Bree & Dave in Los Angeles, CA

While on her first date with Dave, Bree kept her mouth shut about the stained furniture in his apartment. And it’s a good thing: She ended up spilling an entire can of soda on the carpet! Bree and Dave, who met through a mutual friend, dated for about five years before moving in together. The Bride Bree Tichy, 29, graduate student The Groom Dave Callaham, 31, screenwriter The Date May 9 On the first night in their new home, the two were in their pajamas and eating take-out Chinese food among the cardboard boxes that were littering the floor. Dave surprised Bree with a bottle of champagne and after toasting to their new home and their future, he got down on one knee and proposed. Since Bree responded by bursting into tears, Dave says he isn’t sure they were ever technically engaged.