Our story begins like many epic love tales — in the crowded, fluorescent-lit halls of high school. Caitlyn noticed Toby because he never brought a pencil to class. Toby noticed Caitlyn because she always had a pencil... and eventually gave him one. True love? Not yet. But it was a strong start.

Over the next few years, we navigated school dance pictures, awkward teenage phases, bad haircuts, college life, and the eternal question of “what’s for dinner?” Together, we’ve survived seven years of love, laughter, and debates over what to watch on Netflix.

Now, we’re making it official — with slightly better hair, slightly more adult responsibilities, and way more love (and snacks) than we started with. We’re so excited to celebrate with all the people who’ve cheered us on — and maybe lent us a pencil or two along the way. Thank you for being part of our journey and joining us to celebrate this special day!