The two met on Hinge where Lorelei made the first move and messaged Anthony about his "lovely singing voice." Much to Anthony's chagrin, she ghosted him for two weeks before messaging him again. After their conversation reignited, the two had their first date at Taqueria el Camino. After hours of exuberant conversation, the two realized that the restaurant had closed, 30 mins previous. Lorelei and Anthony quickly fell for each other and became an official couple on the evening of November 3, 2023. Since then, the two have nurtured a long distance relationship (Colorado to Maine), and have only grown in their love for each other. On October 5, 2025, while Lorelei was visiting Denver, Anthony proposed at the Denver Botanical Gardens. The two are eagerly awaiting to become husband and wife, and spend the rest of their lives side by side.