Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop

were just right; and all for a great price. Our only disappointment was the top layer (with the flavor combo we were most excited about) went too quickly that we didn't get a chance to try it. We would highly recommend Aggie's for Milwaukee area weddings - and don't skip on their other tasty bakery treats, too!

loved it! The other trouble, our cake was supposed to be ready for pick up at 8am that day, we arrived at 2pm ish, already running late and the cake wasn’t done. Staff were very nice and gave us complimentary snacks and coffee to have while we waited. They also offered money back when I let them know our cake was wrong but I didn’t want to make them do that. I will still go back, it happens and the cake was still amazing!

nsultation , my husband and I were afraid our requests would be too over the top for them to handle but boy did they deliver !! We wanted a three tier cake … each a different flavor , one frosting to compliment each different cake and of course I wanted this cake to be wrapped in sheer minimalist decor . We were so pleased with our cake !! Thank you so much Aggie’s for making our day and stomachs feel so magical!

visualize the size of the cake you're ordering. We went over a variety of combinations and pricing, so it was easy to come up with an option that fit our budget and guest count. The best thing was I didn't feel like we were overspending for the type of cake I wanted compared to other bakers we looked at. We also got a bunch of donuts, which were a hit! The cake looked and tasted amazing, we couldn't have been happier. We even will recieve a 6" 1 year anniversary cake so we never had to freeze the top (we brought it with on our honeymoon instead). Overall, it was the easiest experience and probably one of the best vendors we worked with.

nt than the traditional cake option for our wedding.

. We never even thought about that, so very thankful they suggested placing it in a different location until it was ready to be served. They even positioned the cake topper. Slicing and serving the cake was easy and it held up very well throughout the day! Taste, customer service, and knowing we were getting a quality product is why we gave this establishment 5 stars. We have no complaints, only compliments

're gone in minutes! Our cake was exactly what we wanted, and delivery on the day of was perfect.

and we went with equally delicious mini-pies as our late night snack that were to die for!

ing about wedding cakes within thier shop away from the bakery counter and thier tasting selection was excellent. We ordered a white 4 tiered wedding cake with each layer having a different flavor. The cheesecake here is also excellent, beating out another well-known bakery in the area on both flavor and price. They were very flexible when we had to postpone our wedding due to Covid (no additional fees or hike in price). We had countless people ask us who made our cake at the reception which looked and tasted amazing. Would definitely use again!

beat the reasonable prices. We have yet to go to a wedding that had better cake than ours ;) Thank you Aggie's for the awesome experience!

for the couple'. Very reasonably priced, delicious and attractive work. Ask for Rachel. She's terrific to work with!

the moon with our cake. Thank you Aggie’s❤️ Wish I could post a picture of how beautiful it was

nk you again Aggie’s!

r friends so we decided to check them out. Their tasting has to be one of the smartest ways to sample cake that we have ever seen! It was so cool! They brought out a plate of all of their different cake flavors and then small cups of each frosting flavor so that you could mix and match the cakes and frostings however you would like. My husband and I had so much fun exploring different combinations and ended up choosing a variety of cupcake options as we could not decide on a favorite. It was sooo much cake to sample–luckily they let us bring the leftovers home! When it came to our wedding day, the cake and cupcake display looked beautiful and everyone raved about how delicious it was. We love that Aggies also offers to give you a cake on your anniversary so that you don’t have to worry about freezing it for a whole year. We can’t wait to stop back at the shop next June and relive our memories of our special day!

he traditional cake vibe! (they also offer cakes that are amazing, but we just didn't go that route)

s absolutely Delicious! Guests were calling me weeks after the wedding asking me where we order our cake from and what kind of cheesecakes we had because they wanted to order one for themselves. I am now a regular customer for Aggie’s because I received Delicious cake and cheesecakes along with great, professional, and friendly service. All that for affordable prices as well. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND AGGIE’S Bakery for your Wedding Day!

