About this Vendor

Everyone Deserves a Custom Cake

Details

Price Range

$$ – Affordable

Wedding Categories

Cake Delivery + Setup, Cakes + Desserts

Awards
Bowhof
Bow2016
Bow2015
Bow2013
Bow2012
less

Contact Info

133 East 39th Street , New York, NY

Reviewed on 4/26/2016 Julie C

Butterfly Bakeshop makes the best cake I have ever tasted, ever. Their at-home tastings are so well organized, their design team is easy to work with, the price is reasonable and their execution is flawless. The cake was made exactly how I wanted and we got rave reviews from... Read More everyone on the taste! Highly recommended.


Reviewed on 12/22/2015 Jaclyn R

Butterfly Bakeshop was incredible—I'm so glad we picked them for the big day! Our 4-tier wedding cake was gorgeous and delicious, but the big hit of the night was by far the groom's cake. My husband is a huge Star Wars fan and Butterfly made him a memorable cake for the big day.... Read More Our guests were coming up and taking photos of the cake all night—it definitely stole the show. I would highly recommend Butterfly Bakeshop for anyone who needs a yummy, custom cake for a special occasion.

2015-12-22T14:23:22 Response from the vendor

Thank you for the Kinds Words and sharing your experince with us. Our team had such a great time creating the Star Wars Groom's cake. We look forward to being part of your next Special celebration.


Butterfly Bakeshop

Reviewed on 12/21/2015 Lane S

I'm not a cake artist, but, Chef Leon is! I gave them an idea and they did all the work and the cake was more beautiful than I could have imagined! Delicious, getting fabulous reviews from our guests. Their website is great and they are so nice to work with. When you are... Read More planning a wedding that is so important. So, they are fun to work with and made a gorgeous, yummy cake that everyone loved...and they give you a cake on your anniversary, can't wait!

2015-12-22T07:59:35 Response from the vendor

Thank you for taking the time to leave such a great feedback on our service. We are happy to hear that you and your guests loved the cake, be believe cakes not only have to look beautiful to taste amazing. We would like to Congratulate... Read Less Read More


Reviewed on 11/24/2015

We tried at least 5 different cake providers in NYC. Butterfly tasted the best. Nice texture, great range of flavors, moist. We opted for a super minimalist plain white design. It was executed perfectly. So many guests commented about how surprisingly delicious the... Read More wedding cake was, because too often they're disappointing. Butterfly Bakeshop is truly gifted at their craft and we look forward to working with them for other celebrations!


Reviewed on 10/20/2015 Katherine C

I didn't personally work with Butterfly cake shop, my friend purchased our wedding cake as a somewhat surprise gift. According to her, they were the only bakery willing to work with her in such a timeframe (only a month!) I was involved in the design process, which was... Read More great. They make it really easy! On the day of the wedding it looked and tasted amazing! We received many compliments from our guests about the cake.


Reviewed on 10/13/2015 Emily S

We had Butterfly do our wedding cake and a surprise grooms cake (Star Wars Lego theme), and could not be more happy with the cakes! Everyone, guests and staff, commented on the taste and how great they looked. Wedding cake was simple and classic and grooms cake was fun and... Read More creative. Orlando and his team were first class the entire time. Highly recommend!

2015-10-14T13:00:37 Response from the vendor

Hi Emily, We are so happy that you and your guests enjoyed the cake. We too loved the Star Wars Grooms cake. We hope we have the opportunity to celebrate with you in the future.It was an absolute pleasure to assist you.


Reviewed on 9/27/2015 Michael M

We were decidedly thrilled with the cake we ordered and received from Butterfly Bakeshop. Not only did our guests love it, but some of them who never eat cake or sweets went back for seconds and thirds. The cake is moderately priced and affordable, and yet it was just... Read More stunningly gorgeous and pleasing to the palate.

2015-09-28T10:11:23 Response from the vendor

We are so glad to hear that your guests loved the cake, it makes us happy to hear that they asked for seconds and thirds. It also makes us happy that the design met your expectations. We hope that we have the opporunity to celebrate... Read Less Read More


Reviewed on 8/31/2015 Kristina C

Butterfly Bake Shop created my beautiful wedding cake for my 8/29/15 wedding in NYC. It is safe to say that I had written to over a dozen bakeries, and I found Stacy and her team to be the most fair, honest and responsive of all of my inquiries. We received everything we asked... Read More for, and the cake was absolutely exceptional. Even after a few drinks, surrounded by family, friends and cameras, my groom and I both exclaimed to eachother when we cut the cake, "wow that cake is amazing!" Thank you Butterfly Bake Shop for your responsiveness, willingness to create my unique vision and delivering my cake on time to my venue! I look forward to working with you for future celebrations!


