5 out of 5 stars and 94 reviews
5
(94)Best of Weddings (8x).Serving the Tri-State Area and all of Long Island
About this vendor
Here at Fanny Cakes we specialize in all natural, freshly made custom cakes and couture desserts. Our gourmet desserts are baked in small batches and made from scratch using the finest ingredients to quality and great taste. Our couture desserts are customized for each and every client ensuring that they are the perfect ending to your special day! We want you to experience dessert utopia when you bite into one of our delicious custom cakes and gourmet desserts!
Details
Business Attributes
- Woman-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Accessories
- Cake Stands
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
- Groom's Cakes
Dietary Options
- Gluten Free
- Nut Free
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.094 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 5
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
Wow! The presentation was absolutely stunning, and the cake itself was incredible. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about it, and even the toughest critics in our group had nothing but glowing praise!
We went in with high expectations, and Kristyn still managed to exceed them! We can’t recommend Fanny Cakes enough!
Our wedding cake experience with Fanny Cakes was nothing short of incredible! From the start, the staff was friendly and helpful, and always quick to communicate and answer any questions we had throughout the process. The cake was delicious, and they were able to seamlessly integrate into our wedding timeline (even though their bakery was one hour away from the wedding venue).
A few particular highlights below:
We knew we had picked the correct wedding cake designer upon leaving the tasting session. We were able to try many delicious options and combinations, which made it hard to choose because everything tasted amazing! We ultimately decided on a vanilla cake with lemon curd and raspberry mousse, and it was absolutely delicious.
For the design, we had the general idea of utilizing a simple textured white cake while incorporating our wedding flowers into the cake design. These designs, while simple, can be a little nerve racking because it is always up to the designer the day of to artistically assemble the cake design onsite with the actual wedding flowers. As such, outside of knowing that they had accommodated similar designs in the past, we were left trusting them that they could deliver us a similar cake on our wedding date. And are we glad we trusted them, as they delivered us exactly what we wanted - a simple yet elegant textured flower white wedding cake. Additionally, our guests couldn't stop raving about how wonderful it looked and tasted. We couldn’t be happier with how it all turned out and would recommend them to anyone looking for the perfect wedding cake!
Fanny Cakes did a phenomenal job, and we wholeheartedly recommend them. Additionally, we can’t wait to use their services for our future baking needs as the cake was delicious. Here is a picture of the cake for reference:
Kristyn and her mom were absolutely incredible to work with for our wedding cake! They responded to emails so quickly and had such a nice cake tasting set up for us. They were also so helpful at our tasting in seeing which cake flavors matched well with fillings and which fillings would work well with others, which we really appreciated. Their cakes are so fresh and absolutely delicious. We loved how they designed our wedding cake - it was truly just as we envisioned and we received so many compliments on it. The cake itself along with the fillings were absolutely delicious… the cake was so fresh and the fillings were incredible! I know we’re biased, but it truly was the freshest and best tasting/looking wedding cake ever! They also include an anniversary cake with your wedding cake flavors which is an added bonus that is very generous. Thank you for everything Fanny Cakes!
Very easy to work with and gave us exactly the cake we were looking for. And it was incredibly delicious! Couldn't recommend any more.
We had so much fun during our wedding cake tasting and our cake was not only beautiful, but also so delicious! It was exactly what we had wanted.
The cake was gorgeous, we showed pictures of what we wanted and they brought it to life perfectly. It was also delicious and just exactly what we wanted! Thank you.
Kristyn Weiser and her mom were great. Very professional and they made the process very easy. I showed them a picture on Pinterest and they captured my wedding cake just like I wanted. The Vanilla cake with salted caramel and cannoli filling was delicious my guest raved about.
Kristyn and her team were incredible! The tasting was so delicious and it was incredibly hard to choose just two flavors for our cake because they were all so good. Leading up to the wedding I was able to send over my cake flowers and topper without having to go in, which was really nice since I live in Manhattan. On the day of the wedding, the cake looked perfect and tasted incredible! I don't even know if we'll be able to resist eating our top tier that we saved for our anniversary, it is so tempting to eat it now and just use Fanny Cakes for all our future celebratory cake needs! I'd highly recommend them to anyone!