wedding day. The reason for my 3 star review was the communication in the few months before the big day was challenging and the tiered cake on the day of did not match my original vision (color and shape were a little off). Rachel was extremely gracious and professional and acknowledged the differences, which was much appreciated. Our cake was so tasty, which honestly is the most important part!

s seamless. I didn’t need to worry about anything the day of the wedding. Also absolutely delicious cake! Highly recommend.

cious it was! We are looking forward to ordering from Aggie’s for many more celebrations in the future!

azing! I've recommended Aggie's to everyone since our wedding and will be going back for cake in the future :)

happy to accommodate it. We could not be happier with how our wedding cake turned out and will always recommend Aggie’s! Thank you Aggie’s!

p to the wedding when we needed to adjust our serving count and did not provide much guidance on guest count/number of servings to order. After our wedding, we learned that only 60% of guests eat cake, so we ended up with way too much left over as we ordered one serving for each guest (we were thankfully able to enjoy in the following week) but would have been helpful to have that guidance from Aggies during the ordering process. Overall, we would recommend Aggies for your wedding as the experience was great and the cake turned out perfectly, just some small hiccups in the communication of details in the month of the wedding.

in Aggies

ssle free. We will definitely be coming back for more, especially to see what else they have in store!

eam puffs! We can t recommend them enough!

ality!

other couples!

each estimate would cost us. The cake was moist and fluffy. The fillings and frostings could be mixed and matched as we went about our tasting. They had books and mock-ups in the room with us of previously designed cakes to help us choose the best one for the theme. They also encouraged us to try other bakers - it's like they knew they were the best out there and had confidence in their product. They also feature so many cupcakes and other baked goods for every day or other special occasions. Hands down, we are SO excited and confident that we will have an amazing cake at our wedding.

ut they were just put at the base of the display. Aggie's recommended bakeries to accommodate our guests with allergies, and I really appreciated that. Everything tasted delicious, thanks so much!

amazing, so amazing that by the time I got to our dessert table, it was all gone. Our guests loved it all. Not to mention they are SO affordable! Thank you Aggies- we can’t wait to visit again soon!

orked at Aggie's a month before our wedding when final count and accessories were due. At that time, the process felt unorganized and I was worried my cake wouldn't be delivered. However, the cake was GORGEOUS and exactly how I pictured. It arrived on time and my guests really enjoyed the white cake, along with red velvet. I would recommend Aggie's to anyone!

y be using them again for events in the future.

wonderful. I would highly recommend Aggie's for future events and needs. You won't go wrong hiring Aggie's for your wedding.

our anniversary cake next year!

ere told by our venue that the noticed a small streak on the cake that shouldn't have been there. Aggie's wouldn't accept that as being quality and drove the 30 + minutes back to the bakery to fix the issue and STILL arrive on time with an outstanding cake...that's customer service. We couldn't be happier.

. Maybe too on point because we did not get to try any of the cupcakes. That went away the moment it was served. :)

I'm glad it was recommended that we only do a combination and not a full cheesecake, as the cheesecake started to "melt" a little later in the night. Didn't affect the wonderful taste! The groom and I were initially a little surprised that the coloring/airbrushing was much darker then what we had discussed, especially considering it was documented several times on our design worksheet to have a "hint" or "lightly" done with color, and a picture was attached to our worksheet showing what we wanted . But the only people who would have known that were us the couple :) And in the end, the pictures turned out wonderful, and the taste was AMAZING which is what was truly important to us!

was customized to look like the ocean, to match our themed cake topper, which was such a special touch for our special day.

y responsive and professional which is highly reflective in their cakes and other bakery items.

sultation but they had no problems with that and our cake looked exactly like our inspiration photo. We received SO many comments from family and friends that it was the best wedding cake they have ever had. Highly recommend Aggie’s (and the Oreo buttercream filling!)

