Angela & Anthony had their first date on June 28, 2022, at Tommy's Tavern. They got lost in conversation and laughed over the fact that they went through the Nutley school system and see the same chiropractor, yet, never ran into one another. The pair became inseparable and tried to schedule as many dates as possible with the busy summer approaching. Soon after, they introduced each other to their families and both fit right in. Fast forward to August 9, Anthony was dog sitting Penny and Zola for his brother and sister-in-law, and invited Angela over to cook her dinner. Angela agreed, but the night was less than perfect. Penny got ahold of the entire fresh mozzarella ball and Zola was less than thrilled to meet a new person. Angela convinced herself this would be their last date, since Zola wouldn't stop barking or let the couple sit near each other on the couch. Little did she know, later that night, Anthony would officially ask her to be his girlfriend. And the rest is history!