We don‘t know Piece of Cake‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.
Awards and Affiliations
Piece of Cake Reviews
Share your thoughts with other couples
Reviewed On 9/10/2021 by Kayla S
If you’re looking for a delicious and beautiful wedding cake, go to Piece of Cake in Plymouth! Judy was so easy to work with and we were thrilled with how our wedding cake turned out. I have a gluten allergy, and she was even able to make the t...
op layer of our cake gluten-free. She was knowledgeable about cross contamination, which was a plus! She had a cute cake stand that we were able to use, which went with our rustic theme. Piece of Cake has our highest recommendation!
Reviewed On 8/22/2021 by Emily G
Piece of Cake was one of the bakers recommended to us from our venue. We are thrilled that we chose to work with Judy and the Piece of Cake team for our wedding. We chose to do a small cake for cutting and cupcakes rather than one large cake. N...
ot only did the cupcake display look amazing, but the cake and various different cupcake flavors were all delicious! We most definitely recommend Piece of Cake and will be returning to get some sweet treats in the future!
Reviewed On 8/11/2021 by Katelyn D
Piece of Cake was one of the preferred vendors for our wedding venue, and we are so happy to have worked with Judy and her team for our wedding day! From the cake tasting up until the actual wedding, Judy was amazing to work with and was so fle...
xible with our multiple postponements due to COVID. We ended up doing cupcakes for our guests and a small tasting cake for us to cut during our reception. Everything was beautiful and delicious! Our guests raved about the cupcakes and the setup of everything looked wonderful. We would wholeheartedly recommend Judy and her team at Piece of Cake to any couple in the market for a wedding cake or cupcakes!
Reviewed On 7/04/2021 by Aja J
Judy at Piece of Cake is wonderful! We had a small cake for cutting and 100+ cupcakes (including several that catered to dietary restrictions - vegan, GF, etc.) for our wedding at Pinehills and they were delicious! Judy was so helpful and easy ...
to work with. Highly recommend!
Reviewed On 8/20/2020 by Taylor G
Judy at Piece of Cake is great! She was the preferred bakery for our venue, but I knew about her work previously since I live in the same town. When our wedding got downsized due to Covid, we were easily able to change our order to match the si...
ze of our wedding. We got 3 flavors of cupcakes as well as a small cake to cut. They were all delicious!
Reviewed On 5/01/2020 by Ashley A
Piece of cake did such an amazing job with our wedding cake! They were super nice to work with & the cake was beautiful and delicious.
Reviewed On 4/21/2020 by Megan L
Judy and her team at Piece of Cake were amazing to work with! From day one, they made the process of choosing a wedding cake easy and efficient. They created a beautiful 3 tiered wedding cake, each tier a different flavor, that all tasted incre...
dible! They had also worked with our florist to place flowers on the cake; it turned out to be the most beautiful cake we’ve ever seen! We are beyond happy with our experience working with Piece of Cake and would highly recommend them!
Reviewed On 12/04/2019 by Katie A
From the very first meeting, Judy was amazing! We stopped by on a whim, and she was able to accommodate our tasting right away, and we absolutely loved everything we tried. She walked us through the process, gave us a ton of ideas, and helped...
us design our perfect wedding cake. She worked with our florist to add seasonal flowers to our cake. We were stunned by how beautiful the cake was, and how perfectly it fit our vision!! We would highly recommend Piece of Cake!
Reviewed On 11/25/2019 by Laura D
Piece of Cake baked us an amazing cake for our wedding cake! We had a three tier cake with two different flavors and covered in fruit and it was delicious and our guests loved it! I would highly recommend hiring them for your wedding or next ev...
Reviewed On 11/12/2019 by Emily A
Judy and her team at Piece of Cake made our vision of a wedding cake come to life. My husband and I had such a great time tasting all the different flavors and styles to be able to pick exactly what we wanted. She was able to match the cake col...
or to my exact wedding colors and it came out absolutely beautiful. We can't wait to eat the top March 23rd, 2020!
Reviewed On 8/07/2019 by Nicole P
Amazing and so delicious! Judy made everything so easy and was great to work with. We settled on the cupcake display instead of a traditional cake. I loved the amazing variety and the gorgeous dishes and trays that were used to display them all...
. Judy came to personally set up the display and it was just gorgeous and people raved about them all night!
Reviewed On 8/01/2019 by Lindsey R
Piece of cake did an amazing job with our wedding cake. The tasting was perfect, and from there the entire process was easy and efficient. The guests raved about how delicious the cake was!
