Serving all of Long Island and the NY Tri-State Area
About This Vendor
We don‘t know Dortoni Bakery and Pastry Shoppe‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.
Awards and Affiliations
Dortoni Bakery and Pastry Shoppe Reviews
Share your thoughts with other couples
Reviewed On 2/13/2021 by Melissa M
Dortoni is one of the bakeries our venue uses for wedding cakes. Our cake was absolutely delicious, and the design is exactly what we wanted. Everyone could not stop raving about how incredible and beautiful it was. The staff was easily reachab...
le and was there for any questions we had. Thank you Candice and team!
Reviewed On 10/25/2020 by Gina P
We chose Dortoni's for our wedding cake and it was absolutely delicious! Everyone is still talking about our cake. We went with a simple cake with raspberry and black cherry filling and it was by far the highlight of the night. The cake was sim...
ple yet elegant, which was exactly what we wanted. Look no further, Dortoni’s is the right choice.
Reviewed On 7/26/2020 by Danielle V
We used this bakery for our microwedding after recommendations from our venue, the Heritage Club. Due to Covid-19 the cake tasting was set up for my husband and I to bring it home to try. Dortonis has our take home tasting set up in a way that ...
made it so easy! We still enjoyed the tasting from home- it was so hard to choose. Our cake on our wedding day was absolutely delicious! & it looked amazing! We got so many compliments & cant wait have it again for our 1 year anniversary! We will definitely use this bakery for any pastries or cake needs!
Reviewed On 7/08/2020 by Heather D
This vendor was used by our catering hall, The Watermill. We went to the bakery for a cake tasting which was a fun and memorable experience. On our wedding day the cake looked and tasted beautiful and was exactly what we had asked for! Highly r...
ecommend this vendor and since my wedding day I have used this bakery for my cake and pastry needs!
Reviewed On 3/19/2020 by Elizabeth B
We used Dortoni because they were one of the options offered to us by our venue, Stonebridge. The cake tasting process was easy and enjoyable. Our wedding cake was beautiful and looked exactly how we wanted it to. It also tasted delicious!!
Reviewed On 1/31/2020 by Mamei R
Dortoni’s baked my wedding cake because it was part of my package from Crest Hollow and it was absolutely beautiful and delicious. We chose one layer of Mixed Berry Chantilly and one layer of black cherry. My guests loved the flavors and kept...
asking where it came from. I was surprised at how good it was myself because I normally hate fruit filling. They did a great job!
Reviewed On 1/26/2020 by Stephanie T
Just went for my cake tasting yesterday! The place was packed with people and our tasting was amazing! Best cake I ever had hands down! So happy we choice them and can’t wait to see the final product at our wedding !!
Reviewed On 11/08/2019 by Carolyn I
We used Dortoni’s bakery for our wedding cake and it was delicious! We worked with Candice and she was wonderful. Our cake was beautiful as well. Got many compliments on how good the cake was. So many people in the beginning told me people don’...
t care or remember the cake but, I can say going with Dortoni’s was an amazing decision! I will remember this cake and how delicious it was! I will be going back to them for future cakes.
Reviewed On 10/09/2019 by tammy a
How any business can trust this bakery for their customer's wedding cakes is beyond me. I have what I asked for, and what I received on my WEDDING DAY attached. I already spoke to the manager at the bakery and they didn't even refund me HALF of...
the extra money I paid for the wedding cake design requested. My husband, when we were still boyfriend-girlfriend, carved our initials into a birch tree. I can't tell you how excited we were to have this cake at our wedding, and how I specifically told the photographer I want a photo of us cutting the wedding cake together because it is such a cute part of the wedding day. I received a cake that someone so CARELESSLY, and HEARTLESSLY, rushed through. They printed out a photo of what I wanted and attached it to the order, and told us it would be NO PROBLEM AT ALL, to do this RELATIVELY SIMPLE design. Instead, someone took a white cake, dipped a paintbrush in POOP-BROWN PAINT, and PAINTED WEIRD BROWN STROKES ON A WHITE CAKE. I was EMBARRASSED on my wedding day, something NO BRIDE SHOULD EVER FEEL on a ONCE IN A LIFETIME DAY. SHAME ON YOU. The manager was very nice, and very empathetic, but the owner could not be BOTHERED to even FULLY REFUND ME which would've been the VERY LEAST that he could do. I am absolutely heartbroken that my wedding day has permanent scar on it that I don't think I will be able to just "laugh about" in 10, 20, 50 years from now. Another reviewer said something very similar to me and was equally disappointed. The cake itself was of mediocre quality. We would have paid ANY AMOUNT OF MONEY for the cake we wanted, we assumed that's why we were charged an additional $450 for the design. The money is not the issue. The quality of work, IS. Stop using this bakery for weddings. They don't deserve the business.