If you are looking for a beautiful cake creation, with delicate, delicious flavor, it is Famny Cakes. They listened to everything we wanted in a wedding cake and created our dream cake. It was stunning! So grateful. Thank you Fanny Cakes!
My husband and I used Fanny Cakes for our wedding this past July and we are still hearing about how delicious it was from our guests!! They truly put their heart and soul into baking the cake and the presentation as well. They were extremely accommodating at the tasting, allowing us to choose a variety beforehand so we felt confident in our choice for the day of. I highly recommend using them for your wedding- you will not be disappointed!!
Our wedding cake consultation was very smooth and fun! To be honest, I didn’t care for wedding cakes, as cakes were never memorable for me when I attended weddings. However, after going through the consultation process and finding a cake flavor my husband and I both loved, we became very excited for our guests to eat our cake because it was that delicious. Our theme was puzzle piece and they did an amazing job with the little puzzle pieces around the cake. The best part about fanny cakes is that they also baked me a fresh cake for my first year wedding anniversary which we thought was so cool! It tasted great just like the one they made on our wedding day 7/16/22. I would definitely recommend them to anyone who is having an event.
What a wonderful experience picking out our wedding cake! So sweet and easy to work with!!Once we found the perfect flavors for us not only did our cake look great but it tasted amazing!!!!
Kristyn and the entire staff were such a pleasure to work with. Kristyn patiently walked us through every step of the wedding cake selection process (from design, flavor, decoration, etc.), helped with the cake and filling tasting (she listened to what we like and don’t like and offered suggestions). The entire staff was very responsive to all of our questions throughout the entire process. The wedding cake the team created perfectly reflected our personalities and tasted absolutely delicious. We are 100% pleased with choosing Fanny Cakes to be an important part of our special day.
I was so happy with my cake- we went with Vanilla/Raspberry Mousse/Lightened Pastry Cream and it was delicious and also, beautiful! We asked for a rustic ring buttercream exterior with a seamless border, and had our florist add fresh flowers. It was the perfect wedding cake and the Fanny Cakes team was so easy and nice to work with!
It was an absolute pleasure working with Kristyn. We met with her to discuss what we wanted & followed up with a taste testing. There were so many cake flavors, fillings and frosting to choose from! Everything tasted amazing! I ran out of the bridal suite (mid-makeup) when I saw my wedding cake rolling by. It made me SO happy. Exactly what I envisioned. Couldn't have imagined a more gorgeous cake. Thank you so much!
Thank you Fanny Cakes for a delicious and beautiful wedding cake! Our cake was vanilla chocolate chip with chocolate buttercream and it was amazing! Krisytn was also a pleasure to work with!
Kristyn and the entire Fanny Cakes team were absolutely amazing to work with from start to finish! Our cake was everything we hoped it would be and more. It was delicious, it was beautiful and our guests did not stop raving about it!
Not only our wedding but the grooms cake that I surprised by husband with was the “icing on the cake”. Kristyn brought my vision to life so perfectly that my husband shed a tear when it was presented to him!
We cannot thank you all enough for allowing us to have shared these moments!
See you again for our next occasion!
Kristyn and Patty were a pleasure to deal with! From our initial cake tasting to making the final design decisions, we had a fantastic experience with Fanny Cakes. Not only was our cake exactly what we envisioned, it tasted delicious too! They had such a wide variety of flavors, it was tough for us to narrow it down! In addition to our wedding cake, we also ordered a few dozen cupcakes for our 'welcome party' the night before the wedding. The cupcakes were also phenomenal (tons of flavors to choose from as well) and we will definitely be using Fanny Cakes for our future parties!
Fanny Cakes was amazing to work with. After visiting another bakery, I am glad we had our tasting and ultimately decided to get our wedding cake from Fanny Cake. It was absolutely delicious and looked beautiful. The tasting was relaxed, we felt very welcomed and the women we met with were very helpful when it came to making decisions about our cake. We definitely recommend!
The cake I ordered was DELICIOUS and beautifully made! Thank you for making my day even more special. Without a doubt would book fanny cakes for another event!
