Sophia and Jake danced to "I Wanna Dance With Somebody" by Ben Rector for their first dance. "It felt more like us because it wasn’t a cheesy slow song, but a romantic version of a dance song," Sophia says. "Plus, I started crying every time I heard it during our engagement. It started off as a joke that we would use it, but then we just went with it. I loved our first dance. We didn’t plan it, but started off slow dancing and ended up actually dancing."