Reviewed On 10/06/2019 by Gina K
Dortoni was in the package of our venue, Watermill Caterers. The cake was AMAZING!!! We asked for a marble cake with cannoli and chocolate mousse filling, because I am a chocolate lover and he is a vanilla lover! It tasted so good, we were thri...
lled with how it came out. We had 4 tiers, 2 rustic style and 2 plain and it looked beautiful. Highly recommend!
Reviewed On 10/03/2019 by Amanda H
We got our wedding cake and assorted pastries from Dortonis and it was hands down the best cake I have ever tasted. I don’t typically like wedding cake- but the naked cake they made us was perfectly moist, light & sweet and had the perfect amou...
nt of filling and frosting. Not to mention, it was absolutely beautiful!!
Reviewed On 10/02/2019 by Michele B
We used Dortoni for our wedding cake and it was the absolute best cake I have ever had! They were so accommodating for the tasting and everything was so good it was hard to decide but we went with the custard and berries and the whipped cream a...
nd strawberries. My guests were ravinggggg about how delicious and moist the cake was. I will 100% be recommending Dortoni and using them for all future events!!
Reviewed On 8/15/2019 by Shannette S
The cake was amazing !!! Best cake ever. They did a wonderful job. We received a lot of great compliments on it. Thank you !
Reviewed On 8/08/2019 by Marisa R
We used Dortoni for our wedding cake in July and we are so happy we did!! They were so amazing to work with from our tasting to the day of. Our cake was BEAUTIFUL and absolutely delicious!! Thank you Dortoni!!
Reviewed On 8/05/2019 by Laura G
All I can say is BEST CAKE EVER. The cake was beautiful (just what we asked for) and delicious. Could not have asked for anything more. Thank you Dortonis!!!
Reviewed On 8/05/2019 by Brooke M
We used Dortoni for our wedding cake this July 2019. The four tier cake was not only beautiful, but tasted outstanding. All our guests were impressed. Even the process of choosing a filling flavor was easy and fun. Dortoni also provided a birth...
day cake for my sister which happened to be the same weekend of our wedding. The birthday cake was beautifully decorated and tasted even better. Dortoni also provides a gift certificate to go back a year later for them to recreate the top layer of your wedding cake, so that it is as fresh as the day you had it on your wedding. No other bakery provider this special additional treat. I highly recommend the team at Dortoni for all your bakery needs, especially wedding cakes!
Reviewed On 7/11/2019 by Lauren K
Love this bakery and all of their products are so delicious. The cake tasting was so much fun and everyone working there is so sweet. Our wedding cake was delicious and matched our vision completely! Excited to keep getting cakes here for many ...
years to come.
Reviewed On 7/04/2019 by Allie B
We had the most amazing wedding cake from Dortoni Bakery for our wedding! We had a special Art Deco design in mind, and they were incredibly accommodating without charging huge fees— unlike other LI bakeries. Our cake was priced so reasonably, ...
and the quality was so good.
Our cake was funfetti— and the sprinkles were so vibrant! They weren’t light colored, but vivid and evident! We also chose the chantilly cream with berries as one of our filling— and the guests were so impressed with actual strawberries and blackberries in the cake. It was fresh fruit!
We couldn’t have been happier with our wedding cake and would gladly recommend Dortoni Bakery!!
Reviewed On 6/26/2019 by Michelle M
We got married on June 7, 2019, and Dortoni is the bakery that our venue, The Royalton Mansion in Roslyn, uses for their wedding cakes.
We went there for our cake tasting and you get to try 2 cake flavors and 6 filling flavors, which you tell...
them ahead of time when you make the appointment. Everything was delicious and we had a hard time choosing which filling we wanted. One of the employees came by and then told us we could do 2 fillings, because each tier is 3 layers of cake and 2 layers of filling - perfect! We chose a vanilla cake with chocolate mousse and raspberry mousse.
My venue handled all the design aspects with Dortoni, so I told my venue what I wanted and they passed it along. The cake was beautiful - exactly what I wanted. It was also delicious! Their buttercream icing is the perfect texture and isn't too sweet - the perfect balance.
At our tasting, Dortoni even gave us a certificate so that one year from our wedding we can go back to the bakery and get a 6-inch version of our cake! That way, we didn't have to have the venue save the top tier of our cake to take home - if that's a tradition you like! Fresh cake is definitely better than frozen!
Reviewed On 6/18/2019 by Jessica J
I mean there is no other places to consider besides Dortoni. I go to the bakery for any occasion, so my wedding was no exception. The cake tasting was so much fun! Everything tasted delicious it was hard to decide so they had the genius idea to...
do 4 different tiers. The cake was amazing and beautifully decorated! It was even better than I pictured. Absolute perfection.
Reviewed On 5/30/2019 by Stephanie E
The cake was not only beautiful but it tasted wonderful.