Fanny Cakes was so wonderful to work with. First and most important- the cakes and frostings are DELICIOUS. We went with chocolate cake and raspberry mousse and vanilla cake with cannoli cream and they did not disappoint. The team was very professional and flexible given we were a pandemic postponement. From cake tasting (which was so, so fun) to execution of the cake everything was seamless. They made our vision come to life and we could not be happier! Definitely book them for your wedding!
Kristyn was absolutely wonderful to work with! When we met with her, we had no idea what we wanted in a cake but she walked us through every step. I was blown away with how our cake turned out. It wasn’t just gorgeous, it was so incredibly tasty as well!!
Everyone at Fanny Cakes was FANTASTIC!!!! We had to postpone our wedding 3 times, but they always worked with us. I worked directly with Kristyn Weiser and she was amazing. Our wedding cake was out of this world!! The design was absolutely gorgeous and tasted INCREDIBLE!!!!!!! The guests all said it was the best wedding cake and I am so glad there are leftovers so I can continue enjoying it! So fresh and flavorful. I can't recommend Fanny Cakes enough!!
Our wedding cake came out beautiful AND delicious! My one regret on my wedding day is not eating more pieces of my wedding cake! They were able to deliver exactly what we wanted and every flavor tasted so delicious that it was so hard to choose what we liked the best - but we were able to pick three flavors, all of which were amazing!
Fanny cakes is the absolute best. First, I was late for our original appointment as I travel very far from work. Kristyn and her team kindly waited, didn’t rush the appointment at all, and were a dream to work with. Our wedding cake came out stunning and they put our vision into reality - something simple, but eye catching and elegant. Even prior to that, we hired Fanny Cakes to make cake pops for my shower, which everyone also loved. Can’t put into words how great it was to work with Fanny Cakes - 10/10 recommend!!!!!
I cannot recommend Fanny Cakes enough for your special event. They brought my vision of an upside down wedding cake to life, it was not only beautiful, BUT so so delicious. She didn’t hesitate for one minute on this idea, and did everything she could to make my bridal dreams come true. I did not want a big wedding cake, so we came up with the idea of assorted cupcakes with our wedding cake. The cupcakes were so tasty and provided our guests with tons of variety. I was even shocked when I saw she put my monogram on each cupcake to bring a personal touch to the day. Fanny cakes brought all my wedding dessert visions to life! The owner was so accommodating and truly so wonderful to work with. She even made me a replica of my wedding cake for my first anniversary, Fanny Cakes makes their clients feel so special, especially on their wedding day and anniversary. The cake even tasted just like it did on our big day, it was amazing. Thank you Fanny Cakes for all your outstanding talent and expertise, I still get compliments on my wedding cake till this day. We will definitely be using you again in the future for an event.
Gorgeous cake, exactly what I envisioned!! Our wedding cake was banana with kahlua icing... it was unreal, I was dreaming about it ever since our tasting back in February 2020!
I cannot express enough how amazing our cake for our wedding was. First of all the cake tasting was fantastic and we ended up picking a flavor I would’ve never picked because it was beyond amazing (kahlua buttercream and coconut cake.) My husband and I wanted a very simple (yet delicious cake) and Fanny Cakes made us a cake that was beyond our expectations. It was beautiful and incredibly delicious. Our guests raved about the cake. From start to finish Fanny Cakes was very responsive, organized, and beyond kind. I am so grateful for their beautiful work. They are the best!
We found Fanny Cakes when looking around for vendors local to our wedding venue. We emailed them a sketch of what we wanted for our three tiered wedding cakes and they were able to recreate our vision! Patty was able to give us recommendations for flavor combinations based on our preferences and all of them tasted amazing, easily the tastiest cakes I’ve ever had at a wedding. We all scrambled for every last bit of the chocolate cake with Kahlua mousse! Everyone at our wedding loved our wedding cakes and we’re looking forward to working with Kristyn and Patty again for our anniversaries to come.
Fanny Cakes was a recommended vendor from our venue and Kristyn was such a pleasure to work with. They offer an array of cake flavors and fillings that are so unique. It was hard to narrow it down for our tasting but we decided on red velvet cake with espresso and Kahlua mousse for our wedding. Not only was our wedding cake delicious but it was also beautiful to look at it. It came out exactly how I pictured.
