Nathan and Caroline met on Saturday May 15, 2021. Just two weeks after Caroline decorated her new condo to be a bachelorette pad as she thought she'd never find a quality person to date. Then along came Nathan who was so incredibly smart and genuine, and also kind and excited to find someone to commit to as much as Caroline was. As cheesy as it is to say now, they really did know they were the ones for each other within the first few weeks of dating. Thank god for online dating!