different. The owner/designer sat down with me to get my ideas and vision and came up with a perfect design from top to bottom for my order. I ended up with big cupcakes, little cupcakes, and a little cake as a topper! I got to pick several flavors and they are the BEST cupcakes I've ever had! There were NONE LEFT!! :)

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
mojabunni
Wedding: 3/5/2011
verified review
Beautiful cake, good service posted 3/22/2011

We ordered our simple 3-tier cake from Cupcake Crazy. There were no problems or delivery issues and nothing went wrong. It was a butter cream cake, but everyone thought it was so smooth, it must have been fondant. Their prices are reasonable and service is friendly. I like that they bake you a fresh cake topper on your 1-year anniversary if you bring her a professional photo of the cake.


The only regret is that I did not really enjoy the cake as much on the wedding night. I felt like it tasted better during our tasting at the store than it did when delivered. Maybe I was just overstimulated from everything going on and nothing really tasted appealing...who knows.

Quality
Service
Value

Results 1 - 20 of 24