Reviewed On 5/27/2019 by Kathleen B
We would recommend Dortoni Bakery for all engaged couples! Rudy at Dortoni Bakery was excellent! He helped us at our tasting and then made sure the cake ordering and delivery to Sea Cliff Manor was smooth and efficient! The cake was made and...
decorated exactly as we had discussed! It was delicious - we had 4 tiers, 2 different fillings which gave our guests a chance to try either one! We would definitely recommend Dortoni bakery for all events, especially Wedding cakes!
Reviewed On 2/04/2019 by Kristina G
Dortoni is the best bakery and absolutely delivered an amazing wedding cake! They were very helpful in helping us decide on a cake to match our vision and came out exactly as we pictured! The fillings and choices are absolutely delicious!
Reviewed On 12/15/2018 by Lianna P
Our cake from Dortoni was fantastic! We are currently living out of state and were unable to come in for a taste testing yet everything looked and tasted amazing! The staff at Dortoni's was super helpful and receptive to all our needs. The cak...
e was a focal point at our wedding and is still being talked about by friends and family!
Reviewed On 12/06/2018 by Elizabeth C
Our wedding cake was gorgeous and exactly what we wanted to look like. And on top of all that it tasted WONDERFUL, we got so many compliments from our guests. You cannot go wrong with Dortoni!
Reviewed On 12/01/2018 by Michael R
Oh. My. God. Not only did our Gastby cake look beautiful, it was absolutely DELICIOUS!!! Great job!!
Reviewed On 11/22/2018 by Stefanie P
From the tasting to the final product, we’ve been nothing but amazed at the service and quality! At tasting they allowed us to try everything, sat us down and gave us coffee. Our cake was an autumn and rustic theme and came out better than the ...
photo i sent them. Fresh and delicious!
Reviewed On 10/27/2018 by Daniel D
The experience from the tasting to the finished product was everything I would want from a wedding cake vendor and more. The tasting was my personal favorite part. We were able to try so many different fillings and two different types of cake...
s along with some coffee. The cake at the wedding was so fresh and delicious. That was one of the main comments we received from people; how good the cake was! Highly recommended!
Reviewed On 10/22/2018 by Caitlyn M
We had a 4 tier cake - 2 w/ vanilla cake and cannoli filling and 2 w/ chocolate cake and raspberry filling. Both were delicious. We can't wait to eat the top tier on our first anniversary!
Reviewed On 10/04/2018 by Ingrid R
Our cake was beautiful and delicious. They executed the look just how we wanted and we're easy to work with. I would've given 5 stars but they gave my mother-in-law a ridiculous rate for our rehearsal dinner cake, which was a bit off-putting.
Reviewed On 9/30/2018 by Colleen W
We got our wedding cake through Dortoni and they were incredible. The tasting was great and we tasted 6 flavors with two flavors of cake. They gave us coffee or tea. Rudy who we worked with for our decoration and flavors was so nice and worked...
with us to pick our perfect decoration. With our wedding, we were able to get a 4 tier cake, we decided on a classic decoration. After that, they took care of everything. We gave them a cake topper to use and they added it while at the venue. It was gorgeous and they were so helpful and professional. We would definitely work with them again.
Reviewed On 9/16/2018 by Jillian B
Our cake was included with our venue so we used Dortoni Bakery. The cake was amazing and came out better than we expected. Dortoni had a ton of different fillings to chose from, would highly recommend. We still have people telling us how much t...
hey enjoyed our cake.
Reviewed On 9/03/2018 by Caitlin T
Dortoni made our wedding cake, and all I can say is wow! Our cake looked just like the picture that we picked out, and it tasted awesome! I also loved the process of picking out what flavors we would have for our cake. We came in and we sat ...
at a cute little table for tastings--we chose the strawberry shortcake and the chantilly berry fillings with a vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream icing for our July 6, 2018 wedding. We got to taste at least 6 different fillings and types of cake along with complimentary coffee. Rony (possibly Rudy!) helped us, and made the process quick, painless, easy, and fun! We are so glad that we went with Dortoni, and we will definitely be back if we need any other cakes for special occasions! They have great prices, and delicious offerings. Thank you for making our wedding cake dreams come true!
Reviewed On 8/27/2018 by Michelle I
The cake came out amazing, we received numerous compliments on the taste also.
Reviewed On 8/26/2018 by Emily O
We were connected with the bakery through our venue and could not have been happier! I have gone to Dortoni’s for all of my family cakes and knew they’d do a phenomenal job. When we met with the baker for our cake tasting we showed her an idea ...
of what we were leaning towards and on the day of the wedding it was EXACTLY what we wanted. Everything was perfect!
Reviewed On 8/11/2018 by Carina S
Dortoni Bakery did an amazing job making my wedding cake what I envisioned it to look like. The cake was delicious and I can't wait to have my anniversary cake made, so that I can eat it again. I would recommend them to anyone.
