Caity & Cole were first introduced through their mutual friends, Brooks and Kaitlyn. Brooks coordinated an evening for the two to meet at Caity's apartment in Spring of 2019. Caity and Cole went on several dates before they ended their relationship early.

After 6 months, the two rekindled their relationship after Caity attended one of Cole's wrestling matches at The Citadel. They have remained together ever since that day. Cole officially asked Caity to be his girlfriend on December 26, 2020.

Cole and Caity have been together through some of the most important days of their lives thus far, including Caity's college graduation from Charleston Southern University in 2021, Caity's acceptance into her Master's program for Clinical Counseling, the last two years of Cole's collegiate wrestling career, Cole's Ring Ceremony and graduation from The Citadel in 2022, and Cole's Commissioning ceremony into the United States Army on May 5, 2022.

On July 30, 2022 after 7 months of planning Cole's best kept secret, Cole asked Caity to spend the rest of her life with him. Shortly after proposing, Cole was called down to Columbus, GA to begin his career in the Army. The couple has continued their engagement while Caity remains in Charleston and Cole continues his career in Columbus. The two are ecstatic to end their long distance relationship as they join together as one on June 10th, 2023 with all of their loved ones!