They met at their youth group at Crosspoint Community Church in Oconomowoc when they were just 15! Their older siblings were close friends before Eli and Kaylee had met, before Kaylee moved to the Oconomowoc area. They knew that the families would get along great and that Kaylee and Eli should definitely meet! Their families became good friends, hosting each other's game nights and spending time together at church as well.
Beuna Vista, Colorado. Eli knew that Kaylee adored the mountains (I mean, who doesn't?) and planned the proposal as a part of a road trip with her siblings. On a hidden lake in the middle of the mountains in a small town, on a rainy day, he knew this was exactly her dream spot. Safe to say she said YES!