• Images
  • Text
  • Find a Couple + Registry
GO

Magnolia Bakery

401 Bleecker St New York, NY | (212) 462-2572
| www.magnoliabakery.com
Is this your business?
Magnolia Bakery 5 of 5 1 9

9 total reviews

show reviews by reviewer type:

Results 1 - 9 of 9
  • 1
avatar
bendittle
Wedding: 7/12/2014
verified review

We chose to have 9 icebox cakes and cupcakes at our wedding and had 2 separate meetings with Magnolia to figure out how to best get our cakes to our Hudson Valley venue and how to store them (since they must be refrigerated at all times). The staff was very friendly and helpful, although 2 people I was working with both left during an 8 month period, which was frustrating since no one let us know we would be working with someone else. Other than that, the cakes were great, our guests LOVED them and we loved having our favorite dessert on our special day.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
LKras531
Delicious and Beautiful posted 6/18/2014

Our wedding cake was from Magnolia and wow- was it delicious!! It was the comment I heard the most at the wedding. One of my Aunts is still talking about it 2 weeks later!
We chose the chocolate cake with buttercream icing. The icing had a raked look that we chose and was decorated with our flowers.
Leading up to our wedding, the cake tasting was our favorite pre wedding event. It was so hard to choose since everything tasted amazing!
The price was higher than expected, but apparently wedding cakes are expensive! When I priced out other places, I realized that Magnolia was reasonably priced, and since we really wanted a cake that tasted good, we went with them! Very glad we hired them, would absolutely hire them again and recommend them to everyone! The coolest part is that every time we have a Magnolia cupcake, we'll think of our wedding!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
Zuzzzik
Wedding: 3/13/2013
verified review

We decided last minute to elope on our trip to NYC and only booked a hotel, the officiant and a photographer. The day of the wedding, I though it would be nice to break the ice with everyone involved - and even though we only had two witnesses, something sweet could not be missing :) We bought 6 different cupcakes and brought the box over with us to the central park, where we were getting married. Everyone got one cupcake - each beautiful, tasty and refreshing. What a sweet touch at the end of the ceremony. The bonus: they had a special Cinderella edition that day, so I got to buy one with a blue slipper on it - exactly matching my blue wedding shoes. So just keep in mind, they have variety of flavors, but also of designs and decorations to match your perfect day.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
efernandez123
Wedding: 8/4/2012
verified review
Pie's Pie's Pie's posted 8/28/2012

We chose pies for our wedding instead of a cake and after trying over 15 locations, we had to go with Magnolia's. Their pies were Amazing and their staff were unforgettable. I will definitely use them again.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
Shimmer911
Wedding: 4/6/2012
verified review
Cupcake Heaven! posted 5/11/2012

I used Magnolia (Grand Central location baked order) for cupcake favors to conclude my cocktail reception. Working with Hannah, their Event person was AMAZING! The day of my wedding I receieved a call because they could not decorate one of the cupcakes as per my request to discuss an alternative. my only disappointment was I did not get the cupcakes packaged in the boxes I chose. this was a huge disappointment, but at the time of the reception- I couldn't do anything about it.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
m&kmessenger2012
Wedding: 4/4/2012
verified review
Delicious and Adorable posted 4/19/2012

I had a small destination wedding in NYC, which had a total party of 10. I ordered cupcakes to be delivered to our reception. They were delicious, and on time, but a little expensive for 24 cupcakes and delivery.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
JCarboneKelly
Wedding: 7/1/2011
verified review
Great cupcakes! posted 7/18/2011

Magnolia Bakery provided the cupcakes for my recent wedding. They were delicious! We had vanilla, chocolate, red velvet and pistachio. People are still raving about the pistachio!
Hannah was my contact person and she was great! I had a tasting and we did as much as we could through email which was fabulous.
There was a slight problem with the delivery on the day of the wedding but by the time I got to the reception hall all the cupcakes were there! I definitely recommend Magnolia!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
enovikoff
Wedding: 7/31/2010
verified review
Yummy, Beautiful posted 11/17/2010

We had five cupcake trees (cupcakes arranged on tiers) with special sugar decorations. The cupcakes arrived on time, appeared as planned, tasted delicious, and the guests loved them. Magnolia gave us small boxes with clear lids so everyone could take home a cupcake at the end of the night - great party favor! They also made us a small round cake for us to cut during the reception - that was delicious too! They listened to our requests and provided exactly what we discussed. Oh, and it photographed well too.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
The Knot Member 2005
Rating for Magnolia Bakery posted 5/10/2010


Results 1 - 9 of 9
  • 1