• Images
  • Text
  • Find a Couple + Registry
GO
Harrisburg, Lancaster, Lebanon, Hershey and Surrounding Communities Cleona, PA | (717) 383-1689
| www.katiecakescakery.com
swipe or click to view more
Katie Cakes Cakery 5 of 5 1 41

41 total reviews

show reviews by reviewer type:

Results 1 - 20 of 41
avatar
laurak2010
Wedding: 9/25/2010
verified review
Wedding and Grooms Cake posted 10/13/2010

Katie can bake a cake like no other in this world! Not only are her cakes too beautiful and well decorated to eat, they taste better than any cake I've ever eaten! I ordered a Chicago Bears groomscake for my husband, at our rehearsal dinner. Katie made the colors, lettering, and details to absolute perfection! Our wedding cake had hand made, edible flowers that were just completely unbelieveable. Everyone LOVED the cake. After our wedding, many people were so impressed, that they asked for Katie's information.
Katie has a varied selection in flavors, and can create anything that you can imagine. The cake was so delicious that my husband asked if we can order a nondecorated cake just for ourselves. I'm sure she would do that too. :)

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
mkk001
Wedding: 7/14/2012
verified review

I cannot say enough good things about Katie! Not only was the cake absolutely beautiful, but it was delicious! We went into our consult without a specific idea of how we wanted our cake to look and Katie really took the time to listen to our ideas and sketched out a vision of how it would look. She was very easy to work with and we loved the collaborative element in our consult. We received so many comments and compliments on how beautiful and unique our cake was and it truly was an eye-catching centerpiece as our guests arrived at the reception. Katie not only created a visually stunning wedding cake but one that actually tasted as good as it looked! In our consult we were given several cake flavors and icing options to sample and we opted for a red velvet cake with cream cheese icing. It without question was the most moist and delicious red velvet cake we have ever had! We highly recommend Katie Cakes Cakery!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
Caits21
Wedding: 5/11/2009
Beautifully delicious! posted 7/22/2011

My caterer included dessert with our buffet, so Katie and I worked together to create a 2-tier round cake that had style and served the purpose of the traditional cake-cutting. It was BEAUTIFUL and had a lovely fondant bow on top, with a pretty fondant 'sales tag' hanging down with our monogram. Sales tags labeled multiple items at our reception, and the cake was no exception.

My husband and I stood at the cake table and ate it with spoons because it was so good and we couldn't stand just having one bite! We had the applesauce cake with brandy buttercream icing - and it was AMAZING!

Overall - Katie does incredible work that tastes yummy and looks great... and it's well priced! I can't wait to have another party or event so I can order another one of Katie's cakes!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
AubRowe
Wedding: 5/9/2014
verified review
Beautiful, Delicious Cake posted 5/27/2014 (modified 5/28/2014)

Our wedding cake from Katie Cakes Cakery was not only beautiful, but SO delicious. Our guests raved about our cake – we had two flavors, both were phenomenal – and Katie was such a pleasure to work with. From the tasting to the delivery of the cake, she is a true professional, and my husband and I would recommend her to anyone!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2010
Wedding: 4/26/2014
verified review
Delectable Desserts :) posted 5/13/2014 (modified 5/14/2014)

Katie was so amazing with her recommendations from the flavor combinations to the designs to the size needed. We decided on four flavors for cupcakes and a two tiered cake. Her showroom was so welcoming and I felt right at home. The samples for flavors as well as all the many previous cakes she had made were great and helped me easily decide what I wanted. She is truly a master baker! All my guests raved about how moist and delicious the cupcakes and cake were! I couldn't have been more happy with the result and she chose the best display and stand for everything. I will definitely use her again!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2014
Cake of my dreams posted 5/13/2014 (modified 5/14/2014)

We did not know if we were going to do a wedding cake or cupcakes but when we started looking at pictures of cakes we came up with a plan.. Katie was able to take our thoughts and put them into cake! It was wonderful! I love looking at pictures of it.. and then to top it off it was delicious!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
samiam6388
Wedding: 10/26/2013
verified review
YOUR DREAM WEDDING CAKE IS HERE posted 11/12/2013 (modified 11/13/2013)

Katie is an absolute dream come true. Not only is she a creative genius who can design anything and everything you imagine, her cakes are absolutely DELICIOUS. Guests still rave about how good out wedding cake was. Katie is super sweet and easy to work with. You will not be disappointed!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2013
Wedding: 7/25/2013

This was the best cake I have ever had. Katie Cakes Cakery exceeded all of my expectations and amazed my reception guests. People will not stop talking about how wonderful the cake was. The owner was so professional and the display was beautiful. It was everything we could have asked for and more. If you want a lovely wedding cake, that looks and tastes great, this is the perfect choice. I will continue to use Katie Cakes for every occasion.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2011
Wedding: 5/11/2013
verified review
Absolutely Perfect! posted 10/7/2013

Katie Cakes Cakery was the perfect choice for us for our wedding. Katie was beyond helpful and understanding of what we wanted and how to work with us. We weren't sure what kind of look we wanted for our cake, so Katie emailed us design ideas based on how we described our overall feel of the wedding. She is so creative and talented! And let's not forget the actual cake... It was the BEST cake I have ever had! It was SO moist and flavorful. Our guests loved the unique flavors and the delicious cake. I will definitely being going to Katie for other cakes in the future!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
chuckychill
Wedding: 6/8/2013
Great Candy table and Cake posted 10/6/2013