Reviewed on 7/28/2015 Kayla M

After several lackluster tastings that left me with little more than outrageous price quotes, I was so relieved to work with the kind and talented staff at Butterfly Bakeshop. I wasn't the type of bride who wanted to spend days, hours or even minutes thinking about a cake--I... Read More wanted it to look pretty and taste good. After communicating those sentiments to the staff, along with my preferred budget, there was a quick proposal--I signed immediately. Our cake was beautiful, tasted fantastic, and did not cause me stress for a fraction of a moment.

2015-07-28T15:22:29 Response from the vendor

We are glad to hear that we were able to make ordering your wedding cake easy and without stress. We try to personalize our service to each couples needs. It makes us happy to know that you likee the design and that the cake was... Read Less Read More


Reviewed on 7/01/2015

We sampled a lot of bakeries in NYC prior to selecting Butterfly. I'm so glad we went with them. It was definitely the best cake we tried. Our reception was so hectic that I didn't get to eat any cake that night. But I had two pieces for breakfast the next morning. It was... Read More delicious!


Red Velvet Heaven

Reviewed on 6/26/2015 Solangie A

We were looking for a budget bakery, we had a very small wedding (30 people) and did not need mandatory three layers. Butterfly worked with my budget, were professional, and the cake was divine. We ordered a red velvet cake with a buttercream icing. It was beautiful. Could not... Read More have asked for anything more.

2015-06-27T08:40:48 Response from the vendor

We are happy to hear that we met your expectations. Big or small your wedding day is special and we believe that everyone should have an amazing experience and cake! We hope to celebrate more happy occasions with you in the future.


Reviewed on 6/17/2015 Allie F

They were awesome! Super fast responses, cake was designed exactly as we wanted it. They even drive 150 miles through a mountain to deliver it in perfect condition!


1 Month Later-Everyone Still Talking About THE CAKE !

Reviewed on 6/08/2015

Kindness and quality prevail. From the initial contact to the tasting and final design the staff are wonderful to work with. They make each bride and groom feel special and go overboard to work within one's budget without sacrificing beauty and taste. Their cake was elegant... Read More and absolutely delicious. The cake is moist and the buttercream is perfection.....not cloyingly sweet. Guests actually asked for seconds & as hard as it may be to believe, one month later, people are still talking about. Butterfly Bakeshop are the Dream Cream Team !


Reviewed on 6/02/2015

The last thing you want for your wedding is to have to worry about the cake, and Butterfly made everything easy. I never set foot in butterfly, or tasted anything of theirs before it arrived, but only had conversations over email, basically took a leap of faith, and yet they... Read More managed to get us exactly what we wanted. Our wedding was 75 people, so we had a small white square cutting cake with a large peony flower (the flower was breathtakingly beautiful, even prettier than the website example) to serve to family, and then cupcakes containing the same fillings for the rest of the guests. The cake was absolutely gorgeous, the filling was delicious, and the cupcakes were FANTASTIC, the guests kept commenting on how good they were. Everything arrived ahead of time, with frequent communication between Butterfly and our reception venue. Furthermore it was surprisingly affordable, especially for NYC. I would highly recommend them to anyone.


Great cake!

Reviewed on 2/25/2015 Lisa G

We were referred to Butterfly by a friend who is an event coordinator that knew we wanted a great cake on a budget. We are so happy! We did the cake a la carte and it was amazing! Everything about the process was great, from the ease of the cake tasting to go, the ordering and... Read More payment process, coordination of delivery, etc. the cake itself was amazing and beautiful, not to mention delicious and fresh. Our guests said it was the best wedding cake they ever had. My only regret is that in the craziness of the night, the only piece I got to eat was the small bite my new husband fed to me! I've been dreaming about it ever since. Thank you Butterfly Bakeshop!


Tasty and Beautiful Cake

Reviewed on 11/25/2014 Rebecca G

I used Butterfly Bakeshop for my wedding cake. The cake was delicious. Everyone loved it and several people commented on the variety / tastiness of the flavors. We opted for a thin band with each tier (3 of them) in a different color: red, orange, yellow with three roses... Read More on top. The flower/band looked really good with our flower \ huppah colors. Butterfly Bakeshop was easy to work with, and were responsive to questions / design suggestions. They were also significantly less per slice than other cake companies I researched. If I every need a custom cake again, I would not hesitate to use Butterfly Bakeshop again.


cupcakes for dinner

Reviewed on 11/11/2014 Steph K

We ordered a small cutting cake (chocolate buttercream with vanilla cake) and 180 cupcakes for our guests with various flavors (cookies and cream, peanut butter, passion fruit, and Aztec chocolate). Everything was DELICIOUS and very affordable. We actually had the cupcakes... Read More double as favors (using those cute boxes) and made our OWN cupcake tiers from a Dollar Store to cut costs. Gorgeous. The service also made Butterfly Bakeshop an easy choice. I love the woman who works there -- she spent a ton of time talking to us during our tasting and was very helpful. After the wedding, we froze the leftover cupcakes and ate them for dinner for days after the wedding - so delicious. I never remember wedding cakes/cupcakes, but you can't forget a dessert from Butterfly Bakeshop! Well done!!!


