• Images
  • Text
  • Find a Couple + Registry
GO
swipe or click to view more
Mansion at West Sayville 5 of 5 1 24

24 total reviews

show reviews by reviewer type:

Results 1 - 20 of 24
avatar
sberg727
Wedding: 6/16/2012
verified review
Great place posted 8/14/2012

I fell in love from the moment I walk through the doors! The house is s pretty and was just what I was looking for my wedding day! It overlooks the water/bay/marina which is so breathtaking and romantic during sunset. Everyone was so helpful and even when we had some wedding day glitches, they were easily remedied with ease. They work hard for you and are wonderful people! Food is great! Place is beautiful! I highly recommend!!!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
vanifranisani
Wedding: 10/19/2012
verified review
I'd Do It All Over Again! posted 11/26/2012 (modified 11/28/2012)

After looking at several locations and comparing prices, my now husband and I decided to stay 'close to home' and wed at WSCC. Having grown up together in the town, it seemed to only make sense to get married there.

We never imagined how absolutely perfect this decision could have been for us. The manager, Steve, was always available to answer my questions throughout the entire planning process. The rest of the staff was very friendly and helpful on the day-of, too! The bridal attendant absolutely knows what she is doing and she's by your side at every moment when you might (and don't realize) you need her.

All the guests raved about the food (I highly recommend the Chicken Voldastano as an entree option). I even had a guest who is very particular about wedding venue food tell me that they had some of the best he'd ever tasted.

The liquor is top shelf, we were able to supply a recipe for a 'signature drink' and we upgraded our beer selection to Bluepoint so we could include some seasonal offerings (Pumpkin and Octoberfest), since we were married in October. For the bride and groom, the staff makes sure that you have a few minutes to actually sit and eat your own meal, and your drink glass was never empty. Our bridal party remarked that even they felt like VIP's any time they were at the bar or needed something.

As for my ceremony: Due to circumstances not within WSCC's control (the weather), my ceremony was moved inside. They gave me up until about four hours before the ceremony to decide where to hold it - and at the final hour, we moved it inside. I was initially weary about this plan as the ceremony took place on the dance floor, which was also in this case the cocktail hour space (cocktail hour was held in the main reception space as well)... but everything flowed so smoothly that you didn't even notice you were continually in the same area.

Another great perk to WSCC is that they are neighbors to the Long Island Maritime Museum - which allows WSCC guests to go over and take photos. Though it was periodically raining and drizzling the entire day, the weather let up just long enough for us to get photos outside, and we walked over to the docks to get some cute bridal party photos. If you're lucky, you can also get a pretty stellar sunset photo.

I'm very happy with our decision to choose WSCC and all of its vendors... I just wish the day hadn't gone so fast! I'd like to do it all over again!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
Mreen23
Wedding: 8/18/2012
verified review
West Sayville Country Club posted 10/3/2012 (modified 10/8/2012)

I highly recommend West Sayville County Club as a wedding venue. It was a pleasure working with Steve, the manager, and Anne Marie, our Maitre'd. Steve was always available in person or through email to answer questions. Anne Marie helped everything run very smoothly and allowed me to have a great time at my wedding.

West Sayville is a beautiful venue. It somehow walks the line between looking like a mansion but feeling warm and cozy. It is a great venue if you are thinking about a vintage theme. We liked that it had a "family feel", but was still very elegant. It felt more "us" than bigger, over-the-top venues we visited. We felt that we could feel comfortable at West Sayville Country Club - and we did!

We have received many compliments on the venue and the food. Our friends and family all had a wonderful time.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
margo1717
Wedding: 10/3/2014
verified review
Amazing Evening posted 10/14/2014

I honestly could not have asked for a better place to have my wedding (10/3/14)- the location was beautiful, the food was great and the evening went off without a hitch. Steve and Ann Marie are fabulous and guests were raving and still are. All of the vendors we used that they suggested were amazing as well. Great place!!

avatar
chopstika515
Wedding: 2/15/2014
verified review
Perfection! posted 8/12/2014

I loved the Mansion at West Sayville. The staff, manager, and maitre'd were all helpful and accommodating. We were able to customize the whole menu if we wanted to, which we did for everything but the entrees.

We had our ceremony and reception there, and the transition between ceremony, cocktail hour, and reception was flawless. The coordinator asked me questions on the fly and did exactly as I instructed immediately. I was so impressed with everything.

If you're not in the mood to be creative, they give you suggestions for vendors and their default menu has so many options.