could pull it off. And let me tell you, they perfectly executed the cake I have always dreamed of! Our decorator Brian even did some trial "brushstrokes" for our cake design and sent us photos to confirm that we were happy with it before confirming our cake. When I walked into our venue on our wedding day and saw our cake, it took my breath away. It was exactly what I always pictured. Besides the gorgeous way it looked, our cake was SO delicious. The frosting was not overly sweet, and the strawberry cream filling was light and juicy - it didn't taste like fake fruit, and you can tell that the team puts a lot of love into their bakes. One of the reasons we also love Aggie's is their mini desserts - we ordered turtle brownies, cream puffs and key lime tarts and everything was astounding. Aggie's makes it easy to offer multiple desserts for your guests, which is a fun way to mix it up. Working with the team at Aggie's was also just such a delight. Our wedding date kept moving around due to COVID-19, and the team at Aggie's helped us navigate the whole situation with kindness and flexibility, which took out so much of the stress we were already under. Thank you so much for everything, Aggie's, you really made my wedding day dreams come true. You're the best.

pretty elegant touch 🥰

options and helped guide us through popular and broadly appealing combos. They worked with our budget and made us a 2-tier cutting cake as well as a large sheet cake. They also let us pick the color of the cake and executed our vision perfectly. The day of, cake delivery went flawlessly, and guests were raving about how good the cake was. Thank you so much Alex and team for one of the best vendor experiences we had throughout our wedding planning, as well as absolutely delicious cake!

d and tasted amazing! Great price and very easy to work with. They even provided an extra box to take our top tier home and extra buttercream to put on our floral! Would definitely recommend Aggie’s to any bride!

or to our final payment. Overall, a great experience!

gs. They were all delicious!! We ended up doing cake and cupcakes. Alex helped us decide numbers and how many flavors to get, and made sure they would be delivered and set up on time. Our bridal party and all of the guests raved about how good the desserts were, and I so wish we had more to enjoy after! We definitely recommend Aggies!

ny compliments on how yummy our cake was and all the different flavor combos that we could put inside of 1 simple 4 tier cake!! I would hands down recommend Aggies for your wedding cake because they are now my go-to bakery for any special cake I will be ordering in the future!

frosting creamy, which all our guests loved. We also enjoyed the fact that they had a complimentary tasting which allowed us to be confident in our cake and frosting choices. Alex was great to work with and she was quick to respond. She took down our cake vision and made it happen! We highly recommend Aggie's and plan to get bakery items from them in the future!

ch a beautiful, elegant design. Thank you for making our day that much more special!

bakery for our wedding reception. Our cake was constantly complimented throughout the night and could not have been more delicious. We could not have been happier with our selection and would highly recommend them and their delicious cakes to anyone needing a bakery/cake shop.

we went in with was a small budget because our event was small and intimate. After tasting the cake which was my favorite part :) and searching for ideas my husband came up with a unique cake idea. The delivery was super smooth. I actually was at the venue when the cake was delivered and the delivery person was super helpful with setting the cake up. I have already told my husband that when we have either a 5 or 10 year anniversary party we DEFINITELY will be at Aggie's for them to make the cake!!!!

o cancel, no cake made, ingredients not used (Aggie told me the cake would only take 1-2 days to make), just an appointment date I was told”our return/refund policy WILL NOT AND HAS NOT changed due to the pandemic or any customers unforeseen circumstance”. Very unfortunate and disheartening for a current healthcare worker/soon to be bride, I will never use or recommend this bakery

. Aggie's truly brought our vision of our wedding cake to life. We received multiple compliments about how delicious the cakes were. We have nothing but complete appreciation for this wonderful local bakery! Thank you Aggie's!!

guest list numbers (thanks, Covid!) but Alex was willing to accommodate whatever we needed. The cake tasted delicious, too :)

of other deserts to please everyone’s taste. The cheesecake was a favorite! Would highly recommend Aggies!