Fanny Cakes provided us with the wedding cake of our dreams! The process was fun and easy and we had a lot of options for the tasting; we never once felt pressured during it either. We felt Fanny Cakes had really unique cake and an extensive flavor list that most places don't offer. I didn't quite know what style I was looking for going into it, but the team provided me with some inspiration and turned my vision into a reality. We were very pleased with our experience!
Fanny Cakes is amazing! Our wedding cake was exactly what we were envisioning and tasted delicious too. Kristyn was super responsive and so easy to work with. Our wedding cake was absolutely perfect!
Thankful to Fanny Cakes for creating such an amazing (and delicious) cake. They were super helpful and timely in helping us design the cake and pick out the flavors. They were able to bring what we had in mind to life. It was such a hit!
Best wedding cake ever!
We've been to many weddings where the cake isn't tasty, only meant to look pretty -- and that's the expectation. Needless to say, we were surprised during the tasting when the cakes tasted amazing! We had a hard time choosing only 3 cupcake flavors.
The day of the wedding, our cupcake tower looked beautiful. And tasted just as amazing as we remembered during our consultation. Everything was delivered and set up on time. And they were very accommodating when we had to move our wedding and reduce the amount of cupcakes we needed.
For future parties, we will definitely be using them!
Everything they promised was delivered.... what’s more to say?
Cake was beautiful, tastefully decorated and delicious.
Coconut and strawberry filling was the best layer!!!
Don’t bother with anywhere else..... this is the cake of your dreams!!!
The Fanny Cakes team was amazing to work with for our wedding day! From the cake tasting all the way up to making changes the week before, they were patient and accommodating! I can’t recommend them enough!
Fanny Cakes was a no brainer for us! My brother and sister in law used Fanny Cakes for their wedding and I knew I had to visit. Kristyn and Patty were so easy to work with, my husband and I had so much fun at our tasting. We live and had our reception in Westchester, and Kristyn and Patty delivered our cake to us no problem! We chose them for their unique flavor options- our cake was an almond cake with amaretto mousse, and it was not only BEAUTIFUL, it tasted AMAZING. So many guests came up to us the next morning to tell us how great the cake was! We can't wait for our one year anniversary to eat some more :)
Fanny Cakes was one of our favorite vendors. From the initial conversation we knew they were a great team. They helped us create a perfect wedding cake by fusing together our ideas and their expertise we had a beautiful and very delicious wedding cake. They are warm, welcoming, perfectly priced, and experts in the field. I will be certainly using them for any future events.
I went to Fanny Cakes three days before my wedding because the lady I hired for desert cancelled. They were amazing at Fanny Cakes! They were so sweet and helpful, and made me feel at ease in a stressful situation. Everything looked so cute and tasted delicious! I would 100% recommend them!
Kristyn and her mom do a wonderful job! They are so friendly and easy to work with, and the final product was great! We had the funfetti with vanilla buttercream and the coconut with coconut caramel buttercream. We also had a grooms cake that was a facsimile of our miniature dachshund and my husband was THRILLED with it!
Fanny Cakes was AMAZING right from the start! They helped us narrow down exactly what we wanted and gave us such amazing ideas!! They were professional and very flexible. Not to mention the cake was DELICIOUS!!!!!!!!!! And absolutely stunning!!! Thank you so much for making our dream cake!!!
Where to begin, I’ll start of by thanking Kristyn and her team for making my wedding cake a dream come become reality . It all started with the initial meet and greet Kristyn for the first taste test/sample. It was just my husband, myself, Kristyn and Patty. All of of the attention given was shocking to to my husband who thought this process was much simpler. After a couple of samples we made our final choice and we weren’t disappointed. On the day of the unveiling(cutting the cake) I couldn’t believe how a drawing on a piece of paper could be so beautiful. I truly want to thank Kristyn for all her hard word and patience it took to make my special day more special with a beautiful dream come true cake. I will definitely use Fanny Cake for all of my cakes from now on so this will not be the last you see of me lol.
From the day we tasted cakes at fanny cakes Kristen and her mom made throw experience so easy and stress free for our wedding ! The cake is absolutely amazing and our cake was absolutely stunning ! We also used them for both of our daughters birthdays! I would recommend them for any occasion they are amazing and so sweet !