I personally can't really comment on the food because I didn't get to eat that day...but all the guests said that it was all great and they were impressed with everything.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
Miesje Renier
Wedding: 8/8/2014
verified review
Absolutely PERFECT! posted 8/12/2014

I can't put into words how wonderful our wedding turned out thanks to Steve & Annie at West Sayville! Meadowedge is the perfect venue - from the decor, to the location, to the AMAZING food!

The GM, Steve, is incredibly flexible and helpful. He made sure that our wedding was affordable and that we were getting everything that we could possible hope for.

Annmarie, the MaitreD', made sure that our day went off without a hitch. I would have been lost without her that day!

All of our guests were beyond satisfied with our venue. Family and friends continue to phone us and tell us how wonderful the food and service was.

Thank you Steve & Annie!! If you are contemplating this venue, GO FOR IT!!!

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
Suega
Wedding: 11/9/2013
verified review
Great Place!! posted 12/1/2013 (modified 12/2/2013)

The Mansion at West Sayville was perfect!! Our ceremony had the most beautiful backdrop of the ocean, our cocktail hour was at sunset and the view was spectacular. The Manager Steve, was helpful and very responsive with any questions. Ann Marie was very good about keeping everything on the wedding day on track and on time. All of our guests raved about all the food!.. the steaks were huge and the cocktail hour food was ample and delicious. This place is great.. we truly recommend it if you are looking for an intimate reception place.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
Jennifer Renee Smith
Wedding: 6/30/2013
verified review

This venue has a rustic seaside charm that provides the ideal environment for the DIY/Etsy/Pinterest project-loving bride. Located on a golf course across from Fire Island along the Great South Bay, this restored historic house has recently been renamed The Mansion at West Sayville. I had a wonderful experience working with the staff. I found them to be very helpful and responsive (especially over e-mail), which was key since I planned every detail of the event across the country in Los Angeles. Here are some other aspects I loved about this place:

1)Budget-Friendly. The price you are quoted also includes the (++), which definitely eliminates any surprises. I had my ceremony/reception on a Sunday and they let us pick out any five-hour time slot we wanted. Some places restrict you to windows they've already pre-established, which to me, is limiting.
2) Non-Cookie Cutter Catering Hall. Since it has windows across the entire back wall overlooking a large & lush meadow, you'll always have natural light streaming in, so you’ll never feel as though you’re in a dungeon. You also get your choice in table linens (they have access to a variety of colors), where as most venues give you a choice of only two-three.
3) DIY-Friendly. Steve, the manager and his Maitre’Ds are no strangers to brides coming in a day or two before the wedding with boxes of personal touches and crafts.
4) Beautiful Renovations. They’ve installed a brand new carpet in the dining area, and swapped out the maroon-brown Chiavari chair cushions for a neutral ivory color. But perhaps the biggest change is in the dance floor area. The entire floor is now a gorgeous dark brown wood (no carpet at all!), the ceiling matches the cushions with ivory fabric panels (no more green) and they've expanded and revamped the bar area into an L-shape.
5) Tasty Food. I was shocked over how good the apps and dishes were. We went with the buffet option which I highly recommend.

Service
Quality
Value
avatar
melissasteinmann
Wedding: 9/1/2013
verified review
Great Bridal Shower posted 9/27/2013

My bridesmaids had my bridal shower at the Mansion at West Sayville. It is a beautiful venue and the food was great. The staff was wonderful as well!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
katwardphotos
Wedding: 4/27/2013
verified review

Amazing, attentative staff. Listened to everything I needed and followed through. Extremely helpful manager and maitre'd

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
lalabebed
Wedding: 12/1/2012
verified review
Amazing venue posted 12/18/2012

Wscc was unbelievable! People were blown away by the food service and overall beauty of the venue! They treated us like royalty! It was the best day of our lives!!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
Morgan513
Wedding: 9/28/2012
verified review
Great Venue! posted 11/2/2012

We worked with Steve, and he made the process from start-to-finish completely seamless. He was incredible at responding to emails in a timely manner and he and his time (Annie!) made our big day flow flawlessly. We (and our guests) adored the set up and the team set up our decor perfectly. Would recommend this venue to everyone!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
mkrabba
Wedding: 9/8/2012
verified review
Amazing Venue! posted 9/26/2012

I could not have asked for more in a wedding venue! Steve was incredible helping us plan everything and Annemarie, the Maitre'D was so helpful and competent on the day of, she made the entire day run smoothly and was so easy to work with. The venue is gorgeous and we got nothing but compliments on the food and the place. It's also very reasonably priced, especially for Long Island. Highly recommended!!!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
CollMac17
Wedding: 9/1/2012
verified review
Simply the best. posted 9/13/2012

My husband and I had an amazing day. More importantly my guests praised the staff, such professionalism. Steve helped us through a few sticky family situations 2 days before the wedding. Ann Marie was very helpful and overall made my husband and I feel like a bride and groom. We all had such a great time and lots of fun. I love looking at my photos and reliving the day. I think to myself "absolutely perfect".