Reviewed On 8/01/2018 by Tina K
Dortoni is the best, hands down. Our cake came free with our reception, so we scheduled a cake tasting three months before the wedding. We got to try all the flavors and had a hard time choosing because they were all so good! We dropped off our...
cake topper with them and on the day of the wedding, our beautiful cake was there, exactly how I had imagined it. And it was delicious! I would definitely recommend them.
Reviewed On 7/22/2018 by Megan R
We ordered our wedding cake from Dortoni Bakery and couldn’t be happier!! The chocolate ganache and cannoli cream fillings were delicious! We can’t wait to eat the top of our cake on our anniversary!
Reviewed On 7/21/2018 by Krista G
The best cake I have ever tasted! They made our wedding day so perfect and gave us the cake of our dreams. Using Dortoni was the best decision we made!!
Reviewed On 7/14/2018 by Ginny R
Coming from someone who isn't really a cake lover, I can tell you that Dortoni's cakes are delicious! Our cake was 4 layers and we chose to have 2 layers be chocolate with cannoli filling, and the other 2 layers vanilla with fresh strawberries....
Both were equally tasty! After our wedding I had a few people tell me how delicious the cake was! Not only did our cake taste amazing, it was beautiful! We chose to have a "naked" style cake, so there was minimal frosting and parts of the cake could be seen. We added fresh flowers on the cake and it was truly gorgeous! I wish I could add a picture for you all to see. Again, not being much of a cake fan, I wasn't too worried about the cake that day. When my groom and I had a look at the room before our guests entered, it was one of the first things we noticed. It really was beautiful! We will definitely be using Dortoni's in the future for our events!
Reviewed On 7/13/2018 by Jacquelyn K
I've been going here for years and my sister worked here for a long time, so maybe I am a little biased but I think their wedding cake was fantastic! So many options for fillings and they will work with you to combine flavors and layers to mak...
e what you want. They also gave me a certificate for a 1 year anniversary cake so I don't have to save the topper. How great is that!? The lemon mousse filling is my favorite- refreshing and different. I also showed them a photo of what I wanted and they make it exactly as I had it pictured. Also very friendly and helpful staff. I would definitely recommend them for your big day, they won't let you down.
Reviewed On 7/08/2018 by Jennifer F
Our wedding cake was provided through our venue from Dortoni's and we had the option to upgrade to a rainbow cookie cannoli cake. The cake was delivered exactly how we had designed, and was absolutely delicious! We chose the rainbow cookie ca...
nnoli cake, and it was absolutely amazing. The cake was one of the things we were most excited for and Dortoni's delivered!
Reviewed On 7/03/2018 by Betsy C
Our venue uses Dortoni Bakery for their cakes and let me tell you, there is a reason why! Our cake was not only beautiful to look at but it was so delicious!!!!
We ordered a vanilla cake with chocolate mousse and fresh strawberries in whipped c...
ream and they completely wow'ed everyone!! We have gotten so many compliments on our cake! We were lucky enough to have some packed up for us to take home since we were so busy and were glad we did!
They also gave us a certificate so in 1 year they will bake us a new small cake just like our wedding cake so we dont have to freeze it and eat the old one!
Reviewed On 6/30/2018 by Stephanie V
We are so happy we worked with Dortoni bakery! Carolina was so wonderful to work with! Our wedding cake and grooms' cake were beautiful and delicious. Thank you so much to everyone at Dortoni's! :)
Reviewed On 6/03/2018 by Alexandra K
They were so easy to work with! The cake was delish! And stunning! I couldn’t have asked for anything better! Can’t wait to use them for other special occasions!
Reviewed On 5/22/2018 by Daniela D
Our wedding cake was one of the most beautiful parts of our wedding. When we walked in and saw it, we were blown away. The cake was beyond what we asked for - so elegant and so delicious. We worked with Candace and she was very sweet and accomm...
odating of our changes and putting together exactly what we wanted. We were so pleased with how it came out and received so many compliments on it. We sneak back to Dortoni any time we're in Long Island just to taste their treats!
Reviewed On 4/18/2018 by Hannah W
We first had the pleasure of tasting Dortoni cake at the INN at NHP showcase. We could not stop thinking about it! Dortoni was a dream to work with for our wedding. We met with Candice for our tasting. She was a perfect guide for suggesting dif...
ferent combinations while letting us explore independently. Once the cake flavor was locked in, Candice sat with us and showed us examples of other cakes. We added a medallion to the outside of the top tier and Candice figured out a way to perfectly attach it. Our cake looked amazing and tasted even better! Guest keep telling us it was the best wedding cake they ever had and we just have to agree with them! We highly recommend Dortoni for any event. I know we will be back for future celebrations! Thank you so much Dortoni!
