Sweet Stuff Bakery

Such a great flavor selection and great price for our cupcake wedding!!

Robynne was amazing to work with! She was very collaborative and helped us design the perfect cake for our big day! We sent her pictures of some examples of what we'd like to see on the outside and they delivered, matching our colors very well! The cake was also extremely yummy (got 1 tier with 3 layers - white, orange, white for a dreamsicle flavor) - beautiful inside and out!

Sweet Stuff Bakery baked a beautiful and delicious, multi-flavored, 3 tiered wedding cake for our daughter's wedding last weekend and we couldn't be happier with our choice! Guests kept going back for seconds! We were told that a wedding with an open bar doesn't eat much cake but that was not the case! People loved it!

We LOVED our cake and got so many compliments on it! It was simple yet elegant. We had to do a virtual cake testing due to covid, but honestly it was fine and the following day we got a call from them asking our opinions on the cake flavors! We got lemon for our top tier and white for the bottom and both flavors were amazing. Also, instead of having to save the top of the cake for a year, they make you a free small cake on your one year anniversary! 100% recommend!

Most delicious cake ever! Sweet Stuff was easy to work with and helped me create my dream wedding cake design and worked directly with my florist to make sure he had every thing he needed to execute his part.

Cakes were awesome !! They were a bit late getting to the venue, but everything else was great. No one knew but me and the event coordinator. From the first meeting with them to review and make the order, to the last bite...very easy to work with and great flavor!

The Sweet Stuff Bakery provided 8 amazing cake flavors for my tasting. They allowed me to sample them at home due to COVID. So many of my guests raved about our wedding cake and said it was the best cake they’ve ever had! We highly recommend the strawberry and banana hummingbird.

Our cake was beautiful and so delicious! Me and my new husband thank you from the bottom of our hearts!

We decided to go with Sweet Stuff for our wedding cake. The cake was absolutely BEAUTIFUL. It was even more gorgeous than what we’d imagined. We had the bottom tier lemon and the top tier strawberry, and it was such a hit for our summer wedding! The tastiest cake ever, and I kept getting compliments about the icing!

Sweet Stuff was excellent to work with every step of the way! They made the whole process easy from deciding flavors to picking a design! Everyone was extremely friendly and tried to make the process as easy as possible!

Sweet Stuff is the BEST! They are SO easy to work with. Our tasting was great. Going over the pricing with the owner was so easy. The cake looked and tasted perfectly! We also ordered our rehearsal dinner cakes from Sweet Stuff and they were just as good! I would recommend Sweet Stuff to any bride!!

OMG our cake was wonderful. We loved Sweet Stuff - everything went off without a hitch and our cake was delicious. We love that they'll make us a whole new cake topper for our anniversary. The tasting was really fun, and the cake itself was the best we've ever had. Book them!! You won't regret it!!

Not only was our cake more beautiful than I had imagined, but it tasted great too! We had a few cake tastings scheduled after Sweet Stuff, but signed the contract with Sweet Stuff minutes after tasting the cake- it was that good! It was one of the things I couldn’t stop talking about leading up to the wedding. I couldn’t wait for everyone to eat it! We choose 4 flavors: yellow, strawberry, hummingbird, and lemon. The lemon and hummingbird were my personal favorites! Because wedding days are a bit crazy, I didn’t see the cake until it was time for dinner. I literally stopped in my tracks and gasped- I could not believe how amazing it looked! It was absolutely perfect! Diane was so great to work with and truly brought my vision to life! When it comes to cake tasting, you have to put Sweet Stuff at the top of the list!

Love Sweet Stuff! Diane was amazing to work with! Our cake was perfect & she helped us to have the best flavors. Not only was it delish & but it was beautiful!

I've never tasted better cake! They were very easy to work with and quickly came up with a design for our "Jeep" groom's cake.

Amazing flavors, designs, prices, and staff!

Our wedding cake turned out exactly how we wanted it and the guests gave so many compliments about the cupcakes! Sweet Stuff has great service and was very accommodating every time we called with changes.

Best wedding cake ever!!!! And pretty great pricing! Staff is awesome to work with!

We had our wedding cake and some decorative cookies made. And they were absolutely delicious!! They made our vision come to life and it all tasted out of this world!

