• Images
  • Text
  • Find a Couple + Registry
GO
711 Smithtown Bypass Smithtown, NY map | (631) 724-3242
| www.watermillcaterers.com
swipe or click to view more
WATERMILL CATERERS 5 of 5 1 46

3 featured reviews

Results 1 - 3 of 3
  • 1
avatar

Wedding: 1/3/2014
Member Since: 1/27/2010
fabulous!    posted 1/20/2014 (modified 1/21/2014)

I am SO glad we chose the Watermill for our venue. We got married January 3, 2014. Everything was PERFECT. It was still decorated for Christmas which made our pictures even better. The place was beautiful. I got so many compliments about how much food they served, and it was delicious! Our captain, bridal attendant and maitre D were fabulous! I would definitely recommend the Watermill for your venue. Also, the prices were amazing!!!

avatar

Wedding: 11/3/2013
Member Since: 8/6/2008
Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!    posted 12/3/2013 (modified 12/4/2013)

I can’t even begin to explain how much I loved the Watermill. We had seen a few venues and had pretty much decided on one but we already had an appointment with Watermill so my husband said we might as well go check it out especially because we weren’t absolutely thrilled with our choice. I’ll be honest, I was a little hesitant since it was so far for most of our friends and family but I agreed. The second we pulled up we both got this feeling. It was like it was our place. I never thought I’d feel that way about a reception hall but I did and best of all DH did as well which was totally unexpected. We were shown the Carnegie chapel for the ceremony and Astor Suite for the reception and we fell in love the chapel immediately and knew we were meant to be married there. We went back to the car but immediately called and said hold our date we want to be married at Watermill. I couldn’t have been happier with our choice. The grounds are beautiful the staff is amazing. The food is TO DIE FOR!!!!!!!!!!!! We were very lucky and got to deal with both Bob and Roy as our BMs and they were both the best. Roy is my new best friend (lol) They both really seemed to care about us and our wedding and we felt very comfortable with them. The day of our Maitre D was Bryan who was super sweet and very on the ball without being bossy or anything. Our captain was Brendan and he was great as well. Jenn was my bridal attendant and I LOVED HER!!!!!!!!!! She was amazing and also just seemed to really care about us and making me happy and comfortable. Our guests are still talking about how wonderful everything was and how delicious the food was. Watermill made our dream wedding come true and we can't thank them enough!!!

avatar

Wedding: 11/8/2013
Member Since: 6/16/2012
Amazing!    posted 11/25/2013 (modified 11/26/2013)

I had my wedding at the Watermill a few weeks ago and I am thrilled with everything. Everything was amazing and the service was unbelievable. Everyone was raving about how beautiful it was and how great the food was. There was so much of it! The staff truly went above and beyond to make sure my day was so special and I am so happy I chose the Watermil!


Results 1 - 3 of 3
  • 1

The Watermill

This magnificent catering establishment is unsurpassed in providing world-class cuisine and service in elegant, natural and hand-crafted surroundings. As a Scotto Family tradition, you and your guests can count on enjoying the very best of everything as you celebrate your new beginning.


  • Price Range: $$$
  • Outdoor Ceremony Area: Yes
  • Indoor Ceremony Area: Yes
  • Outdoor Reception Area: Yes
  • On the Water: No
  • Tented Area: No
  • Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
  • Onsite Catering: Yes
  • Outside Caterers Allowed: No
  • Kosher Available: No
  • Liquor License: Yes
  • Onsite Overnight Accommodations: No
  • Onsite Parking: Yes
  • Valet Parking: Yes
  • Onsite Wedding Consultant: Yes
  • Liability Insurance: No
  • Site Fee: No
  • Capacity: More than 400
  • Style: Banquet/Reception Hall

WATERMILL CATERERS's twitter