Reviewed On 1/09/2018 by Sylvia C
Dortoni made out wedding cake and people literally stopped us all night asking where the cake was from.
It was delicious.
Our flavors were:
Chocolate cake with raspberry jam & Yellow cake with Dulce De Leche.
The tasking w...
as easy and as busy as the bakery was, everyone was so helpful and attentive.
They made our cake exactly like the picture we sent them.
Excellent job :)
Reviewed On 1/02/2018 by Danielle N
Wedding cake was phenomenal and just as I envisioned!
Reviewed On 12/18/2017 by Ariana S
Thank you for such a beautiful Wedding cake!
Dortoni was able to make our vision come to life and we are forever grateful.
Thank you for taking the time to pick out flavors and options, you were so very helpful!!
Reviewed On 12/13/2017 by Jennifer Y
Our wedding cake was included with our wedding, and our venue's vendor was Dortoni. I can't thank Dortoni enough because I was absolutely blown away by how gorgeous our cake was. It was more beautiful than I could ever have imagined! My jaw ...
dropped when I saw our cake during the reception, it was definitely the prettiest wedding cake I've ever seen. I'm also not a cake person, but it was really delicious! We got vanilla cake with the chocolate whipped cream filling. It was so light and not overly sweet at all. Our cake was just perfect and I couldn't have asked for anything more. Thank you so much, Dortoni! We're excited to cut into our top tier on our first anniversary!
Reviewed On 10/31/2017 by Tasha P
Our wedding cake was included in our wedding package for our venue at Larkfield. We decided to go with a ‘naked’ cake to fit our rustic theme, rather than pick from the included cake designs. There was no extra fee. The cake was absolutely be...
autiful and looked exactly like the picture we gave them. The cake itself was absolutely delicious. We choose the yellow cake with chantilly and fresh berries and dolce de’leche fillings. Soooo good! I don’t usually care for cakes at weddings, but this cake was fantastic. Highly recommend this bakery!
Reviewed On 10/26/2017 by Michelle M
Our tasting was so fun and easy; the cake itself was a knockout! We loved working with Dortoni on our wedding cake and would recommend them to anyone.
Reviewed On 10/04/2017 by Stacey L
They are a well known and established bakery. When we went for our tasting they accommodated our large party size and offered such a nice variety of cake flavors and fillings. They have a good selection of design choices as well. Since my husba...
nd is on a gluten free and dairy free diet we ordered a grooms cake that would meet his needs. He was excited to have that because his body hates regular cake. We loved our wedding cake, it was delicious and a good combo of flavors that everyone would like (4 tiers. One tier vanilla cake, one tier chocolate cake and that alternated. But the fillings were the same on every tier: berries in chantilly cream and chocolate dobasch). However we rated them a B+ since they never delivered the grooms cake. We were disappointed in that.
Reviewed On 9/19/2017 by Amanda G
Dortoni cake was included with our venue and they did an amazing job. We had a great experience cake tasting and the day of our wedding, the cake was fresh and delicious. It didn`t taste like a typical wedding cake. Would definitely use again i...
n the future!
Reviewed On 8/03/2017 by Jennifer L
We got married at the Watermill and they use Dortoni (as do many others on LI). The cake was delicious! Often, wedding cakes are dry and don't have much flavor. The Dortoni cake was SO moist and the fillings were delicious. There were so ma...
ny fillings and cakes to choose from. They did a great job and I would definitely order a cake from them in the future!
Reviewed On 7/29/2017 by Natalie P
Our venue provided our wedding cake gratuitously through Dortoni and we were so glad they did! The cake was amazing. Layers with Nutella, Dulce de Leche and Italian Custard on white cake. The cake was made to perfection and resembled the photo ...
I provided them flawlessly. The cake tasting experience was also a lot of fun. Thank you Dortoni!
Reviewed On 7/25/2017 by Ariel L
Yay! Married at the Larkfield so their cake was outsource through them. So delicious ! And looked stunning. I was nervous - as someone who did wedding cakes for a little- I can be picky. But it was perfect. Only this I can say negative is that ...
any upgrade charges are extremely high for little work. So that's frustrating. But still delicious and beautiful! Thank you guys
Reviewed On 7/07/2017 by Tatiana S
The best! Wedding cake came out just the way we wanted it. Thankful that they offer gluten free cake mix as well. It was the best gluten free cake mix we have ever tasted. It was so moist! Very happy we chose Dortoni for our wedding cake. You ...
wil not be disappointed.
Reviewed On 7/07/2017 by Jaclyn G
Ana is the absolute best! She was the nicest and such a help to me and my Fiance for our Wedding Cake and all of the Desserts we ordered for our Viennese Hour. Every time we met with her she had such patience and answered all of our questions, ...
and gave such great advice! I would recommend everyone go to Dortoni's and meet with Ana! Thank you again so much for all of your help!
