26 total reviews
Their cake tastes like giant eagle...at best! Anyone who says how good it is, doesn't know good food!!!
We ordered our wedding cake from Pastries a-la-Carte recently. It was very beautiful and delicious, exactly what we wanted. They were very professional when we met with them for our tasting. This was the only bakery that gave us our own whole cake to taste and take home with us. A lot of bakeries just gave us dried, small pieces of cake for a tasting. They were comparable in overall price to the other bakeries I received quotes from. However, they were also the only bakery that was able to include all of our servings in one large three-tier cake, rather than back up sheet cakes. To purchase the same size of three-tier cake from many other bakeries in the area, we would've had to pay almost twice the price or choose a very small three-tier cake for the same price of the large, beautiful one we bought from Pastries a-la-Carte. The cake was also delicious and very well balanced. If you don't want something made from a mix or overly sweet icing, this is the bakery for you.
Pastries a la Carte was the first bakery that we visited in our wedding search—it was so early at that point that I wanted to wait and shop around—but after 3 months of scattered interviewings and tastings, I had to admit that nothing, and I mean nothing, could top them.
Due to the pretty hefty cake cutting fee at our venue, we decided to go with gourmet cupcakes, and Pastries a la Carte's cupcakes most definitely did not disappoint. They were enormous and incredibly delicious, and they came in flavors that suited everyone at the wedding! We went with their coconut/pineapple, optical illusion, red velvet, and s'mores flavors (and let me tell you I ate at least one of each the morning after the wedding:) ). They also baked our beautiful wedding cake, which was a 2 tiered round. We'd asked them to write one of our favorite book quotes around it--the cake looked and tasted delicious, and went perfectly with our theme!
Kathy was also incredibly accommodating--even though she had limited experience baking vegan, she made 2 dozen vegan salted caramel cupcakes for our vegan guests that tasted just as good as the non-vegan cupcakes! Plus her team wrapped each individual cupcake in special book page cupcake wraps that we'd prepared--the finished product looked like a Pinterest photo!!
We rented and returned their stands for the cupcakes without a problem, and the way they set everything up for the big day was flawless. Not to mention their prices are unbeatable!
I 100% recommend them--definitely the tastiest part of our big day :)
My initial experience was having a spy cake made from a picture I had found online for a birthday in July. They did a really nice job on it and the kids loved it-- so when I wanted a unique Star Wars groom's cake for my wedding, I went there first! Kathy and Donna were phenomenal. Not only were they extremely friendly and professional, they were able take a random picture from online and make it a reality. The cake turned out perfect and was a big hit at the wedding! In addition, I purchased a variety of specialty cookies and pastries that were absolutely delicious! Huge RAVE for Pastries A La Carte! I am extremely impressed and would recommend them to anyone. Thank you again, Kathy and Donna!
Cake was delicious and looked fantastic!!!!
We purchased trays of Pastries a la Carte's fancy wedding cookies for the late evening snack at our daughter's wedding reception last weekend. They were simply outstanding. They were beautifully and intricately decorated, used her wedding accent color beautifully, and tasted amazing. The variety within the wedding assortment included quite a few different kinds of cookies. We received many compliments from our guests and thoroughly enjoyed them ourselves.
Pastries ala Carte came highly recommended, and we were very pleased with our experience. Our tasting was free and 4 of us got to sample a very nice variety of cakes. They had tons of pictures to show and came up with drawings right there, based on what we described that we wanted. Their cake tasted incredible. We got buttercream icing, the cake itself was moist and we had a layer of raspberry - to die for. On our wedding day, the cake looked exactly how I wanted it to, and it tasted amazing -- plus the price was more than reasonable.
I also ordered our groom's cake, which was very good but they didn't follow my instruction entirely, so I had to unfortunately sacrifice some of the design that was initially agreed upon. It still looked nice, but wasn't what we discussed and therefore wasn't as customized as I hoped. However, despite that I would highly recommend Pastries ala Carte; their value, quality and taste was everything we were looking for - and it photographed great! Plus, the owners, The Battis', are very easy to work with!
Perfect cake! It was so gorgeous! Guest raved about how good it was! The flowers looked beautiful on it! Everything was so perfect about our cake! Definitely would recommend to everyone!
Our wedding cake was beyond AMAZING!! I saw a Bling Cake on their facebook page and knew that was the one. They do outstanding work and the cake tasted great too!! I highly recommend them!
Pastries a la Carte is by far the best place in Pittsburgh to order your wedding cake from!!! I ordered a cake from them for my Bridal Shower first which was in July and it was the most beautiful and best tasting cake I had ever had!! After that there was no question that I wanted to get the cake for our wedding there too! And believe me.. again, they did not disappoint! Our cake was not only beautiful and looked exactly like I hoped it would... it tasted amazing! We got the white almond cake with raspberry filling.. yumm!!! I can't even tell you how many people at the wedding said, "I don't even like cake, but that cake was delicious!" That certainly made me feel good! So thank you very much Pastries a la Carte!!!
We actually found the flavors and design of our cake at another bakery but there service was so horrible that we didn't bother going back. Pastries a la Carte not only made us a custom wedding cake from the flavors we found at the other bakery, but they made a very similar design that we just loved! Their customer service was fantastic, even after our wedding. My husband and I spent all that time picking the perfect cake...but at our wedding the only taste we got was during the cutting of the cake. We went back to Pastries a la Carte and explained that we wanted a small cake just for us so that we could enjoy it. They made us another small cake and it was delicious!!! We loved working with Pastries a la Carte and would recommend anyone to visit their bakery. (For the price, we did have cake for 250 people)
The Georgetown Centre included my cake and pastries a la carte was one of my choices. I had planned on using them for my cake anyway because I love their cake. The cake was beautiful and just what I wanted! It tasted delicious.
Exactly what we wanted...Delicious
I cannot thank Pastries A La Carte enough for the amazing job they did on our beautiful wedding cake and matching cupcakes! Our guests were floored! Delicious, beautiful, and arranged so well. Visiting the vendor was a simple process...they walked us through our options, showed us a portfolio of past designs, and let us try as much as we wanted! I would recommend them to anyone and everyone!
Cake tasted GREAT! It looked how I wanted to, however I never actually got to speak to the baker like I requested. She avoided me and my phone calls
The cake and cupcakes were delicious!
The cake was part of the Gold Package at the Youghiogheny Country Club. It was fantastic! I wish we would have ordered the Alfies Icing, tho... The presentation was great! It was more beautiful than I imagined. The staff did their absolute best to give me the highest quality without the upcharges.
We had a red velvet cake with cream cheese filling and butter cream frosting - our guest were RAVING about it! Most people will comments on a cake being too sweet, too dry....but we heard non-stop positive feedback on our cake. It was DELICIOUS and looked beautiful. Highly recommend Pastries A La Carte. Great service and price!
I am not a cake person but I was told the Dark Chocolate Fudge cake we had was delicious by many guests. I liked that the icing wasnt too sweet and the cake was moist. The cake was included with our recption venue so I have no complaints. It looked like the picture I had chosen from but they are willing to do details to your specifications too.
I usually do not like wedding cake because it is dried out. This cake was not dry! It was so good!
Report Abuse Policy
If you have any documentation proving it false, please send it to firstname.lastname@example.org. We will review your request in the order it was received.
You can expect to receive a response within 5 business days.
Thank you for reporting your review.
Our policy is to only take down reviews that contain spam, explicit content or are proven to be factually false; we cannot dispute a bride’s opinion. We will review your request in the order it was received.
You can expect to receive a response within 5 business days.