Mike & Hayley

April 6, 2024 • Pittsburgh, PA

Mike & Hayley

April 6, 2024 • Pittsburgh, PA

Our Story

Our Story

One night at a Bible study in Florida, Hayley met Annemarie, who insisted she set her up with her brother-in-law. But Hayley was already talking to another guy at the time, so she declined ☹.

November 07, 2022

One night at a Bible study in Florida, Hayley met Annemarie, who insisted she set her up with her brother-in-law. But Hayley was already talking to another guy at the time, so she declined ☹.
Meanwhile, far off in Pittsburgh, Mike was giving up on dating. He had received several calls from Tom and Annemarie about this "dietitian girl", but for all he knew she was dating someone. However, in mid-November, the tone changed. Annemarie and Tom shared the great news that Hayley was "very single"!!

November 17, 2022

Meanwhile, far off in Pittsburgh, Mike was giving up on dating. He had received several calls from Tom and Annemarie about this "dietitian girl", but for all he knew she was dating someone. However, in mid-November, the tone changed. Annemarie and Tom shared the great news that Hayley was "very single"!!
Annemarie took Hayley’s number, email, and height measurements and delivered them to Mike (the brother-in-law). Little did Hayley know, Tom added her number to their phone as "Mike's future wife."

December 14, 2022

Annemarie took Hayley’s number, email, and height measurements and delivered them to Mike (the brother-in-law). Little did Hayley know, Tom added her number to their phone as "Mike's future wife."
Hayley received a text from Mike. The next day, Hayley responded and they set up a phone call date, which lasted nearly 3 hours. Mike thought it went great. Hayley was nervous because she thought it ended abruptly and awkwardly.

That afternoon, Annemarie invited Hayley over to her house for dinner. Everyone was doing their best to hide their hopes and excitement over the development.

December 15, 2022

Hayley received a text from Mike. The next day, Hayley responded and they set up a phone call date, which lasted nearly 3 hours. Mike thought it went great. Hayley was nervous because she thought it ended abruptly and awkwardly. That afternoon, Annemarie invited Hayley over to her house for dinner. Everyone was doing their best to hide their hopes and excitement over the development.
The time had come for them to finally meet in person. They were both super nervous. Though, they agreed that if things didn't go well in person, they would simply continue to video chat for the rest of their lives since that was going swimmingly.
Mike arrived, bearing flowers and all the waiting and anticipation was put to rest as they strolled the park, hand in hand.

January 29, 2023

The time had come for them to finally meet in person. They were both super nervous. Though, they agreed that if things didn't go well in person, they would simply continue to video chat for the rest of their lives since that was going swimmingly. Mike arrived, bearing flowers and all the waiting and anticipation was put to rest as they strolled the park, hand in hand.
The weekend progressed with ease and laughter. They spent the first day together at Tom and Annemarie's, Mass, and then a romantic dinner by the beach. They spent the next day at The Kennedy Space Center, stopping off at Buccees on the way home. United in Buccees onesies, Mike bravely attempted the DTR talk (what a man). They were officially dating!

January 30, 2023

The weekend progressed with ease and laughter. They spent the first day together at Tom and Annemarie's, Mass, and then a romantic dinner by the beach. They spent the next day at The Kennedy Space Center, stopping off at Buccees on the way home. United in Buccees onesies, Mike bravely attempted the DTR talk (what a man). They were officially dating!
The following weekend, Mike headed back to Daytona Beach to take Hayley to a Valentine's Day dance, where they danced to Mike's new favorite song, "The One." They spent the rest of the weekend exploring the Ponce Inlet Lighthouse and took a Rosary walk on the beach before Mike returned to PA. Both Hayley and Mike could tell the weekend was blessed with prayers from loved ones as it went so smoothly.

February 04, 2023

The following weekend, Mike headed back to Daytona Beach to take Hayley to a Valentine's Day dance, where they danced to Mike's new favorite song, "The One." They spent the rest of the weekend exploring the Ponce Inlet Lighthouse and took a Rosary walk on the beach before Mike returned to PA. Both Hayley and Mike could tell the weekend was blessed with prayers from loved ones as it went so smoothly.
After several months of long-distance dating, both Mike and Hayley knew they had met the person they would spend the rest of their lives with.

April 06, 2023

After several months of long-distance dating, both Mike and Hayley knew they had met the person they would spend the rest of their lives with.

The Proposal

On July 25, four days before Hayley’s birthday, Mike was in Adoration when he felt the conviction to surprise Hayley in Florida with a proposal on her birthday. He had no ring and no flight. Was this even possible?


Mike began strategizing with Tom and Annemarie. He made a few phone calls and found that the exact ring she wanted (in Colorado) happened to be in stock and they could ship it to arrive by Friday. Minutes later, Mike got off work, booked a flight, and called Hayley’s dad who graciously gave his blessing.


Saturday morning, July 29th, Mike was in Florida, and gave Hayley a birthday call, asking what she was up to that day. She said she was going to stop at the beach. That was not specific enough for Mike. He interrogated, “what beach?” Thanks to Annemarie’s extra interrogations, Mike eventually found Hayley sitting with her mom, secluded on the beach. Mike called out “Hayley” from a stone’s throw away. She turned her head, and her face radiated with a big smile. She walked over in disbelief and gave him a big hug, shocked he had surprised her for her birthday. Mike held her hands, looked into her beautiful eyes and said, “It was six months ago today when we first met…” Hayley realized what was happening and said, “Are you really doing this?” He responded, “Yes. I want to spend the rest of my life with you.” Going down on one knee, he said, “Hayley Kathleen, will you marry me?” She nodded her head yes and said, “yes, of course!”