73 total reviews
Its almost a month after our wedding and we are still hearing about how wonderful our wedding reception was... The Columbus Athenauem was the perfect venue for our perfect wedding reception.
We rented the Oak Room at TCA. The room has gorgeous woodwork and was more than enough space for our 205 guests. The day of our wedding the room looked gorgeous with the linens, centerpieces, and all of it...
Working with TCA has been wonderful. I was planning our wedding from afar, so the fact that it was kind of a "one-stop" shop was really a blessing. Ann at the Athenaeum was awesome to work with. She was able to provide us with ample information to make an informed decision about our wedding reception and really guided us through planning, to make the perfect event. The food tasting was phenomenal... so much food... and it was so good and we felt confident that the food on our wedding day would be perfect for our guests. The days leading up to the event, I was in good order, thanks to Ann. Details were worked out. Food was ordered.... everything done in a timely manner, so I could focus on other things.
The day of the event was perfect. The room looked impeccable. The food was delicious and a fun time was had by all. A 6-year old cousin raved that the water served from the bartender was the best he'd ever had. I've had really big, burly guys tell me how much they enjoyed their salad at dinner. I've had people tell me it was the best food they've ever had at a wedding.... and people cannot stop talking about the fun they had and how much they enjoyed the venue.
If I had to do it all over again... I'd do it the same way. I wouldn't change a thing.
Thank you all for your hard work and for hosting our perfect event!
The Columbus Athenaeum was the perfect fit for us. We couldn't have been happier with it. Our reception was in the large theater. The room itself was so beautiful and really had the wow factor we were looking for. The food was incredible. Our guests said that it was the best wedding food they had ever had. Most of them are still talking about it. Gina was incredible. She worked so well with us and really helped us achieve exactly what we wanted. One of the things I loved most of all was that almost everything was included. They took care of our centerpieces, and additional decorations, food, drinks, linens, and tables and chairs. We didn't have to go through a bunch of different places and it was all quality stuff. They didn't try to nickle and dime us as we found with many places. They were open and honest with us from the beginning about prices. It really was perfect! Thanks to the Athenaeum I can look back at my wedding day and have no regrets.
We worked with Trisha and then Danielle at the Athenaeum and had great experiences with both. They each were very responsive via email and helped us as we planned a wedding from out of town. On the wedding day, Danielle and other employees seemed dedicated to making our event a success. Everyone enjoyed the food and loved the space. We got married in the Priory - lovely spot for a wedding - and had the reception in the Oak Room. All we heard from the guests were compliments on the venue and the service. We would recommend the Athenaeum to others in Columbus for sure!
I am so glad that my coworker recommended that I book the Athenaeum for my wedding. The prices were fair, especially for the quality of service and product, and the food was amazing. I had guests coming up to me during the reception and commenting that it was the best food they had ever had at a wedding - the station package with the mashed potato bar is a must! We had our ceremony in the Priory with the reception in the Small Theater - definitely great to have them right across the hall from each other, given that the majority of our guests were from out of town, so almost zero travel time between ceremony and reception. Also, if you ask, they can give you wi-fi for the day if you need to Skype the wedding to those who can't be there (we had to for my mother-in-law, who was in the hospital).
Would definitely recommend!
The Athenaeum was the 2nd venue that we saw and I was instantly sold on the Olympian Ballroom. The room has such a dramatic feel. I loved that the cocktail hour is in the balcony to oversee the ballroom. The room looked amazing! I couldn't say more positive things about the Athenauem! We had the best experience here which made our wedding day perfect! Ann Clark helped us throughout the wedding planning process. She did an amazing job with everything. Ann helped set up our wedding timeline that coordinated with the DJ and photographer. We ran a little behind on some the entrances and dances but she worked hard to keep us moving. I absolutely loved every minute of our reception with the help of Ann. HIGHLY recommend having any event here!!
We ran across the Athenaeum at a local bridal show and by change my husband was familiar with it because he had been to an even their previously. Danielle explained the different rooms & prices for a Friday wedding so we set an appointment immediately.
When we went for our meeting with TCA our consultant was Anne Smith. She made sure to sit with us so that she best understood what our expectations & budget was for our wedding & then proceeded to walk us through the venue to all of their event rooms. The moment we saw the Large Theatre room we absolutly fell in love with it. It was so different than anything we had ever seen before. On top of the unique venue the prices for our Friday wedding were next to unbeatable for the type of wedding we were wanting. We booked our venue within a week of meeting with Ann.
