Keegan and Alli first met in 2015 through a mutual friend. After several years of on and off conversations with Alli in college in PA and Keegan enlisted in the U.S. Coast Guard, they reconnected in 2020 while Keegan was stationed in Cape May.

Keegan posted a picture in the area and Alli messaged Keegan via instagram. They ended up talking all night. Their first date was at Asbury Ale House in September 2020, and Keegan officially asked Alli, "Want to call it what it is?" on October 2nd.

After 3.5 years of dating, Keegan, Alli, and Sunny (their dog) moved in together in late 2023.

Keegan knew since 'calling it what it is', he would propose one day. He received permission from Allison's parents in July of 2024, although if you ask him he's not sure since he might have blacked out from how nervous he was asking Mr. and Mrs. Butow.

He proposed on October 19th, 2024, at Spring Lake Beach, one of their favorite places to go during the summer.

Cheer's to the future Mr. and Mrs. Pindar!