What Johnny planned for the couple as a 'brief get away to slow down around the holiday season' turned into Alli's dream proposal on a romantic beach in Falmouth, Jamaica on December 11, 2022.

On the first night of their vacation, Johnny surprised Alli with a private dinner on the beach set up for just the two of them. As they walked towards the table admiring the Jamaican sunset, Johnny pulled Alli to the side, got down on one knee, and asked her to marry him.

EASY YES.

The proposal was complete with touches of Sunny, a personalized engraved ring box, and the sweetest and funniest waiter, Alexander! Johnny and Alli spent the next (??) hours happy crying at the table, making googly eyes at each other, and completely forgetting to actually eat dinner. They eventually ended the night facetiming their family and best friends to share the news.

The next three days were spent lounging on the beach, bamboo river rafting, eating delicious food, and learning the correct usage of "fiance" vs. "fiancee." It was a dream.