Throughout the entire process (November-August) Ann stayed in contact with us, making sure we stayed on our time lines & if we needed any help. She was really great to work with.
Now that our wedding has come & gone I can tell you this.. TCA helped us throw our dream wedding. The large Theatre room was stunning, the lighting was beautiful, the center pieces (they provided) were beautiful, everything that we brought was set up perfectly & we have received compliments almost daily on how great the food was! Not only that but we did this by staying at a reasonable budget!
My only compliants with TCA would be: The room was extremely hot during rehearsal & we were told it would be better the next day for our wedding & I don' believe that it was. We had several of our guests comment on how hot it was in the room & they would step outside to get fresh air and would miss something going on inside.
Ann Clark was my wedding consultant and she did a great job helping me plan out all the details in a stress-free,kind and professional manner. The great thing about this venue is they cater everything (delicious!) and the rooms are so nice, I barely needed to add any decorations (just flowers). I would say that it's smart to designate someone or some people to help carry out and load gifts, etc at the end of the night because it was somewhat chaotic. Otherwise, this place is amazing. They do a ton of weddings and clearly know what they're doing.
The Athenaeum was the FIRST reception location my husband and I scouted…we decided on it that day! We held our reception in the Olympian Ballroom it was everything we could have hoped for and more! From the delicious catering, to the seamless transitioning from one part of the reception to the next, the Athenaeum goes above and beyond to ensure that your event is stress free and is EXACTLY what you wanted. The decor, parking, and loading/unloading of everything was all done with complete ease. The Athenaeum knows how to throw a gorgeous wedding, their service is impeccable and I couldn't imagine having held my reception anywhere else. Danielle L. also deserves very special mention for all of the hard work she didn't coordinating and planning our event…she truly made the entire process a joy! Holly P.
My wedding reception was in the small theatre, and the athenaeum was absolutely fabulous. The venue itself is beautiful, and they set up all of the decorations for you. Although I was a little concerned that we had to cater through them, the dinner and desserts were delicious! They have several different packages (very flexible in what they include) that are great for most budgets. My event manager, Gina, met with us several times to make sure we had all the details decided on, and then they took it from there. The Athenaeum was a great, hassle-free reception venue!
At my first meeting with Ann, I was very impressed with her attention to detail and how she made me feel like my wedding was important to her. She followed up with me and invited me to one of their food tastings. I looked at 2 other venues and I felt that the Athenaeum had the best first impression and was the best value.
I booked the venue about 16 months ahead of time and throughout the whole process, the Athenaeum walks you through everything. We met pretty early on to go over details and at that meeting we established a lot of the planning. It was very helpful for me so that I could communicate everything to my other vendors.
Ann took excellent notes and didn't miss a beat! I was very impressed on how she got every detail right and I didn't have to question her because everything was laid out in front of me on our banquet event order. Of course there were small changes made in the several months leading up to the wedding, and every single change was noted and updated in a timely fashion. I never doubted their abilities to pull off a successful event.
During the wedding, Ann was there to direct guests and to ensure we had everything we needed. We had a room for the bridesmaids and I to relax right before the ceremony. They watched the clock for us and let us know when it was time. Everything was just as we had discussed and there were no problems. It's clear that the staff at the Athenaeum are professionals in the business. The service they provided was exceptional!
The reason for the 4 star on quality was mainly because of one of our entrees. We had 2 entrees that we had tried at the food tasting so I knew what we were having at dinner. We served chicken beurre blanc and london broil with bordelaise sauce. At our tasting, the london broil blew my taste buds away but at our wedding, it didn't taste the same nor as good. I was a little disappointed because I was so looking forward to eating it again! But on the flip side, the chicken beurre blanc tasted better than I had remembered so I was happy with that. I even ate my husband's chicken!
The other thing that gave the quality a 4 star were the uplights in our reception room. I added purple gels to the uplights to create more of a purple glow to the room. Either the gels weren't that great or the uplights because you could barely see the purple. Minor detail that I noticed moreso in the pictures because I wanted that purple in the background.
Honestly, I could not have asked for a more perfect wedding. The stage at our reception was perfect for our special dance performance and I think everything about the venue made our day more special. There are a few important things when it comes to your wedding and venue is probably number 1 and based off the experience I had with the Athenaeum, I would not hesitate to recommend this venue to anyone. They did a wonderful job and being a bit of an OCD bride, all the details were perfect!
great service and coordination! Gina is fantastic! Food is delicious ... we would highly recommended the mash potato bar.