Reviewed On 6/17/2017 by Kathleen D
We got married 3 weeks ago, and everyone was talking about our cake. Dortoni was amazing. Our cake was delicious. We wanted something simple, yet elegant. Our cake was truly beautiful. So many people have come to me to ask who I used so they co...
uld use Dortoni for future events. Reasonably priced and absolutely delicious!
Reviewed On 5/22/2017 by Queen B
My wedding roses came out GREEN instead of MINT! WORSE service ever!
Reviewed On 3/18/2017 by Debra C
My Daughter's Wedding Cake and Cookies the BEST EVER...
Jenna great to work with!!!
Reviewed On 12/18/2016 by Amanda W
Thank you for the beautiful wedding cake!! I was very specific about the type of cake that I wanted, and they made it taste delicious! People were raving about the Nutella frosting. I loved the bows (one somehow got taken off during the ceremon...
y, but the staff at the Watermill took care of it and made another bow - incredible! I wouldn't have noticed it if they didn't tell me.) We froze the cake and can't wait to have a piece of it in a year from now. Thank you again!!
Reviewed On 12/07/2016 by Christie V
My husband and I cannot say enough great things about using Dortonis for our wedding in October. We loved our rehearsal dinner and wedding cakes. The surprise grooms cake also came out awesome! Our guests are still talking about how great the c...
akes looked and tasted! We would not go with any other bakery.
Reviewed On 10/06/2016 by Lauren P
used Dortoni for my wedding cake for my September 17, 2016 wedding. They did an amazing job! First of all the cake was delicious! We had the tasting and talked through the design for our cake and what they made was absolutely perfect - exactly ...
what we wanted! It was so elegant - we had so many compliments from guests. Additionally, we had guest whose birthday was the same day of our wedding and we added a small birthday cake to our order and they were very happy to do so. I would highly recommend them for your events. They were also very reasonably priced.
Reviewed On 9/15/2016 by Danielle M
They do wedding cakes all the time - I am terribly picky with cakes from a bakery and I could never find a good enough cake for my wedding - I am so excited my venue only deals with Dortoni's! My chef husband loves this bakery and they were a...
mazing! Cake was good and the cannoli filling was the real deal. I continue to use this bakery whenever I'm near. The tasting was enjoyable and fun! The day of the wedding we were impressed with the cake display - we had Dortoni's do a simple design and the florist put flowers on it - it came out better than I imagined!
Reviewed On 9/13/2016 by Guadalupe T
We had our wedding on 9/3/16 from Dortoni's and it was AMAZING. The cake tasting was a wonderful experience with many selections that made it easy to choose our fillings. We showed them a picture of the cake we wanted and they definitely delive...
red. We would recommend this Bakery to anyone.
Reviewed On 9/01/2016 by Suzie C
I’ll start by saying that what I originally wanted, Dortoni’s was not able to do for me. Or rather they advised against my original idea. However everything happens for a reason and I am so pleased with the outcome. My wedding cake was beautifu...
l and delicious. The cake tasting was fun and we were easily able to pick out our favorite flavors. I showed them a picture of the design I wanted and I was pleasantly surprised on the wedding day to see that it they had executed it perfectly. I remember cutting the cake at the wedding and saying to my husband how good the cake was. I don’t know why I was so shocked because as I mentioned, we had done the cake tasting. The cake was so good that we decided against storing the top tier in the freezer for a year and instead we ate it the very next day. ha!
Reviewed On 8/22/2016 by Nicole R
After trying almost every filling in the bakery they came out with the perfect pairing for us! They were so accommodating and helpful with choosing our perfect wedding cake. Our cake was perfect the day of our wedding and we could not have bee...
Reviewed On 4/18/2016 by Julia S
AMAZING CAKES!! The staff at Dortoni are so easy to work with, plus their cakes and treats are amazing. I got so many compliments on our cake! I will definitely be going back to the bakery and getting other cakes and cookies from there in the f...
uture. I'm sold!
Reviewed On 1/23/2016 by Carly G
Take it from a guy who doesn't normally eat cake:
This cake was AWESOME.
From our tasting and deciding on what we wanted in our cake, to putting the fork down after enjoying this delicious masterpiece, Dortoni was perfect.
Our cake was...
included in our Larkfield contract, but we wanted more than the cakes that came with package.
We paid an additional $75, Dortoni provided us a 4-tier cake with (2) delicious fillings of our choice (Nutella and Canolli cream), and 3 layers of cake - in each tier!
They also gave us a fondant design in a buttercream frosting (That, and the 4th tier created the up-charge - which we were happy to pay).
This cake was beautiful and absolutely delicious.
Reviewed On 12/14/2015 by Christina O
My cake was the best! It was beautifully designed & the cake tasted great as well! Me & my family use Dortoni's all the time & they always do a great job! Very happy!
