Dairy Free, Nut Free, Sugar Free, Vegan
Cake Tastings, Cakes + Desserts
Alex at Pastries by Design is amazing! She and her team made my wedding cake dreams come to life! Every other baker I called turned my ideas down or were outrageously priced. She not only made my cake, she made it better than I had imagined and it was affordable! We had 2 flavors and both were so yummy and moist. We don't live in the area, but every time we come to town, we stop in for cupcakes. Book her and you won't be disappointed!
Amazing quality and so easy to work with. We absolutely loved our wedding cake, it was beautiful and tasted great!! It was a huge hit. So happy we chose Pastries by Design!!
Very Helpful and affordableReviewed on 11/25/2015 Leigh T
Our cake was very simple and very affordable. They were able to work with our budget and help us conceptualize what we wanted for our beach wedding cake. She was even willing to make half of the layers out of styrofoam and nobody knew. The sheet cakes that we served the guests were delish!
YUM-GLUTEN FREE!Reviewed on 9/10/2015 Alina R
I was doing a destination wedding, and only had a week and a half at the location before the wedding. I was worried I wasn't going to be able to have a cake tasting, but when I emailed Alex, she put my mind at ease immediately. We had SO much fun at the cake tasting! The cake was so delicious (and I have a gluten allergy!), and my husband and parents got to try the regular (non gluten-free) cakes and they loved them as well! Alex was incredibly helpful and made sure that everything was going to be perfect. We ended up doing both gluten free and regular cakes, and we devoured them. SO DELICIOUS!!!
Yummy and Beautiful!Reviewed on 12/29/2014 Paula S
The cake was the Best wedding cake I have tasted in years. It was exactly what I wanted. It was moist and the buttercream icing was delicious. Highly recommend!
BEST CAKE EVERReviewed on 6/20/2014 Ariana D
We had a white chocolate raspberry cake! It was amazing! Everyone loved it and wanted seconds!
If I have to listen to my mother talk about this cake one more time....Reviewed on 4/17/2014 Caitlin C
It seems the overall consensus are that wedding cakes are typically pretty awful. Or at least that's opinion all of my guests shared about their experiences prior to our wedding. My husband and I don't eat sweet often, because, well, we just prefer meats and carbs. :) In fact, we didn't know even what to pick besides chocolate and amaretto. So, we didn't have much to compare it to during our tasting besides that it was pretty delicious and we like those flavors. Our wedding cake was one of those details neither of us had a strong opinion about. We picked out a design on Pintrest and a special topper on Etsy (https://www.etsy.com/shop/lollipopworkshop) and chose the highest recommended baker in Sarasota on theknot.com. However, this is evidently a HUGE detail for the guests. And, apparently, our cake was hands down the best wedding cake they have ever had. The cake and the food were all anyone talked about for days! In fact, it became everyone's go to late night snack after the ceremony. My mom still makes a point to mention the cake to anyone who asks about her daughter's wedding. It was very whimsical and looked identical to the picture we picked out. They also allowed lollipopworkshop to deliver the topper months in advance and stored it safely for us. Now, we will always use Pastries by Design for any party of event. Loved by all and delish, delish!
Fabulous cupcakes!Reviewed on 1/15/2014 Bonnie W
We did cupcakes instead of a traditional wedding cake, and Pastries by Design did an AMAZING job. They turned out really elegant (not hokey like some cupcake towers) and they tasted absolutely delicious. The ladies at the bakery are really professional and clearly passionate about what they do. We couldn't have been happier with everything.
Delicious!Reviewed on 1/09/2014 Michelle W
We chose Pastries by Design because our wedding cake was included in our wedding package. I really didn't want fondant on the cake because I think it is gross and they were very accomodating to planning a cake without it. The cake was delicious and just what I wanted. My only regret is that I didn't get to eat more of it at our wedding!
Perfect!Reviewed on 10/31/2013 Michele S
Pastries by DesignReviewed on 10/22/2013
Beautiful and delicious! Thank you!
oh my word Amazing!Reviewed on 8/01/2013 Malia G
The cake and cupcakes turned out amazing. We heard amazing reviews. They were very helpful when deciding what type of design we should do. Lindsy even drew a picture right there to help wash away my fears! I would highly recommend this bakery!
Best Wedding Cake Ever!!Reviewed on 6/09/2013 Nadia H
My husband, family, and all of our wedding guests couldn't say enough about the wedding cake! Lyndsy does an excellent job and really values a high quality. Her ingredients are fresh, organic, and locally sourced, and the taste of the cake showed it. It was a little on the pricey side for a four-tiered cake, but we went with two different flavors, one of them being a custom flavor and the other was one of their higher priced fillings. But trust me, it's worth it.
Delicious!Reviewed on 5/28/2013 Julia B
We met with Lyndsy, the owner, to do a tasting about 5 months prior to our wedding. I was so impressed that despite having a fabulous, upscale storefront, that she was not at all pushy and did not try to upsell us on things we did not need or want - she was completely down to earth. In her eyes I bet the cake I ordered was so boring and standard (they do a lot of wild, creative stuff), but she did exactly what I asked for and didn't try to sell me on anything crazy or more expensive. The cake turned out beautiful and delicious - we did not save the top since we are from out of state - so I ate the cake multiple times after the wedding - YUM! We also ordered some key lime glazed shortbread cookies for our welcome bags - the guests raved about them - and I couldn't stop eating the leftovers! They were to die for! I got a quote from Publix too for the cake - this only ended up being about $40 more - so worth the extra money for service and a wonderful product!