An easy and delicious choice

Reviewed on 10/20/2014

Butterfly Bakeshop was excellent and easy to work with. All of my communications with them were responded to promptly, and all three of the women I worked with were incredibly helpful and kind, whether it was by email or over the phone. The cake was truly delicious (we had a... Read More vanilla-orange cake, which I highly recommend)! We had the most simple design possible (by our choice), so I can't speak truly to their design prowess - but it looked lovely, and was just as we wanted. I will point out that if your cake is under $500, they do charge $50 for the tasting (which are two bite-size cupcakes for each flavor); but it's pretty easy to bump it over that mark, and then the tasting is included. Highly recommended!


Butterfly Bakeshop - A+ on all counts!

Reviewed on 10/02/2014

We couldn't have been happier with the entire experience. Working with Stacy and Kimberly was great. They answered all the questions we had, offered suggestions and were always quick to reply. The cake itself was sooooo delicious...I feel like every single guest commented on... Read More it and we couldn't have been happier to hear that. My husband and I both have a sweet tooth so the cake was a big deal for us. We tried 2 other places before a friend recommended Butterfly Bakeshop and once we tried their samples we knew it was a home run. The delivery went smooth (we got married in NYC) and they offered very specific, detailed instructions on how to store the cake and serve it at perfect room temeprature. Our design was pretty simple/clean but it still looked beautiful. We were thrilled with the whole experience...A+ for the entire team at Butterfly Bakeshop - thank you for making our special night even sweeter!!!


Highly recommend

Reviewed on 9/17/2014

Butterfly bakeshop was a pleasure to work with from beginning to end of the process. Our cake was not only beautiful but also DELICIOUS !!!!! We received many compliments!!!


Wonderful Wedding Cake!

Reviewed on 9/08/2014 Lisa G

The team at Butterfly Bakeshop, including Kimberly who coordinated our order is simply wonderful! We waited a litttttle late to order our cake, and they worked with us quickly to supply a beautiful and delicious cake for our wedding. The at-home tasting process is smart and... Read More easy, and the cake was absolutely perfect for our night!


Loved our cake!

Reviewed on 8/31/2014 Jessica F

Butterfly Bakeshop was an absolute pleasure to work with. They understood exactly what we were looking for. The cake design was simple and elegant. We chose vanilla cake with Nutella buttercream alternating with a layer of chocolate cake and chocolate buttercream, and both... Read More tasted absolutely delicious. My husband and I received so many compliments and we were very happy with our cake.


My July 3 wedding

Reviewed on 7/30/2014 NYISHA

Butterfly Bakeshop is absolutely amazing! I planned my wedding from Florida and they were very accommodating and helpful. My cake was beautiful and tasted even better than it looked. They also gave the best price of everyone I contacted. I will recommend them to any and... Read More everyone.


Amazing Wedding Cake

Reviewed on 7/25/2014 Jacquelyn S

I found a picture of a wedding cake I fell in love with and Butterfly Bakeshop replicated the wedding cake perfectly and scaled it down to size for my wedding with 40 guests. Everyone at my wedding raved about the wedding cake and said not only was it beautiful, the cake and... Read More buttercream had excellent texture, moisture and flavor. Quite simply, everyone loved it. Butterfly Bakeshop makes incredible cakes, their prices are reasonable and they are a pleasure to work with.

2014-07-25T11:06:39 Response from the vendor

We are so happy that you and your guests loved the cake. We thought is was really pretty too. We look forward to celebrating with you in the future!


Absolutely Perfect!

Reviewed on 7/21/2014 Caroline T

We chose a small but intricate cake and it came out beautifully - our photos are amazing and the cake was delicious! The team was very responsive and extremely professional - it was a pleasure working with them and I highly recommend them to other brides.

2014-07-22T09:33:34 Response from the vendor

We are glad to hear that you loved your cake! Large or small we strive to create the cake you dreamed of. We look forward to celebrating with you in the future.


VIEW MORE