My husband and I loved our wedding cake from Magpie's!! I worked mainly with Ryan Huddleston, and she was awesome.
We had an Italian Cream wedding sheet cake with a fondant overlay- decorated to look like an old book (my husband is an Engli...sh scholar). I didn't give them a lot of direction, but when I saw the cake, I thought it was perfect. And my, my, my was it delicious. The entire cake got eaten!
We also had several dozen assorted cupcakes - they have regular sized, and mini-sized, so we did a mix of both, in their "deluxe" assorted flavors. The display was so pretty! I couldn't keep people away from the cupcakes - they were mostly eaten before we even cut our cake.
I would highly recommend Magpie's. Their cakes and cupcakes are delicious, and so charming. I know they do really elaborate cakes, but I really just wanted something that looked like real food, real dessert at least - and that is exactly what they made for us. They are easy to work with, and it is just obvious they take great pride in making desserts that people enjoy.