Wedding Day

Our Lady of the Isle Church

Ceremony

SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill

Optional: The Bar at SALT will be open in between the ceremony and reception

The Boathouse Shelter Island

Reception

After Party

Last Ferry to Greenport (North Ferry) is 11:45p.m. 

Last ferry to Sag Harbor (South Ferry) is 1:45a.m.

Our Wedding

When we first met… Freshman year at Fairfield 2014

Fairfield, Connecticut

When we started dating Winter 2019

Hunter Mountain, New York

Sloppy Tuna 2019… RIP Summer 2019

Sloppy Tuna, Montauk

Our first vacation together! Winter 2020

Bahamas 

Endless sunset cruises Summer 2020

Three Mile Harbor, East Hampton

The start of many Vermont trips! Winter 2021

Mount Snow, Vermont

More summers out east! Summer 2021

Montauk, New York 

Kali’s Law School Graduation Summer 2022

New York Law School

Forever wedding dates Spring 2023

Sarasota, Florida

Our first time skiing out west Winter 2023

Park City, Utah

Key West, Florida

Maidstone Beach, East Hampton 

Engaged at our favorite place!!! December 14, 2024

Ditch Plains, Montauk

Our Story

Photos

Katherine Heritage 

Danielle Ferrara

Regina Ferrara

Victoria Graham

Josette Santana

Shannon Reahl

Agatha Reed

Erin Reilly

Amanda Ludwig 

Anna White 

Angela Emmolo

Ellie Mangus

Chase Nolan 

Bryan Reilly 

Ray Garvey 

Enzo Lucarelli

Connor Geoghan 

Tyler Reed

Tom Heritage

Shane Mitchell

Chuck Schlegel 

Adam Ritzer

Wedding Party

Q + A

Shelter Island Hotel Options 

*Two night minimum stay required.This hotel is owned by the same team as our venue and is located very close by, so it’s a super convenient option if you’re still looking for a place to stay on Shelter Island.&nbsp;It is blocked for our wedding ONLY, unless all rooms are not used. Please book using the code: KALIJOE26 ***make sure to type in under PROMO CODE

The Shelter Island House

Greenport Hotel Options (take the North Ferry to Shelter Island, 3 minute ferry ride)

*Two night minimum stay required. Use the link below to book our room blockWalking distance from the ferry

The Menhaden 

*One night stay permitted.While we do not have a room block for this hotel, you can book your own room. It is walking distance from the ferry and next to The Menhaden.

The Harbor Front Inn 

This hotel is not walking distance from the ferry, but is on the sound in Greenport.

Cliffside Resort And Condominums 

Air Bnbs on Shelter Island  or Greenport 

We recommend checking out Air Bnbs or houses for rent on VRBO if you have a group! Feel free to reach out if you have any questions!

Travel

Thank you for making the trip to celebrate with us! Here are some of our recommendations and favorite places to visit on and off of Shelter Island!

If you are joining us from out of town….

Shelter Island Country Club

Crescent Beach, Shelter Island

Located in Greenport right next to the North Ferry! Dockside bar with good food and live music.

Claudios Waterfront

Located in Greenport, a short walk from the North Ferry. Great drinks and outdoor bar!

American Beech

Visit Sag Harbor by taking the South Ferry from Shelter Island to Sag Harbor. There are tons of restaurants, shops, boutiques, and bars!

Kali & Joe

Kali & Joe

Wedding Party