From the moment we had our tasting with Fanny Cakes we knew we made the right decision. Their love & warmth shines right into the taste of the cake and the care and effort they put into creating a beautiful cake that reflects the taste of the bride and groom. We couldn’t be happier. What little was left of our cake after the wedding we took home and cut in half, one half for our anniversary, and the other half well let’s just say it didn’t stand a chance. We devoured it immediately. Fanny Cakes is awesome!
Our wedding cake from Fanny Cakes was SO beautiful and exactly what we were looking for. Working with Kristyn and Patty was a pleasure - they are so responsive and great at what they do. And the cake was delicious! We went with a semi-naked cake and I gave them some inspiration pictures for what I wanted and they carried out my vision beautifully. I highly recommend Fanny Cakes. Thank you Kristyn and Patty for the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake!
My wedding cake was very important to me since I love all things dessert and from the moment I met Kristyn at Fanny Cakes and tasted her delicious cakes and fillings I knew my wedding cake was going to be amazing, and it sure was! She helped us come up with a unique filling combination to get it just the way I wanted since we had 3 fillings we just couldn't decide on! She loves what she does and you can tell when you taste her cakes! The best!!
Fanny cakes made a beautiful AND delicious cake for our wedding! they even made us a one year anniversary cake in the same flavors that our wedding cake was, so that we had a fresh piece to eat on our anniversary. They made our vision come to life with an elegant design including flowers to match our centerpieces. We got half vanilla chip cake with cannoli filling and half vanilla cake with cookies and cream mousse, and it was so delicious! I would recommend them 100%!
Fanny Cakes was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding cake! They are not your typical bakery that does wedding cakes. They DO wedding cakes. The bakery was beautiful and they provide a ton of images. The best part was the tasting! We picked Birthday Cake flavor with Vanilla Butter cream, so unique and our guests LOVED it! Kristyn is amazing and we felt we were in great hands from our very first email. We picked a simple design and they nailed it. We aren’t fondant people we went with smooth burger cream and it looked amazing. Look no further if you want the amazing wedding cake experience every bride wants!
Fanny cakes was an absolute pleasure. The cake turned out even more beautiful then I could have imagined and was so delicious. As a bride I missed my desserts Debuting the wedding. But we got to pick up leftovers the next day, and let’s just say I ate more then I should have. Lol.
If you want a beautiful, delicious cake done by the sweetest mother, daughter team. I recommend fanny cakes all the way.
We would definitely recommend Fanny cakes to any couples needing a wedding cake! My husband and I got married last week and we worked with fanny cakes! Kristyn was amazing to work with and everything went so smoothly and seamlessly throughout the planning process. Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious! We froze the top layer and can’t wait to eat it for our one year anniversary. Thanks, Fanny Cakes!
They were one of the best vendors we used for our wedding! They were so helpful in picking out a design. I wasn't exactly sure of what I wanted, but they narrowed it down and came up with the perfect cake. I had so many guests tell me that the cake was beautiful and delicious. I loved that they had many flavors to choose from and allowed us to mix and match. We never felt rushed during our appointment. The cake was delivered and setup on time. I never had to worry about this part of the wedding planning. I would definitely use them again for my special occasions.
Fanny Cakes was the perfect choice for our wedding, we could not have asked for better. Kristyn and Patty were so nice, and truly enjoyable to work with. We’ve had their cupcakes in the past - which are delicious - and explained how we preferred their cupcake flavor choices over a typical wedding cake. They went above and beyond providing us cupcake flavors that could be turned into the perfect cake. We had a tasting a few months prior, with 4 different cake flavors and 4-5 frosting possibilities to be paired with. We ended up choosing a 4-tier Snickerdoodle cake with graham cracker cake and cinnamon sugar cream cheese buttercream - perfect for our November wedding! It was wrapped in edible white lace with tiny edible gold pearls, and large hand piped white flowers for the bottom tier. It was beautiful, and delicious too! So many guests commented how the flavors went perfectly with our fall wedding. Would highly recommend Fanny Cakes to anyone!