Sweet stuff is the best Stuff!! We had our wedding cake made here and everything turned out great!! The flavors were delicious! Everything was beautiful and the staff was very helpful in picking out what we wanted! It was great! Thank you so much for everything!!

Sweet Stuff Bakery has an awesome staff!! From the time we went in for our cake tasting up until our wedding day, they made sure that all of our request were met. They took the time with us to make sure that our cake was just that “OUR CAKE.” We had 3 tiers & 3 different flavors and also a 1/2 sheet cake. The cake was very moist & so good. I definitely recommend Sweet Stuff for any of your bakey needs.

Best cake I've ever tasted! Diane and her team are wonderful! They created an absolutely amazing Groom's cake and wedding cake for me. Their cakes are so moist and flavorful and the icings are so fluffy, smooth and delicious! My guests were raving about how delicious the different layers of cake were. Both cakes far exceeded my expectations. Sweet Stuff knows cakes and they do it well!

Best wedding cake ever! Diane and her team worked with us to design a cake that fit our budget while still allowing us to get the best wedding cake in town for our wedding. We got the yellow and hummingbird cakes and our guests raved about them both. Unlike most wedding cakes, the flavor was perfectly balanced and the cake itself was still moist at the time of serving. Only wish I'd gotten to eat more than one piece!

I've used Sweet Stuff since moving to So. IN 20 years ago. I email a picture and they always exceed my expectations! I have tried several flavor cakes and all have been delicious but Banana Hummingbird is my favorite! Highly recommend!!

Wow was this cake delicious! We had the ability to select a different flavor for each tier with the Almond being my favorite. Our venue packed us a bag with two pieces of each flavor and my husband and I were eating wedding cake the entire week following our event. I can't wait until our one year anniversary when Sweet Stuff will gift us an anniversary cake. I will definitely use Sweet Stuff for other cake catering needs.

Our wedding cake turned out not only beautiful, but delicious as well! It was so moist and we had so many guests tell us it was excellent. The grooms cake turned out very nice too and they were very professional to work with. We definitely recommend using Sweet Stuff Bakery. They do not disappoint!

I love cake. I eat it a lot. Sweet Stuff is by far the best cake I have had in the Louisville area. For my wedding, I got a two-tier strawberry cake, and a half chocolate/half yellow sheet cake. Both were moist and beautiful. Also, the staff is great. Patient, competent, didn't try to upsell.

The cake tasted and looked fabulous! I could not have picked a better place to get any cake from. Great customer service as well! I highly recommend for all events.

They did a beautiful job on our wedding cake and dessert bar! Loved working with them.

I had so many complements on how tasty the cake was, personally I was too busy to eat a piece, but we have the top tier here at home to eat! Mainly because Sweet Stuff actually will remake out top tier on our 1 year anniversary so I don't have to try to find a freezer to keep it in! They are a value compared to another very popular bakery in New Albany and taste just a good for half the price! And our rather unusual request for a grooms cake was no problem for Sweet Stuff!

It was wonderful working with Diane to design our wedding cake and treats. In addition to a gorgeous cake, we also had dessert trays and cookies. Diane made the process simple and fun, and best of all, everything was delicious!

Our cake was non-traditional in flavors, but very traditional in appearance, and this bakery delivered in both! It was absolutely breathtaking and delicious. We will be having the same flavors (strawberry, lemon, and orange) in many birthday cakes to come!

Diane was great at our first meeting! She printed a picture from my Pintrest and was very receptive to our ideas. She delivered on time and everyone loved the cake.

Customer service is amazing. My favorite part about ordering from Sweet Stuff Bakery is that I didn't have to save the top part of my cake for our anniversary. They bake us a brand new one. I don't think there is one flavor that I tried that I didn't like. Each flavor is just perfect!

Let me first say that my husband and I did taste testings at several other bakeries, and Sweet Stuff was our favorite by far! Hands down best wedding cake I've ever had. And they did a fabulous job on the design I asked for (which looked rather difficult to do). We also loved that they use buttercream icing instead of fondant. It was so light and fluffy! I loved it and I usually hate icing! Everything about it was amazing. We couldn't be more happy with how our cake turned out. It was average priced- a little more expensive than a couple of other bakeries we looked into, but it's worth it in my book!

