Caitlin and Andrew first connected on match.com. The two talked for several months before meeting up for the first time in person in Feburary of 2019. When they first meet spakrs started to fly when they were discussing their love of movies and books. Caitlin and Andrew would continue to have several dates and made their relationship offical in September of 2019.

On November 12,2022, Andrew asked Caitlin to marry him in their home with the help of friends.