Once upon a time, their mutual friend Matt decided to play matchmaker based on very tiny details that he learned about Julisa. When Luke asked Julisa to go on a date, he thought only about the day of the week, and tried to make their first date fall on Valentine's Day. Not wanting to jinx it, they opted for two days later instead. That day, it snowed around 6 inches in Evansville. When they arrived at Red Robin, it was closed due to the snow. So, they ended up at Old Chicago (RIP) next door instead. As they browsed the menu, they decided to split a pepperoni and bacon pizza. As the waitress began to walk away, Luke asked for pineapple on half. Julisa said they could put pineapple on the whole thing, and that's when she knew it was meant to be.