Reviewed On 6/06/2019 by Danielle D
Best wedding cake I've ever tasted! It was delicious, and my husband and I can't wait to break out the top tier on our first anniversary! Judy was lovely to work with - so kind and professional, listened to what I was looking for, and execute...
d exactly what I wanted. Such a great experience here!
Reviewed On 2/21/2019 by Joanna K
Judy was absolutely amazing to work with! She was so patient and kind during our consultation, even gave my now husband a carrot cupcake to bring home because she heard him mention he wanted a carrot cake for our wedding (sorry, honey!). Everyo...
ne raved about the cake and we cannot wait to return for another special occasion!
Reviewed On 2/04/2019 by Maryann M
Piece of Cake did our wedding cupcakes and we couldn't have been more pleased!! The display itself was so beautiful and Judy did such a great job helping us make our vision come to life! We had 10 different flavors for our guests to choose from...
and we have gotten so many compliments on them! Judy and her team are very professional and her desserts are truly impeccable. We would highly recommend Piece of Cake!!
Reviewed On 1/15/2019 by Kelsie D
Judy is fantastic. She hand delivered it to our venue and that day made wonderful finishing touches with fresh flowers. During our cake tasting she was straightforward, kind, and very informational. We went with a white cake, lemon filling, van...
illa butter cream frosting and it was amazing and not too sweet which was very important to my husband! I actually don't eat sweets and even I loved our cake! Judy was wonderful to work with and we were so so happy with our wedding cake
Reviewed On 10/16/2018 by Amy R
Judy and her team are wonderful! They are a pleasure to work with, very responsive, and created a cake for us that was classically beautiful and incredibly delicious. They are also very affordable for the amazing work they do.
Reviewed On 6/03/2018 by Kaleigh P
Judy was amazing! The cake tasting was great and the cake came out exactly how I imagined! The florist brought flowers and Judy was able to put them on right at the venue hassle free! Everything went beautifully and the cake was amazing! Great ...
service and prices! I would highly recommend! The cookies and cupcakes from my bridal shower were amazing as well :) will def be going here for all future bakery needs!!
Reviewed On 11/20/2017 by Elise T
Each time we drove to Plymouth (from Boston) to meet with a vendor for the wedding, we were sure to stop at Piece of Cake’s waterfront location for a cup of coffee and a cupcake or cookie. It was therefore a no-brainer for us to ask Piece of Ca...
ke to create the cupcakes for the big day. Judy was VERY easy to work with and responsive via email and phone. Our tasting day was a lot of fun, and we were all impressed by the display, flavors, and attention. The day of the wedding, the display was beautiful and the guests had great things to say about all of the flavors (raspberry chocolate, salted caramel, coconut lemon, blueberry, and peanut butter). In addition to their wonderful baked goods and professional and friendly service, we were impressed by Piece of Cake’s thoughtfulness in offering gluten free cupcakes for several of our guests and needing to be sure that we had no severe nut allergies among our guests before agreeing to serving peanut butter cupcakes. Throughout the planning process and the day of the wedding, Judy and Piece of Cake took great care of us! We can’t wait to stop back in the next time we’re in Plymouth!
Reviewed On 9/07/2017 by Theresa H
What can I say other than FANTABULOUS!! Judy is amazing to work with. She is the absolute sweetest ever. She did an amazing job on our cake (it was a birch tree theme with our initials in a heart & orange flowers)! The flavor was incredible. Th...
e top tier was carrot & the bottom layer was actually chocolate & vanilla with raspberry filling & fresh raspberries. OMG! It was so good! Everyone loved the cake, so didn't my husband even though it was smeared on his face! LOL! Highly recommend!!!!
Reviewed On 8/22/2017 by Colleen M
Thank you to Judy and her team at Piece of Cake for the beautiful (and DELICIOUS) naked wedding cake!!
Reviewed On 7/31/2017 by Jill D
Judi and her staff are amazing! The cake tasting was a lot of fun and they were so easy to work with. Not only was the cake beautiful, but it was delicious! Highly recommend!!!
Reviewed On 2/07/2017 by Caitlin G
Judy is awesome! She and her staff did an awesome jobe with our rustic themed wedding back in November. The cake was beautiful and she really worked with us to come up with a great design. She also was great working with our venue and coordinat...
or. I highly recommend Judy and the Piece of Cake staff. You won't be disappointed.
Reviewed On 10/16/2016 by M R
Judy and the staff at Piece of Cake were fantastic throughout the entire wedding planning process. They made the cake tasting feel fun and intimate, and even offered extra cake and limited flavors because they truly wanted us to be happy w...
ith our wedding cake.
