Melissa & Jeff in Minneapolis, MN

At first glance, Jeff Brunson was so not Melissa Falk's type. She was into clean-cut preppy guys, and Jeff was a long-haired skater boy. The Bride Melissa Falk The Groom Jeff Brunson The Date October 31 Still, the two became friends after meeting at a regional church group gathering and it wasn't long before Melissa felt like she could talk to Jeff about anything. They tried long-distance dating (she lived in Minneapolis and he was in Iowa), but broke up until a visit from Jeff reignited their romance. He proposed a year later, and at their Halloween wedding, they had a Nightmare Before Christmas inspired wedding cake.