First Date, Stop #1: Dinner at Rolling Stonebaker Pizza in Valparaiso. Emilija and Joe first meet each other after connecting on Catholic Match a week before.

First Date, Stop #2: Seeing promise, Emilija invites Joe to get ice cream at Valpo Velvet down the road to continue their conversation.

First Date, Stop #3: Seeing promise himself, Joe invites Emilija to finish the first date by playing some tennis at a local court. A discussion of favorite saints soon ensues.