Stunning seashell cakeReviewed on 5/07/2013 Melissa B
I was so impressed with my wedding cake. I gave them a picture I wasn't sure Could be remade and they made it happen. Absolutely perfect and everything I hoped it would be. The different types of cake flavors were amazing!
Wedding cake of my dreamsReviewed on 5/05/2013 valorie m
When I went into my cake appt. I had a few ideas of what I wanted but in general I needed help deciding on the overall design. Lyndsy is so creative and had so many great ideas of what to do with it. It was effortless to come up with a design I loved pretty quickly. The day of the wedding it was gorgeous!! It was exactly as I hoped and it was delicious. Everybody was saying how good it was!! It's definitely the best cake I ever had. There was only one little mishap, my initial in our monogram fell before we cut the cake. So the V looked like an L. That wasn't really fun to look at in the pictures, but it was outside and the heat probably didn't help. Overall I am very pleased!!
Beautiful Cakes AND DeliciousReviewed on 3/27/2013 Courtney W
Lyndsy is so easy to work with! She makes amazing cakes that still taste great. We were thrilled with the design and look of our cake. We received rave reviews from our guests on the chocolate peanut butter flavor we chose!
FabulousReviewed on 1/14/2013 Jacqueline M
Lyndsay did a great job understanding what we wanted and within our budget. It turned out better than we could have imagined and tasted incredible!
AMAZING CAKES AND CUPCAKESReviewed on 11/27/2012 Hannah H
Wow! Pastries by Design really knows how to deliver! They did our wedding cake, groom's cake, and cupcakes. We had 105 people at our wedding and dessert for probably 200 and pretty much all of it was gone by the end of the night. We are still hearing wonderful reviews from our guest. We even had a guest order their cupcake cake through them because it was all that good. The groom's cake was a power line crossing water... It even had our dog sitting by the water... the groom loved it! Thank you for the wonderful cakes!!
DELISH!!!!Reviewed on 11/12/2012 Donna H
My mother really dislikes sweets & she devoured these cupcakes in 2 minutes... I knew this was the place to use! The tasting that was set up for us was amazing; I had no doubt that these treats would be perfect. I love to cook and came up with some crazy combinations (Mojito, Mai-Tai, and Mudslide cupcakes) - the chef loved it and made the best tasting cakes ever; literally tasted like the true drink! The bakery made the groom's cake (Ford logo), our couples cake (basic 6 inch round) & 90 cupcakes - so good!
Absolutely amazing!Reviewed on 11/04/2012 Christina C
Lyndsy is absolutely amazing! Our wedding cake was perfect and delicious. I took in a picture of what I wanted and that is exactly what I got. She is incredibly talented and super sweet. Our cake was so delicious that we asked her to bring 6 cupcakes the day of our wedding so my husband and I could have a late night snack after the wedding :)there were only two left when we got home the next day!
Wonderil ExperienceReviewed on 10/28/2012 Tara W
Lyndsey was wonderful. She took a picture and made it into a masterpiece that we could afford. She was so informative and easy going. It made the stress of choosing a cake easy!
We loved our cakes!!!Reviewed on 10/21/2012 Jen F
Lyndsy and team are fantastic! Our wedding cake and groom's cake not only looked amazing, but tasted amazing too! Lyndsy designed our wedding cake with so much detail - it was exactly how I envisioned it! And the groom's cake (a piano) was outstanding! All of our guests raved about how good the cake tasted. The carrot cake was our favorite - we highly recommend it!! Thank you Lyndsy! :)
Absolutely Stunning Cake, Just as good inside :)Reviewed on 6/15/2012 Carrie S
We ordered our cake from Lyndsy and Co. for our June Wedding in Longboat Key. We requested a Key Lime Cheesecake- our favorite -even after other bakers had told us that there was NO WAY. I sent her a picture of my flowers and a few cakes that caught my eye. I could not believe what was sitting on the table at the reception. It seriously took my breath away! Sounds silly, but seriously, it was fabulous! And then... we cut the cake. Oh, dear Lord. It was in fact the best Key Lime Cheescake that we, or our guests had ever had! Our guests are still talking about that bad boy! The cheesecake was 3 layers tall, with a fabulous fondant icing-it was perfect, not hard or chewy like others I have had. And then she covered it with hundreds of little pearls, and the most beautiful sugar orchids, roses and calla lillies; they had a little shimmer which was FABULOUS. We can't thank you enough Lyndsy and Co.! For the record, We tried to call a few times to thank you personally. I sure hope you see this- YOU ALL TOTALLY ROCK! I wish I could upload a picture. -C and R
Best cookies ever!Reviewed on 4/26/2012 Jessica F
I highly recommend Pastries by Design! We had them do a rehearsal dinner cake (in the shape of a ballot box), our wedding cake, and cookies for favors. Everything tasted incredible, and both cakes were absolutely beautiful. We had so many rave reviews about the cookies, as well. I was very happy with the product! I will say that it did take them a little while to respond to my questions via email, but other than that, working with Pastries by Design was a perfect experience!