First Impressions

Carolyn’s Version: When we met in Atlanta during a Marine Corps mobilization, my first thought was… nothing. Absolutely nothing. Then one day, at a staff meeting in civilian clothes, I saw his legs. These were not “nice legs” legs. These were legendary, could-carry-a-whole-platoon legs. I thought, Okay… who is this walking miracle?

Jonathan’s Version: When we met, my first thought was, “Wow… she’s way too busy to notice me.” I was right. Took civilian clothes and my superhero legs for her to finally acknowledge my existence.

How We Met

Carolyn’s Version: We barely spoke in Atlanta. Then we moved to Parris Island and fate—or tacos—intervened. The staff went out for tacos and margaritas, and somehow Jonathan and I ended up sharing a giant margarita that could have hydrated an entire city. Between sips, he talked about his family, and I thought, Wow… I want a man who talks like that. Also, If he drinks any more, he’s going to topple over. From then on, I started noticing him more—tall, confident, and basically Captain America… if Captain America had sniper training, a mischievous grin, and a onesie collection.

Jonathan’s Version: She says we “ended up” sharing a giant margarita. Truth: I didn’t want to drink that monster alone. Her impressed face when I talked about family? Sealed the deal. She also says I look like Captain America. I’ll allow it.

The Ring Pop Proposal

Carolyn’s Version: Years later, we were still in a group chat. I posted a wedding tug-of-war video and joked, “Whoever marries me will regret this—I have a ton of brothers.” Jonathan replied, “I thought we were getting married.” I said, “My hand looks empty.” He sent a Ring Pop. We all laughed. A few days later, he messaged me privately and asked if I’d marry him for real. I waited thirty minutes—because suspense is romantic—and said yes.

Jonathan’s Version: She baited me. I went with a Ring Pop because, honestly, nothing says “I love you” like sugar-coated plastic. Then I asked properly, and she made me wait thirty minutes. I considered retracting the proposal out of dramatic principle.

Our First Weekend

Carolyn’s Version: After two weeks of nightly marathon texts, I flew to Memphis. I kissed him at the airport—because priorities—and we spent the weekend doing thrilling adult things: professional bull riding, the Bass Pro Shop pyramid, and eating enough BBQ to make a competitive eater blush. The highlight? Our onesie party. I was a sloth, he was a banana. We looked ridiculous—but in love. He made me breakfast… for the first and, apparently, the last time. Turns out cooking is not his superpower. And it wasn’t the last onesie party. Jonathan owns over 30 onesies. Suddenly it all made sense why he was fully prepared for the Christmas onesie party back at Parris Island. This man is always ready. Always. When I went through TSA to leave, I ugly cried like a full-on, public meltdown. The agent asked if I was okay—I wanted to say, No, I just met my person, and it’s too much. I called my grandma and said, “He’s the one.”

Jonathan’s Version: She kissed me at the airport. No “Hi,” just straight to business. Then I gave her the Memphis tour: bull riding, Bass Pro pyramid, BBQ… and onesies. She was a sloth, I was a banana. Absolutely ridiculous. I made her breakfast for the first time…and apparently the last. Cooking is not my forte. She cried at TSA. I thought she just really hated security lines. Oh, and she’s officially figured out I own over 30 onesies, which explains the Parris Island Christmas party domination.

The Real Proposal

Carolyn’s Version: Jonathan joined me on a trip to Puerto Rico in February 2025. On our anniversary night, I planned dinner after working all day. I gave him two restaurant options—he refused to choose—so I picked a rooftop spot. We took enough sunset photos to fill a coffee table book, shared entirely too many mojitos, and soaked in the view. After dinner, we walked to the fountain in Ponce. I asked what he wanted to do next. He said, “Marry you,” got down on one knee, and voilà—I’m officially his fiancée.

Jonathan’s Version: She asked me to pick a restaurant. I didn’t want to pick wrong, so I punted. She nailed it: rooftop, sunset, mojitos, perfection. We walked to the fountain. She asked, “What do you want to do next?” I said, “Marry you,” knee down, heart racing, world slightly better than before.

What We Love Most About Each Other

Carolyn about Jonathan: He’s steady, selfless, and makes me feel safe—whether we’re at a rooftop in Puerto Rico or a Bass Pro Shop pyramid. He makes me laugh every day, loves his family fiercely, and has legs that deserve their own fan club. Also… he owns over 30 onesies, so basically he’s prepared for life.

Jonathan about Carolyn: She’s strong, stubborn, and somehow still the funniest person I know. She works harder than anyone, loves deeply, and keeps life interesting. Also… she cries at TSA, which, yes, is adorable.

Registry