Sam and Andrew connected through a series of what some might consider "fated" encounters. Walking by her salon one day, Andrew spied Sam and couldn't resist the opportunity to talk with her so he stopped in for haircut. As luck would have it, they continued to run into each other throughout Columbus and bonded over astrology. After they both incidentally found themselves in North Carolina on separate trips, they decided to meet up. They bonded over some yoga and rock climbing. Fast forward some time later and Andrew, knowing Sam's love of all things witchy, took Sam on a trip to Salem, MA. With his mom and Sam's parents present, he popped the question.