As of September 9th 2018, rates for December 14-16, 2018 are $100/night. It's a 2 star motel with fairly good reviews at almost 4 stars. Budget friendly.
2.2 Miles from the American Hotel.
Use Google Flights to help you find the cheapest flight. You put in your departure and arrival airports with your dates and Google Flights will help you find the cheapest day to fly on. Feel free to come a day or two early if you want to see NYC or other fun places nearby (see Things To Do Tab) if that is how you get the best price.
This website lets you put in your airports/dates and compare flights with multiple website (Be prepared for MULTIPLE windows that pop up, one for each website chosen). That can help you get the best deal as well.
As of September 9, 2018, rates are between $90-100 a night. It is budget friendly, almost 4 stars. It is also 2.2 miles from the American Hotel. It is next to the Freehold Motel
We recommend a cheaper alternative to rental cars are getting Ubers or Lyft rides either to & from the airport and/or around town. Everything is fairly close by though.
Uber.com or Lyft.com
As of September 9, 2018 rates are about $198/night. It is 2.9 miles from the American Hotel. Four star hotel.