E & E really got to know and love each other throughout the time they spent together in New Haven. Emily was living downtown, and she and Erin would frequent the bars and restaurants in the area often. They always hung out at the Anchor, an awesome little dive bar which was right across the street from Emily's apartment.

The night of the engagement, they were heading to New Haven for a screening of Rocky Horror Picture Show on Mischief Night. They started off with Old Fashioneds at the newly renovated Anchor Bar. Not the same, but reminiscent in locale nonetheless. Emily was going to propose here, but decided to hold off until he moment felt right. They were sitting at Elm City Social drinking cocktails named "Psycho Killer," and Emily could not wait another second. She pulled out the ring and asked Erin if she would be her wife. Erin of course said yes, and they celebrated the remainder of the evening at College Street Music Hall watching the show.

Registry