The rooms are more beautiful in person than online, you must schedule a tour here. We used the Large Theater for both our ceremony and reception because it was so original. We worked with Trisha, and she was there as much as we needed, which was super helpful. I originally didn't want a wedding planner, but having her there for suggestions and support was priceless. I would absolutely recommend TCA again, they are fabulously attentive to detail and their deadlines give you one less thing to worry about because you know that they're taking care of it.
Overall, we had a really great experience with The Athenaeum. To start, the venue is simply gorgeous. We had a reception of 200 people in the Olympian Ballroom. It truly is a room and venue like no other. So much history. So much romance and classic elegance. Our reception turned out STUNNING. Ann was great to work with and the staff at TCA was wonderful. The staff the day of (along with Ann!) were just fabulous. They made you feel so great, and one thing everyone told me before my wedding day was to "Make sure you eat dinner!" well, TCA makes sure you do. They bring you a plate of food, appetizers, drinks, their level of customer service was spectacular especially during that night of!
The Columbus Athenaeum was one of the first venues that we saw and visited when we started planning. We were really interested in the "all-inclusiveness" of their services. Add that to the gorgeous historic building and we were sold. Honestly, I couldn't have been more happy with how our reception went, the level of service the Athenaeum provided and the helpfulness of the event coordinator that we worked with (Ann Clark).
Planning: The planning process was really helped by our coordinator. Ann was available to answer all of our questions (in a timely manner!), provide suggestions and really help us create the flow of our reception as we were DIYers with no Wedding Planner or DOC. Throughout the planning process we made numerous changes (even some last minute) and she was very accommodating and interested in us having the day that we wanted.
Food: While we loved the idea of an onsite caterer, I was a little bit worried about what the quality of food would be. We were able to attend a tasting where they had a buffet set-up with a lot of the variety of HDVs, entree's and deserts. Literally there was SO MUCH food at the tasting- and it was totally yummy! This put my worries to rest. The night of, the food was still great- big portions, fresh veggies and great temperature (we did a plated meal). We actually missed our cocktail hour due to photos, but the staff was nice enough to have a little bit of everything at our head table when we sat down for dinner- everything was great
Overall we had a wonderful experience with the Athenaeum although the change to the alcohol policy wasn't favorable to customers. We also had an issue with the bartenders not replenishing liquor as promised which we did not find out about until about a week following the wedding. The venue was beautiful and Anne was helpful throughout the entire process. Other than the issue with the alcohol the event went off without issue.
Once I walked into the Olympian Ballroom, I knew that is where I wanted our reception to be. We had a guest list of just over 300 people (only about 190 attended) and that was the best room in Columbus I had found (for a great price). We got engaged end of October and married in August, so with a short timeline, I wasn't sure if we were going to find the best place. Trisha was amazing from the second we met with her on our very first tour, to the day she called me and told me they had an opening in the ballroom for the month I wanted it.
Trisha paid attention to all the details and made sure everything was great for us. She gave honest opinions (which I am a huge fan of) and didn't try to "sell" us on anything.
The only downside to this venue (and most all others) is that you don't get to taste the food before you book the room. However, my husband's grandmother is still talking about how the prime rib she had at our wedding was the best she has had in her lifetime (she still talks about it to us when we see and its been almost 2 months!). The strawberry salad dressing was one of my favorites (one of the many great suggestions by Trisha) and people were going up for seconds.
We knew people that had not gone with this venue because of their lack of a liquor license. However, they have a liquor license now, and it is great - you only buy how much alcohol you want to be consumed! I hated looking at other venues and how the only option was to pay per person. At the Athenaeum, we were able to buy as much beer & wine (we did not do liquor) that we thought our family & friends would consume. They even said that if there is any left over, that we could have taken it home with us. We ordered the perfect amount and there was no alcohol left over (we did ask them to save a bottle of red & white wine for us to keep).
I personally did not like any of the ceremony rooms, so we did our ceremony elsewhere. This is a great place for a reception though - especially for the price, we were VERY happy with this venue.
Thanks again for a memorable evening!
We booked the Athenaeum about one year before we got married, and worked with Ann Clark to plan our dream reception. She made the entire process go smoothly, from choosing linens to picking out our dinner choices. The Olympic Ballroom was absolutely beautiful, and we could not have asked for a better experience. We would highly recommend the Columbus Athenaeum to other couples!