We chose to have a dessert/candy table and a small cake for our rustic barn wedding. Katie created a textured buttercream cake with fresh flowers that fit in perfect with our theme. The candy table was a mix of white and yellow candy with some cookies and cake pops. It was a great treat for our guests to take home. Prices were very reasonable.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
aub92011
Wedding: 9/3/2013
highly recommend posted 10/6/2013

Thank you for the amazing cake!!! I can't tell you how many compliments we received. Very happy with the service from the first meeting to the final product.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
erserrano14
Wedding: 3/9/2013

Where do I begin? Our small family wedding was held in Berks County this past March. We put together the plans in about 2 months and Katie could not have been a bigger help! Funds were limited but the cake did not reflect our price limit at all!! I could not have dreamed of anything better. The cake was so delicious and loved by all attendees. It perfectly complemented our theme of cream and gold and looked like something out of a magazine (I know Katie’s work will be featured heavily in a well-known magazine someday!) The personal photos we have of the cake and cutting into it will be treasured forever. I can’t wait to order a cake from her for my son’s first birthday next year!!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2013
Wedding: 9/21/2013
verified review
Bride posted 10/4/2013

The cupcakes were delicious. Everyone at my wedding raved about them.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2013
Wedding: 12/22/2012
Cupcakes! posted 10/2/2013

I had my heart set on having cupcakes at our wedding reception ... and Katie definitely helped make them even better than I envisioned! Katie was great, she listened to my ideas and helped me make the right decisions for what would work best with our type of party! We had a rustic/laid back style reception, we decided on four flavors. Each one was decorated beautifully with edible flowers or pearls or fresh strawberries for toppings! She even made a special cupcake for us to cut. We decided on carrot cake and cream cheese icing (best carrot cake I've ever had!) apple sauce spice and caramel icing (melts in your mouth!) vanilla cake with strawberry preserves filling (so moist and sweet!) and a chocolate cake with raspberry preserves filling and vanilla icing(the guest favorite!) Everybody complemented on the cupcakes and several asked if they could take any leftovers home with them!
I would definitely recommend Katie, the whole experience was a joy. Now im just trying to decide on what holiday or event is coming up next so we can order a few more! Thanks Katie!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
bm756
Wedding: 3/9/2013
beautiful and delicious! posted 10/2/2013

Katie made a wedding cake for my daughters small and intimate wedding this past March. Although it was a small event, we still wanted a beautiful cake that would be a centerpiece for the room. She did just that with her creation of a gold and ivory fondant lace cake with gold dusted sugar flowers. The flavor was a chocolate cake with espresso ganache filling...yummy!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2012
Wedding: 7/4/2013
verified review
Hand Painted Wedding Cake posted 7/29/2013

I got married July 5th 2013 this summer. I was looking for a baker who could design a hand painted wedding cake. After searching and asking at least twenty bakers- Katie said she would give it a try. My cake turned out beautiful! Katie is wonderful to work with- very flexible and accommodating to any ideas you may have for your wedding day! The only drawback of Katie's services in my particular situation was the total cost of the cake- around $1,500. I know I wanted something unique with the hand painted cake, but $1,500 seemed a little pricey for what we received. Overall, the cake was beautiful and the taste was great.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
Jennyssong
Wedding: 6/22/2013
verified review

Our cake was delicious and soooo pretty. It was uniquely ours and we received many compliments on it. We recommend Katie Cakes Cakery highly.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2013
Wedding: 4/13/2013
verified review
Katie Cakes Cakery review posted 7/9/2013

Katie did an AMAZING job for my wedding! She took what I had envisioned and went beyond my expectations! We have also had Katie make us other cakes for special occasions and they have all been beyond beautiful! They are not only beautiful but absolutely delicious too! She is definitely our "go to" person for all of our cake needs! Thank you again Katie for the amazing cake! You made our special day even more special! ~ The Hartlieb's

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
katihoover
Wedding: 10/20/2012
verified review
Delish! posted 11/18/2012

We had a rather large wedding (priced for 180 people). We really enjoyed working with Katie in developing our wedding cake. She was very detail oriented, which is very important to me. And not to mention her cakes are amazing! We had the applesauce spice cake with caramelized apple filling with buttercream icing on a few tiers and the other tiers were alternating chocolate/vanilla cake with chocolate ganache filling. We had to have different cakes because of a cinnamon allergy at the wedding and Katie had no problem helping us out! The cake was delicious (both kinds). The only thing I would have changed was the color blue (fondant) used on the cake - I was looking for a darker navy and the blue she made came out much lighter than I was expecting.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
knpa06
Wedding: 10/6/2012
verified review
Most Beautiful Cake EVER posted 11/1/2012

I know I may be biased because it was our wedding cake, but this was absolutely the most gorgeous wedding cake I have ever seen. It tasted great too! I had soo many compliments just on the cake. Really great job Katie!

Quality
Service
Value

Results 1 - 20 of 41

Delicious Creations for all Occasions

Katie Cakes Cakery specializes in custom wedding cakes to best reflect the couples' personality. Also offering creative sweets tables, delicious cookie bouquets, specialty cakes for other occasions including bridal showers, engagement parties, birthdays, anniversaries and much more!


  • Price Range: $$
  • Type: Gluten Free

awards and affiliations

  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2014The Knot Best Of Weddings 2014
  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2013The Knot Best Of Weddings 2013