Caleb and Ally met the way that most people meet in Rexburg, Idaho…the dating app Mutual. Their first date was on September 19th and they were supposed to go get sodas. Ally teases Caleb that she zinged the moment she saw him and it was love at first sight, however, while Ally was falling in love Caleb was quickly changing his date plans because after seeing Ally he decided getting sodas was not good enough. So, they went mini golfing and Ally beat Caleb at golfing so fast that he had to quickly think on his feet again and decided to play pool. As Caleb was throwing the pool game so that Ally could win he decided to run to the bathroom, however, instead of going to the bathroom he was actually deleting his Mutual account. After an amazing first date they both kept finding ways to keep the dates coming and Caleb found the ultimate way by asking Ally to be his girlfriend on September 22nd. After deciding that they wanted this to keep going for eternity Caleb asked Ally to be his wife on December 23rd.