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
Skitt100
Wedding: 8/24/2012
verified review
Cute, quaint intimate for not so huge weddings posted 9/10/2012 (modified 9/12/2012)

Loved the atmosphere, and the people there are very helpful and attentive.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
amysmuller
Wedding: 6/8/2012
verified review
Amazing! posted 6/26/2012

Steve - the head guy at West Sayville - is amazing. They were willing to work with us on everything that we needed and wanted. The place is gorgeous and was perfect for our beautiful June wedding. Anne Marie - the maitre d' wsa also incredible.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
ChristineAnnC
Wedding: 7/8/2011
verified review
Better Than I Could Even Imagine posted 10/8/2011 (modified 10/25/2012)

I have to agree with everything everyone already said. WSCC is absolutely amazing. I loved my wedding and it was honestly, better than I ever thought it would be. It's a beautiful old house in a great location. I LOVE the way the room is set up (with the dance floor and bar separated by french doors). Not only is it pretty, but it makes a great party room. The older guests at my wedding were able to talk in the dining room and still be party of the music and dancing. The set up is one of the reasons I choose this place.

Another reason I chose it was the beautiful grounds around it. We planned on getting married on the dock of the maritime museum. Unfortunately, it rained on our wedding day. We needed to do the ceremony inside in the dance floor room, which I really didn't think was going to be so great. I, of course, wanted the water view they would also have to switch the room into the cocktail hour room quickly (that was also going to be outside). Ann Marie did an amazing job with this! The ceremony was beautiful (also thanks to Bayport Flowers) and the transition was very smooth and well organized.

Ann Marie, the maitre d', could not have been more professional, organized, and helpful. She made everything easy for us and we had anything we needed. My husband, his friends, and most of my family all drink Jameson. I had told them this would be a popular choice. At one point during the wedding, a bartender told us they were close to running out. We told Ann Marie we were concerned about it and she told us not to worry, she would fix it. Before we knew it, they were FULLY stocked and we NEVER ran out.

I could probably go on and on about this place. You really can't go wrong. It was a great deal, a gorgeous wedding, and our friends and family can't stop telling us what a great time they had. It really was perfect.

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
supersega1
Wedding: 8/6/2011
verified review
Was perfect posted 9/11/2011

Everything was even better then I expected! The manager and matre d made sure that everything went smoothly! The food was amazing. People are still talking about what a great place and wedding it was!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
mmatero
Wedding: 8/5/2011
verified review
LOVE this Venue posted 8/22/2011

I absolutely LOVED my wedding at West Sayville. Not only was it a GREAT deal, but it was a beautiful venue. There is an old elegance about it that you don't get w/ other venues. Beautiful view of the South Bay and a great maritime museum next door which makes for fun photographs with the bridal party. Steve at West Sayville was wonderful to work with. He gave us a great price for what we wanted and he was always responsive to emails, even when he was out of the office. I can't recommend this place enough. Day of the wedding was low stress, they all know what they're doing over there and you can feel rest assured you're in good hands. All my guests LOVED the wedding.

If you are hesitant because the dance floor is separated from the dining room by french doors - don't be!! Everyone had a great time and it was not an issue at all.

Definitely check this place out!!

Quality
Service
Value
avatar
JessB710
Wedding: 7/10/2011
verified review
couldn't be happier posted 7/26/2011

My experience at the West Sayville Country Club was excellent! The people were extremely helpful and professional throughout the planning and on the day of my wedding. They truly went above and beyond! The food was delicious and the Country Club was beautiful inside and out! I couldn't be happier with every aspect of my wedding day!

Quality
Service
Value

Results 1 - 20 of 24

Mansion at West Sayville

Experience a private club atmosphere, in a restored 1909 mansion on the Great South Bay. Enjoy our lavish glass enclosed patio, perfect for cocktails and hors d'oeuvres.


  • Price Range: $$
  • Amenities: Indoor Ceremony Area, Kosher Available, Liability Insurance, Liquor License, On the Water, Onsite Catering, Onsite Parking, Onsite Wedding Consultant, Outdoor Ceremony Area, Outdoor Reception Area, Valet Parking, Wheelchair Accessible
  • Capacity: Up to 200
  • Style: Banquet/Reception Hall, Country Club

awards and affiliations

  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2013The Knot Best Of Weddings 2013