• Images
  • Text
  • Find a Couple + Registry
GO

Make My Cake

2380 Adam Clayton Powell Blvd New York, NY | (212) 234-2344
| www.makemycake.com
Make My Cake 5 of 5 1 12

12 total reviews

show reviews by reviewer type:

Results 1 - 12 of 12
  • 1
avatar
robrebe
Wedding: 6/9/2013
verified review
Amazing Cake! posted 6/27/2013

From the first meeting till they deliver the cake they were very professional, and made me feel very comfortable and sure of the choice I was making. The cake was delicious! & it was done exactly how I asked for it to be. Loved it!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
chbs2014
Wedding: 5/25/2013
verified review
Delicious cake but not at all what we ordered posted 6/23/2013 (modified 6/28/2013)

Their butter cream cake is to DIE FOR! So delicious. Couldn't have been happier with the taste; the guests LOVED it.
However, the design was not at ALL what we had asked for. We asked for a 2-layered cake with one simple silver ribbon tied into a big bow with the ties hanging down. We like simple and hate busy, flowery, over-done designs. What we got was just that- busy, flowery, with pearl-like drops of icing all over. And an ugly ribbon looped around the top AND bottom tier. I'm not sure how they didn't understand that the ONLY decoration we wanted was one simple, elegant, ribbon. Needless to say, on the big day, we were kind of bummed about the way our cake looked.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
rocky718
Wedding: 10/20/2012
verified review
delicious! posted 11/6/2012

This wedding cake was delicious!!! Tastes like homemade! They also gave us plenty of time and personal attention when we were trying to design the look, as well as a generous free tasting. I recommend this vendor definitely.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
honeymarks2012
Wedding: 5/26/2012
verified review
Awesome red velvet cake! posted 6/12/2012

The cake was beautifully decorated and tasted amazing! It was well worth the trip from Brooklyn to Harlem!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
sandersonbree
Wedding: 5/26/2012
verified review
my Blingy Wedding Cake posted 6/11/2012

MY Bling Wedding Cake was the the talk on how gorgeous it was and soooooo delicious it tasted. i had a beautiful 3 tier round buttercream cake with rhinestone banding and 3 rhinestone initials. it was sooo gorgeous. go here you will not be disappointed

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
bennyjay
Wedding: 12/31/2011
verified review

These ladies can make a cake, man! You can book an appointment to review their designs and taste cake options - it's free (unless you dither and come back a second time, which they'll rightly charge you for, but why on earth would you do that? Best deal in town, with the best cake.) We chose a butter cake with buttercream icing and a pineapple coconut filling - it was light and yummmmmmy and the perfect dessert after our rich & saucy Chinese banquet. Make My Cake will customize every little thing about your cake, they're flexible with designs and flavors, and can deliver your cake right to your reception venue on the day, so you don't have to worry about it. I wanted to choose the flowers for the cake, so I picked some up and dropped them off at the bakery the day before, trusting to the artistry of these master cake makers. And wow! It was beautiful, elegant and delicious, all set up on the designated cake table and artfully arranged. I highly recommend Make My Cake. Even if you're not getting married, and just want some cake. :)

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
jmcjr18
Wedding: 12/1/2011
verified review

Make My Cake and their staff led by Miss Jo-Ann Baylor made us feel welcome from the second we walked in. As a same sex couple this was something that weighed heavily on our minds. Those ladies never batted an eye and made us feel so special to have chosen them to make our cake. The design direction was simple and elegant and the cake that we walked into was beyond my wildest dreams- perfection! Classic elegance. Everyone raved about how beautiful it looked. Then the biggest test of all, the taste....sublime! My mother (a baker) first words were this is homeade cake...this is no ordinary bakery cake. Frosting was sweet but not sugary and Miss Baylor's addition of the Grand Marnier brushed on the layers was excellent. We chose a yellow butter cake, with raspberry jam and Vanilla buttercream- a perfect combination. The guests raved and went back for seconds and thirds! The #1 compliment was that everyone was thrilled to not see or eat a fondant covered cake! I never realized I was in the majority of people who can't stand that stuff and peel it away! Real buttercream icing wins the day! Make My Cake, made my day, made many friends in the NYC gay community and made me a loyal customer for life!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
ycolemon
Wedding: 9/4/2010
verified review
The cake was tasty! posted 9/22/2010

Everyone loved this cake. It was a very good and a great value. They have a special for smaller weddings and we got a cake to feed over 50 people for $175. It was a two tiered cake with no fancy decoration, but the taste made up for it. I have been going to this bakery for about 4 years and have always been happy with the items they sell.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
landa0701
Wedding: 5/14/2010
verified review
My wedding cake!!! posted 9/1/2010

My husband and i were very undecided in what kind of cake and where to go to get the cake. A friend of mine suggested that we try make my cake and it was the best advice that i was given> my husband and I went to make my cake and we fell in love with the people and the cake.Joann helped us pick our cake and decide excatly what it was that we were looking for. Make my cake was the first and last place we looked to get our cake. The cake was beautiful and it tasted as good as it looked. Every guest asked were we got the cake and they couldnt believe how good it was. Thank you Make My Cake, your cake was the perfect ending to the best night of my life

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
lilmomma76
Wedding: 6/25/2010
Pleased customer posted 8/15/2010

It is safe to say that both my husband and myself were extremely pleased with the outcome of our cake. Not only was it absolutely delicious but it was also beautiful.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
Joyedances
Wedding: 6/12/2010
verified review
Absolutely Stunning posted 8/12/2010

We were so pleased with the cake. It looked so much more beautiful that we even imagined and best of all it was so yummy! We had tried more expensive cake vendors but the actually cake did not taste as delicious. Exceptional price, great customer service, with an absolutely stunning cake. We were beyond happy with our cake.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
AronaT30
Wedding: 1/30/2010
African Wedding posted 8/6/2010 (modified 8/6/2010)

I will recommend Make My Cake to all of my friends whether they are getting married or not.
The team at Make Make My Cake are so professional, and they live up to their word. For my wedding the cake was delicious, very pretty, and the delivery was on time at the reception hall. " Hats of to Make My Cake"


Results 1 - 12 of 12
  • 1