We ended up choosing a fall spice cake with apple pie filling, and all of our guests loved it. Judy made sure that the cake ribbon exactly matched our bridesmaids dresses, and even made cupcakes for the bridal shower that matched the theme of the shower and the wedding cake, which tied everything together nicely. The cake was beautiful, and exactly what we had imagined.
We would recommend Piece of Cake to everyone. Judy and staff were friendly, organized, and invested in our vision. We had a great experience!
-Lauren (Mike R's wife)
Reviewed On 8/17/2016 by Emily D
Our cake from Piece of Cake was delicious! We got a white cake with lemon filling that was a hit! Judy was such a pleasure to work with and she had wonderful ideas. She was also extremely accommodating - we were married outside on one of the ho...
ttest days in July and she arranged to deliver the cake just before the ceremony started to minimize the chance of the cake melting. She also used flowers left by our florist to decorate our cake and it looked exactly as I had envisioned it. I highly recommend Judy from Piece of Cake!
Reviewed On 7/05/2016 by Caitlin F
Our wedding cake came out beautiful! The cake was absolutely delicious too! Judy was very nice to work with and I would definitely recommend Piece of Cake to anyone!
Reviewed On 11/27/2015 by Nicole E
Piece of Cake made our wedding cake in September 2015. Not only was it beautiful, but it was absolutely delicious! Judy also has great attention to detail. She realized that the ribbon I wanted around each tier would look darker on the frosting...
than I anticipated, so she contacted me to suggest possible alternatives, and made sure I would be happy with the final outcome.
Reviewed On 9/06/2015 by Christine C
Great service! We had a wonderful time trying different cake flavors, and Debbie and her team were extremely helpful when we were trying to finalize our cake design. Everything came out beautifully and tasted delicious!
Reviewed On 8/25/2015 by Jessica M
We were scared at first to use a little cake baker from the small town in jersey called the villas but boy where we impressed! Our cake was not only beautiful and a perfect beach theme but it was so delicious! I never had a better tasting weddi...
ng cake! I highly recommend them if you are having your wedding in the south Jersey/shore area!
Reviewed On 5/11/2015 by Heather E
We absolutely LOVED our wedding cake from Judy at Piece of Cake! It was stunning and so delicious! We cannot wait for our anniversary to eat the top tier! From the get-go, Judy was so helpful. The cake tasting was so delicious and SO filling! I...
t was such a fun experience and we enjoyed every aspect of the process of working with Judy.
We plan on ordering many cakes from Judy in our future!!
Reviewed On 7/07/2014 by Caroline J
My husband and I were married at Pinehills in Plymouth, MA on 5/31/14 and our package included a cake from either Piece of Cake or Fratelli's. Unaware of both bakeries, we called both to make tasting appointments. We both instantly loved Judy. ...
Even though she knew we had other options within the contract, the tasting was hands off and she was not pushy whatsoever. She explained all of the flavors and showed us some pictures but then left us to try the flavors and look through designs on our own. She drafted a contract with everything I wanted and mailed it after the fact to our apartment, and we left pretty certain we would be using her, but appreciated that she allowed us to talk about it and make the decision on our own without ever feeling pressure.
The cake was beautiful and exactly what I wanted - three tier, white scroll detailing, yellow ribbon, and big white pearls along the edges. We had to flavors, the bottom was chocolate with raspberry filling and the top two were white cake with lemon filling. It tasted and looked unbelievable!
Reviewed On 3/08/2014 by Jane M
Reviewed On 9/25/2013 by Molly P
We used Judy at Piece of Cake in Plymouth, MA for our 08.17.13 wedding in Plymouth. Our cake fed 200 people for $500 - she delivered it to our venue - very easy to work with. We had a cake tasting and it was one of the more fun memories of pla...
nning the wedding. We went with a lemon cake, lemon filling, vanilla butter cream frosting and it was amazing and not too sweet which was very important to my husband! My cake was the most beautiful thing I have ever seen - Judy used cascading cobalt blue hydrangeas and daisies which made the cake look rustic and elegant at the same time. Judy is the best you must use her if you are getting married in the South Shore.
Reviewed On 5/22/2013 by Lauren V
Our cake was beyond what we could of asked for. A Piece of Cake Bakery understood my bridal vision and executed it perfectly. A few pictures I brought them from pinterest was all they needed to design our shabby chic fresh flower covered cake. ...
My husband loved our tasting and after getting stuck in traffic coming from Boston the owner was so sweet and accommodating. Its taking all of our will power to not defrost our saved "anniversary" piece of cake and enjoy it now instead.