Had an amazing experience with Fanny cakes! Within minutes of walking In the store Kristyn knew exactly what I had in mind! Had so much fun cake testing for our big day! I’m still receiving compliments on how amazing the cake both looked and tasted! Kristyn provided us with excellent service and was always extremely respectful! Highly recommend!
Krystyn is a truly imaginative and talented baker. The wedding cake she designed for my son snd daughter in love’s wedding was elegant and chic- and tasted delicious! The groom’s cake stole the slow- it was artistically executed with minute details. The groom’s cake was in the shape of the couple’s ring bearer dog, Cosmo - a mini long- haired daschund. The dog was a Boston sports fan’s dreamA Celtics team jersey and an extraordinary Fonda t baseball hat bearing the Red Sox, Celtics snd Bruin’s logos. Detailed included the paws and nails snd a curly- fur tail. The cake - sad to eat it- but was sooooo good. Kristyn a d her team are incredibly talented!! The most delicious and creative cake creations!!!!
Best bakery for wedding cakes! My husband and I met with them before the wedding and showed them a picture of what we wanted and they got it down to the T! Not to mention we picked 3 different flavor of cake and icing to taste test and everything was delicious. Definitely a hard choice. Everyone raved about how delicious our cake was and how beautiful it was as well. We were extremely happy!
Fanny Ckes provided us with the most beautiful and delcious cakes for our rehearsal dinner and wedding ! They were warm and helpful to work with and completely followed our vision and design ideas ! Our rehearsal dinner cake was a one of a kind police officers hat with badge and it was so beautifully made and realistic looking even down to the stitching! And our wedding cake was exactly what I pictured in my head with a partially naked style , pinecones, Flowers, an was so delicious. You will be beyond happy with the work they provide for your special event. I will definitely use them again!
Fanny Cakes made picking our wedding cake fun, easy, and quick! All their staff were extremely friendly and professional. We had a great time at our cake tasting and the process of designing our dream wedding cake was easy. Only difficult part was choosing from so many great flavours, as they all tasted incredible! We ended up going with a apple spice cake with salted caramel buttercream. Our wedding cake was absolutely delicious, looked amazing and was exactly what we wanted! Thank you so much to Kristyn and the team at Fanny Cakes.
I can understand why Kristyn is a preferred vendor at the Harbor Club- our guests are still raving about how delicious our cake was. Not only was our wedding cake beautiful, but it was also DELICIOUS! My husband and I were contemplating eating the top of our cake the day after our wedding instead of freezing it! Everyone I recommend Fanny Cakes to is blown away by their quality and how easy they are to work with. Thank you for your beautifully delicious work.
It took me a very long time to figure out exactly what I wanted our wedding cake to look like. When I finally made a decision, Kristyn made sure that she matched my vision perfectly. She even special ordered a mold to make sure I got exactly what I wanted for our wedding cake. We left our tasting stuffed with so many delicious cake options. She had so many options to choose from and one was better than the next. As for the day of our wedding, not only did our cake look beautiful, but it tasted amazing. By far, the best cake we ever tasted. Thanks for exceeding our expectations.
Kristyn and her mom, Patty, were so amazing to work with. I knew when we walked into their sparkling clean and beautifully decorated shop that these two women would definitely pay attention to detail when it came to my daughter's wedding! We chose an almond flavored cake with chocolate mousse/cannoli filling. Not only was it gorgeous and elegant to fit our venue (Harbor Club), it was truly the best wedding cake we have ever eaten, and the amount of compliments we received from our guests was astonishing! It didn't stop there. We had Fanny Cakes do the favors for the wedding, too! With all of the running around we had to do, it was brilliant on my part to enlist professionals to take care of this for us. (Yes...We actually thought for about a minute that we could do them on our own. No Way!!) They matched the exact colors that my daughter asked for and displayed the favors (macaroons) exquisitely in a box with ribbons and tags! They were absolutely delicious! I was smart enough to order extra for myself, so I continued to enjoy them days after the wedding! Thank you again, Kristyn and Patty for everything that you did for us! Can't wait to use you again for our next occasion!
Contact
127 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset, NY | Serving the Tri-State Area and all of Long Island
Fanny Cakes's photos