Sweet stuff is awesome to work with. She really tries to get a feel for your personality and make every cake unique. Their cake is also the most delicious cake that we tried. Bonus: instead of saving your top tier, she includes an anniversary cake that you can order fresh one year after your wedding!

The cake design was beautiful and the cake tasted amazing! They will also make the top layer of your wedding cake for free on your first anniversary!

Sweet stuff did an amazing job on our wedding cake! The cake was delicious, all 5 flavors! We were able to get an extra sheet cake along with our tiered cake to accommodate all our guests. They were very easy to work with and decorated our cake from a picture I found online! Exactly what we wanted! They are even including a fresh top tier to our cake in a year, so we didn't have to save ours! Highly recommend!

Sweet Stuff worked with me on the design and the taste. They can make any cake happen. It was perfect and everyone raved about the taste. It was perfect. Last minute they created a grooms cake that was awesome. I'm so grateful. The. It's was the most reasonable around. Best bang for your buck here!!

They work with you to help decide what you want. It was exactly what I wanted! And super delicious. Best part is you get to order your 1-year anniversary cake you don't have to freeze it.

We went to sweet stuff because I love their sugar cookies with white chocolate icing. When we went in for the first meeting it seemed awesome and they could make us exactly what we wanted. When we went in for the mock up and couple weeks before the wedding, they couldn't do that now and what they could do was not pretty. We finally came to a resolution and then comes the wedding day. The cake was beautiful. Here were the issues....the cake toppers were on there completely. Then, the bottom layer of our cake WAS frozen still. Supposedly, they don't freeze them. It was just a rather disappointing experience for 400 plus dollars. The cake(that wasn't frozen) was delicious and the buttercream icing was great

Diane knocked i tout of the park on my wedding cake! Wow, I never imagined I could have such a beautiful cake that tasted so great. I personally think cake is tough to perfect, especially when making an art piece of it, but Sweet Stuff did better than imaginable. The cake was so moist, perfectly sweet, and if I haven't said yet, simply stunning. I took Diane a picture of a cake I loved, a complex cake at that, and there is stood at my reception, EXACTLY as I wanted! But more than just the look, the taste is what amazes me. It shouldn't...a professional baker should be able to make a decorated cake that tastes great. But you go to so many weddings and the cake is just cake. Many people don't eat it or just take a bite for something sweet. But I got multiple compliments on my cake. Everyone LOVED the red velvet. My husband and I are carrot cake connoisseurs, and that is the layer we cut into. I had the stomach bug on my wedding day and even then knew the carrot cake was to die for. I proved this theory on Christmas as my family surprised me with a miniature version of my wedding cake which was just as pretty as the first one and withstood the TRUE test of tastiness as we all had time to sit down and simply enjoy each bite of the delicious cake. Diane fulfilled our dream of the wedding cake, creating the look and flavors we wanted. She did THREE different flavors of cake (all so tasty), and made them into the wedding cake of my dreams. The amazing part to me was that the wedding cake displayed was actually the cake served! I have talked to many vendors who serve sheet cakes now and decorate styrofoam. This is truly a PERFECT service review of Sweet Stuff Bakery - Thank you!

I searched the web for the perfect cake. I was able to meet with Diane and present my ideas, piecing together my favorite parts of various cakes. I received exactly what I had envisioned. The cake was not only gorgeous but incredibly delicious. Their work was clean, precise, and professional. We enjoy baking and decorating cakes, but I would definitely use Sweet Stuff again.

We wanted to have a dessert table of mini desserts and a cake for us to cut. Sweet Stuff was able to do mini size brownies, cupcakes, cheese cakes and so much more! It was a huge hit amongst everyone and we were happy to be able to choose desserts we liked. The value is fabulous with Sweet Stuff. You get amazingly delicious desserts at a cost that is very reasonable. The staff was also very nice, helpful and willing to meet all of our needs! Would definitely recommend them.

I am rating this place a 5 star because their cake is amazing. We got a 3 layered cake with 3 different flavors and I must say all 3 was the best cake I have ever had. The cake turned out to be beautiful me and my Husband was very pleased I would highly recommend to go there!