Reviewed On 11/29/2012 by Kim L
Judy and her team are an absolute dream to work with. First off, their cupcakes are beyond delicious. They are simple, but so incredibly tasty. And there are so many different flavor and filling combinations so everyone will be satisfied! She t...
ook care of delivery, set up, and clean up without any hassle at all, and made our cupcake display look absolutely wonderful.
If you want delicious cake and a very easy baker to work with, then Judy and Piece of Cake are for you!!
Reviewed On 11/11/2012 by Megan B
We met Judy a few months before our wedding and she was the only cake place we met with. We heard so many overwhelmingly good reviews that we never felt it was necessary to look at others, and we still feel that way. My husband isn't a huge f...
an of cake, so i thought the tasting would be painful to be quite honest. I like any cake/baked good there is so this was never really on me. But after we started tasting them and he started to analyze and critique each, i knew we were on to something. Then we hit the golden cake with strawberry filling and he actually said he loved it! This was groundbreaking. We were sold. It was so good and everyone at the wedding talked about how good it was. Most of it ended up on my face so I can't wait for our 1-year anniversary to actually taste it!
On top of the taste of the cake, Judy was great. We ordered the cake without deciding on a cake topper and completely forgot about that aspect until the week of our wedding. Judy called and reminded us and since we still didn't have a cake topper offered to do our flower design on the top and it was gorgeous! She even matched our wedding blue to the cake so it matched, which was amazing!
If you are looking for a cake in the Plymouth area, definitely use Judy and Piece of Cake, you won't regret it!
Reviewed On 10/22/2012 by Melissa R
Our wedding cake was perfect. Judy did a great job marrying our wedding style with her creations. She used ribbon and suggested fresh flowers for the top; a real crowd pleaser! The tasting we had sold us from the start. We are so happy we used ...
A Piece of Cake. If we didn't freeze our top layer correctly (or if we did) we will be back for more!
Reviewed On 8/02/2012 by Julia B
Judy and her team created our dream cake and were so helpful in the whole process. We were able to try different cakes and frostings during our tasting and were served coffee and tea in cute china cups with saucers.Judyis outstanding at what sh...
e does and everything was yummy - it was all I really ate that night !
Reviewed On 6/13/2012 by Jane M
Our wedding cake was delicious, beautiful, and there when we needed it. Couldn't have been better, and Judy was so nice!
Reviewed On 10/27/2011 by Kelly P
I loved working with these guys. Our cake tasting was really yummy and a lot of fun. They made us a square three level cake that had giant pink polka dots on it and black ribbon around each layer. We loved the way the cake tasted and looked!
Reviewed On 10/14/2011 by Amy S
Piece of Cake was awesome! Judy and Jackie were so friendly at the tasting. The cake was beautiful, exactly what we wanted. It was delicious too and completely affordable.
Reviewed On 10/06/2011 by Carrianne H
Judy made our day perfect, what a beautiful cake and of course yummy too! Here perfessionalism was terrific. I would recommend Piece of Cake to any bride!
Reviewed On 9/23/2010 by Bree S
I got a simple topper and 100 cupcakes (3 flavors). Everything tasted really great, but the look was really nothing special. Two out of three of our cupcakes had fillings, so there was a yellow cupcake with Bavarian cream, a chocolate cupcake w...
ith raspberry filling and a red velvet. I have rarely seen cupcakes with fillings, so I thought this was a really fun option.
Reviewed On 8/27/2010 by Crystal M
I was never planning on having an actual cake, when I realized I did need one the search was on. So when we stopped into the shop a week and a half from the wedding I was pretty sure I would be laughed out of the place. Which was far from what...
The staff were all very nice and very helpful. They were able to get a cake together for us with time to spare.
I only had a bite of cake at the cake cutting. Everyone that did have cake said it was great.
The only downfall which is my own fault(other than not eating a piece of my own cake)is our wedding was two hours from Plymouth, so we had to bring it up ourselves. I don't think the cake liked traveling, it sort of drooped by the time we got it to the venue.
Reviewed On 8/09/2010 by Cynthia C
My cake was beautiful but a little sweet.
Reviewed On 5/10/2010 by Megan R
I knew what i wanted.. so it was easy. The price i got was decent! Everyone said how good the cake was--but i didn't get a chance to eat it :(
Reviewed On 5/10/2010 by Amy O
Pam is very easy to work with and she is one of the least expensive cake bakers around. The cake looked great and tasted great as well.
Reviewed On 5/10/2010 by Heather H
I have known this woman for a long time she is a friend of the family. But she was amazing!
Reviewed On 5/10/2010 by Nelle J
easy to work with and best price around- close to wedding venue
Reviewed On 8/25/2007 by Sarah G
very willing to do any design, gave us an excellent cake tasting...very laid back