We don‘t know Pie oh My!‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.
Pie oh My! Reviews
Share your thoughts with other couples
Reviewed On 11/14/2016 by Athena L
I'm not a huge cake person so we booked pies! Melennie was super helpful and attentive in helping us pick our pies. Her and Jane worked together to find the best solution in our budget so I appreciated that immensely. We went with traditiona...
l large pies and they did custom lattice on our wedding pie. Love them!
Reviewed On 7/28/2016 by Bekah C
We had pies instead of cake. Pie oh My! did an excellent job. It was delicious! And our pie buffet was one of my favorite features of our reception.
Reviewed On 7/01/2015 by Mollie S
I knew when I got engaged that I didn't want to do a wedding cake. I'm not a cake fan, and I find that more often than not taste is sacrificed for looks. We decided on pie because we both love it, and the moment I met Jane at Pie Oh My I knew I...
had made the right choice. Jane is so sweet and to the point and gave us exactly what we wanted (including a delicious tasting). Jane created 10 different flavors of pie for us--5 different flavors in normal size pies, and 5 different flavors in mini pies. Our guests were blown away. Not only was this a unique dessert, but it was absolutely delicious. I only wish we had gotten to try them all! Jane was so easy to work with, delivered them to the venue on the day of, and the price for what we got was extremely reasonable. I could not recommend Jane and her team more.
Reviewed On 10/23/2014 by Lauren
We had Pie Oh My make 120 mini pies to be served as favors at our Oct. 11th wedding reception, which happened to be an incredibly busy weekend for them with various events in Saint Louis. Not only were the pies delivered promptly, but their att...
ention to detail with the packaging & overall presentation was outstanding. Couldn't be happier! P.S. They are DELICIOUS! You will be back for seconds, it's guaranteed :)
Reviewed On 10/14/2014 by Aeric B
We opted for wedding pies instead of cakes. Cindy did a wonderful job and really went the extra mile to make sure our pies were perfect. Our guests loved them!
Reviewed On 6/16/2014 by Olivia S
The pies were a BIG hit. They were beautiful and tasted amazing. We loved the unique flavors and couldn't have been happier with the variety.
Our only issue was that we think they need to be more organized. We sent a check to them and had ...
a confirmation of pick up time and date. I also let them know the check was coming etc. When a friend got there to pick them up, she was told they didn't receive our payment. This was the DAY of the wedding!!! I get a call from my friend as I am literally in the midst of one of my emotional, "I am getting married moments" stating, "they didn't get your check!" That is the LAST thing a bride wants to hear as she is trying to keep it together. My friend then pays for the pies only to receive a phone call a short time later that they found the check. This is NOT ok.
Organization needs to be improved as they take on the wedding industry.
Reviewed On 10/17/2013 by Jessica K
They are the greatest! Wonderful to work with, creative, seasonal flavors of pies using local vendors as suppliers (think Schlafly Pumpkin Ale with pecans!), the prices are reasonable and they were genuinely excited to participate in our big da...
y. We ordered several pies from them and I stop in every few weeks just to have a slice because the flavors are always changing and I love the adorable little shop. Have them make you a pie!!!