Reviewed On 11/11/2015 by Rebecca M
The cake was delicious. A lot of times I feel like the cake is always very plan and dry at weddings, but this cake was most and flavorful. It was also beautiful.
Reviewed On 11/07/2015 by Stephanie S
Dortani Bakery did my bridal shower cake, as well as our wedding cake. Both cakes tasted and looked amazing! Our guests raved about the cakes.
Reviewed On 10/25/2015 by Sarah B
Dortonis did our wedding cake this past weekend and it was amazing. It was so beautiful and of course tasted amazing. I wouldn't choose any other bakery for a wedding cake!
Reviewed On 10/03/2015 by Ingrid M
We went with this bakery since it was already included with the reception venue. We decided to pay extra for the fondant on the cake and nice golden decor on the cake. However it was nothing like the picture of the cake we showed them. The gold...
en color was too dark and I didn't really like it. I was not impressed with the cake itself. When we had our sample tasting for the filling the staff was friendly but you cannot try all of the fillings, but only 6-8 of them.
I wish we didn't spent extra $500 on the fondant and save that money instead!
Reviewed On 9/29/2015 by Marina G
Our wedding cake was so good, we might not wait until our first anniversary to eat the top tier!! They caked was absolutely delicious with the flavors we chose and the bakery was so easy to work with. They did a great job and it looked beautifu...
Reviewed On 8/31/2015 by Jaclyn G
We used this bakery because they worked with our venue. A cake from them was included with our reception. When we first went for our cake tasting we were disappointed in the customer service we received. We had an appointment yet we had to w...
ait 30 mins until someone brought us out cake to try. Then no one ever came over to talk to us they were too busy helping everyone else in the store. I was getting frustrated and they could tell so Anna finally sat with us. Long story short she gave us wrong information about what was and wasnt included with our package from our venue. I left completely upset and freaking out that I would have to find a new bakery and pay for an entire cake.
I called my venue and they cleared it up. We went in for a second appointment and met with Rudy- he was amazing. We were able to get exactly what we wanted. Yes we still had to pick from the "included" choices but at least he showed us pictures and gave suggestions based on the pictures I brought in.
If you go to this bakery ask for Rudy!
Reviewed On 8/04/2015 by Jackie N
A little expensive ... But the cake is worth it!!!
Reviewed On 7/30/2015 by Luciana P
Our cake was from Dortoni Bakery, the in-house bakery for our reception venue.
It was delicious and we were very happy with how it looked and how it tasted.
The staff at the bakery was friendly and very helpful, guiding us through the tas...
Highly recommended !!!
Reviewed On 7/21/2015 by Lindsay P
Our wedding cake was included in our budget at our venue.
The staff at Dortoni were wonderful and we tasted several cake fillings, which were delicious.
Our only concern regarding our cake was that the fillings looked messy once the cake ...
We got married on the Fourth of July. One of our fillings was Chantilly with blueberries and strawberries, which would reflect red, white, and blue in the cake. However, once the cake was cut, it didn't appear the way we thought it would. The fillings mixed in with the cake and there wasn't enough fruit to give the red, white, and blue look.
However, the cake itself was perfect, which to me, was the most important.
Reviewed On 4/02/2015 by Danielle L
Our cake was AMAZING! Go with the cannoli filling - you will not be disappointed.
Reviewed On 1/23/2015 by Michelle D
My wedding cake was so delicious. I recently just got married in December of 2014. I had a red velvet filling with cream cheese icing. They were so easy to work with. The women said send me a picture and we will duplicate it and they did just t...
hat. Great bakery!!
Reviewed On 12/19/2014 by Alyssa G
The cake looked beautiful and was delicious just the way I wanted it. Half canoli and half chocolate mousse (I'm such a dessert person and I was head over heels)...recommend them because even their cookies and cupcakes are amazing!!
Reviewed On 12/11/2014 by Nicole G
Dortoni's is absolutely, hands down, the most delicious bakery i have ever had. Our wedding cake was created to PERFECTION based on the picture I showed them and not to mention delicious. They are so kind and wonderful service, it's no wonder t...
hat place is standing room only every time you go in! Thank you again for our amazing wedding cake!
Reviewed On 10/27/2014 by Serkan A
Amazing cake. My cake came out beautiful. Amazing taste.
Reviewed On 10/20/2014 by Kristen S
The cost of my wedding cake was included as part of my venue, so I can't really speak to the price of my wedding cake. It was a good cake, but honestly, it wasn't the best I've ever had. It was beautiful, though! They did an amazing job decorat...
ing it. I also purchased a rice krispie treat cake from Dortoni's as a groom's cake. It was $200 for 50 people. I think that is outrageous pricing for something that should've cost no more than $50 to make. But, it also looked awesome. The individuals I worked with at the bakery were very friendly & polite; they worked with me every step of the way to ensure I got the flavors/design I was looking for.