When I was seeking a venue for my September wedding, the Athenaeum surpassed every expectation I had with their venue. The inclusions of catering, tables and chairs, centerpieces, the ability to have both our ceremony and reception in the same building, all contributed to my decision to hold my wedding there. We had the ceremony in the Priory, which had the look of a cathedral with the feel of an intimate ceremony and the reception in the Small Theater across the hall, which was such a beautiful room that decorations were hardly needed. The planning process went smoothly, Trisha Morris was my coordinator and made it very easy for me to plan from a distance. I was very impressed by the ease of the event on the day, things ran seamlessly and I could tell that the staff was well practiced. The food was excellent, all of my guests were complimenting it throughout the night. The only part that may have been slightly off was making sure we were out in the allotted amount of time at the end of the night but we didn't feel rushed or pushed out, but the deadline is pretty set in stone so if you're looking to be able to have your event taper off whenever it naturally does so this is something to keep in mind.
Overall our experience here blew me away, the space looked amazing and really represented me and my husband as a couple. The Athenaeum also recommended vendors for us which was very helpful since we were not familiar with what was available in the Columbus area. I highly recommend this venue for anyone who loves architecturally interesting spaces, delicious food, and top-notch customer service.
We loved having our wedding at the Columbus Athenaeum! The venue is gorgeous and all of our guests could not stop talking about how amazing the food was!
Pros: Our wedding was gorgeous, beautiful and elegant. Our wedding coordinator was wonderful and I loved working with her! She was prompt in responses and always tried to be available when I came to town as I was an out of town bride. The food tasting was delicious and very well done. We had a cookie table, which is not the most convenient addition to a reception. The coordinator worked really hard to give us what we were looking for, and the cookie table was the highlight of the evening! The food was delicious, and we heard wonderful comments from all of our guests about how beautiful our reception was.
Cons: We were one of the "unlucky" ones who booked The Athenaeum before they acquired a liquor license. When we met with them initially they raved about how cost effective it was to be able to get alcohol outside the venue. We booked with them with this in mind with our budget. A few months down the road we hear they had acquired a liquor license and we were now legally bound to order through them. We had already found another vendor for our alcohol, but still had to use them. It seems strange they had no idea they were getting a liquor license when we signed the contract. When we met with our coordinator we found out that management was not going to provide any additional "accommodations" for the inconvenience of the change. We then learned that we would not be able to keep OR sell back any unopened liquor we hadn't drank but had already paid for. This seems very unethical to keep liquor WE PAID FOR and sell it at a higher cost to other wedding parties at another date. We also were not able to take home any of the DELCIOUS food left over from our wedding. I know many couples who were able to do this after their reception with other venues. Again, another way The Columbus Athenaeum failed on customer service. My father had spoken to management at one point during the alcohol issue and the man was defensive from the beginning of the conversation and wouldn't listen to his comments. We weren't looking for free alcohol, just additional services for the inconvenience of changing the policy after we signed a contract.
Overall, the Athenaeum is a beautiful venue, serves amazing food and we had an amazing time. Their policies are fairly extreme, and management is a pain, but their staff are wonderful and accommodating as much as they can be. Brides, just know the policies WELL before you sign any contracts!
Report Abuse Policy
If you have any documentation proving it false, please send it to [email protected]. We will review your request in the order it was received.
You can expect to receive a response within 5 business days.
Thank you for reporting your review.
Our policy is to only take down reviews that contain spam, explicit content or are proven to be factually false; we cannot dispute a bride’s opinion. We will review your request in the order it was received.
You can expect to receive a response within 5 business days.
Historical architecture and a downtown location provide the setting for a wedding to remember. From our grand ballroom to our century-old Gothic wedding chapel, the Athenaeum offers a dozen rooms of varying size and décor. We also offer an extensive menu that can be tailored to your needs.
- Price Range: $$
- Amenities: Indoor Ceremony Area, Kosher Available, Liquor License, Onsite Catering, Onsite Parking, Valet Parking, Wheelchair Accessible
- Capacity: More than 400
- Style: Banquet/Reception Hall, Mansion/Historic Site, Unusual/Alternative
awards and affiliations
- The Knot Best Of Weddings 2013
- The Knot Best Of Weddings 2011
- The Knot Best Of Weddings 2010