Reviewed On 10/13/2014 by Brian C
We used Dortonis Bakery for our Sept 19 th wedding and we could not have been happier. We have used them for years for family parties and it was a no brainer to use them on our wedding day. We brought a picture in that we saw on pintrest and th...
ey were able to re-create it I was shocked with how beautiful it came out it was stunning. I also had many people compliment us on how delicious it was as well. They were very helpful and I would definitely recommend them
Reviewed On 9/18/2014 by Maritza C
Our cake looked absolutely beautiful! We didn't get to really eat it our cake because we were to busy partying but we froze the top tier in our freezer...I might cut a piece before our 1 year anniversary because I heard it was tasty. I don't kn...
ow how much our cake was (it was including in my package with Larkfield). We had a 4 tier cake with butter cream icing,purple roses , canoli and chocolate mouse filling. My husband isn't really a cake person but he definitely enjoyed our cake tasting session lol. I would recommend this bakery. I wish I could've bought some things while I was there but I was on a diet lol
Reviewed On 8/27/2014 by Trisha B
Delish and beautiful! The tasting was such a fun time and they were so very accommodating! Loved it!
Reviewed On 7/21/2014 by Allison C
We upgraded our cake and it was made by Dortoni. It was so delicious and looked better than the picture I had provided! I am a total dessert person and very critical when it comes to food, and this cake was so yummy. I cant wait to eat the topp...
er on our 1 year anniversary!
Reviewed On 6/14/2014 by Lauren S
Dortoni's created the Groom'd Cake for our wedding. It was a casino theme cake which was unbelievable! My husband was totally surprised and the poker chips and cards looks so real. It was an excellent display piece for our wedding and was delic...
Reviewed On 1/13/2014 by Tara R
Their cakes are unbelievable and delicious, but they delivered my cake with the wrong color ribbon (even after I personally dropped off the ribbon I wanted). They did apologize profusely and gave us a gift certificate, but I wonder if they're ...
so popular that there is a loss in the attention to detail.
Reviewed On 7/12/2013 by Radhika V
Our cake was provided through our reception venue. BUt we went there for cake tastings and we even got a side sweet! My husband and I are big foodies, so the many options made us happy! They were accomodatinga nd even let us pick a design that ...
we loved from online which wasn't the standard bethpage cake. overall satisfied
Reviewed On 12/26/2012 by Christie J
the bakery was wonderful. we asked for a couple of "non" buttercreams and they made them on the spot for the tasting and then used it for our cake without charging anything extra.
Reviewed On 11/07/2012 by Deanna R
I got our wedding cake and Grooms cake from Dortonis. From my first visit there and on, they are so wonderful and helpful and accommodating. They gave us a tasting of unlimited fillings.. and WOW, they're just great people working there! I had ...
a vision in my head, and they produced something even more perfect! For the Grooms cake I did a police type cake, and it was awesome. The colors were perfect, the only thing is i would've wanted the hat a little bigger on top, and the skyline going all the way around... but it was still awesome looking. As far as taste, amazing!!!! We knew we didn't want a fruit filling (fruit should be healthy, cake should be yummy!) so we went with Italian Custard and Chocolate Doubasch for our Wedding cake, and the flavors were amazing, the cake itself was melt in your mouth moist! Definitely THE best Wedding Cake I've ever had! For Grooms, we'll dig into that on Thanksgiving, we never cut it!! But I'm sure it's delicious!
Reviewed On 10/29/2012 by Lisa B
Our venue provided a wedding cake with the catering package. After going to that bakery, we knew immediately that we needed to find a different cake vendor! Through word of mouth we heard about dortoni... and when we arrived, the whole parkin...
g lot smelled of the great baked goods! You know you've found a great bakery when you walk inside any time of day and the place is packed! I design cakes myself so I was very particular when designing my own wedding cake! And dortoni lived up every expectation! They were so flexible in designing the cake exactly as we wanted it and it was such a pleasure (and delicious) to go to the tasting! On the day of the wedding, the cake arrived on time and was exactly how we wanted it! And even better, it tasted phenomenal! Now I can't wait for our anniversary so we can eat the rest of it! THANK YOU!
Reviewed On 10/09/2012 by Marissa O
Everyone at my wedding was ranting and raving about the cake. It was a simple yet beautiful design and it was delicious!! It was a 3 tier round ivory simple cake with a row of fall colored leaves running from top to bottom. They made it exactly...
like in the picture I showed them and it didnt cost more than $500. Great value for the price.
Reviewed On 10/08/2012 by Catie W
My cake was perfect, exactly what I wanted. I received so many compliments that not only was it pretty and unique but that it was also so delicious! Thank you!
Contact Info for Dortoni Bakery and Pastry Shoppe
3264 Hempstead Turnpike, Levittown, NY | Serving all of Long Island and the NY Tri-State Area