The summer of 2021, Tiffany's Twinster moms decided to make Tiffany a dating profile on Bumble. A whole year passes and by the summer of 2022, Tiffany has yet to go on a date. Unsatisfied with her dating efforts, the Twinster moms gave Tiffany a deadline to go on a date by the end of the summer. Well, just luckily enough, Tiffany was chatting on Bumble with a teacher named Reagan, who lived in West Seattle, who also happened to be a father of twins. He asked her to a concert. However, that day didn't work for Tiffany, so they continued chatting. One evening at a high school football game, while Tiffany was updating her Twinster moms on her dating status, they decided to take matters into their own hands (again) and took Tiffany's phone and each took turns crafting and editing an invite for a future date with Reagan. They anxiously waited for his response, and by the time they were walking to their cars after the game, Reagan said he would love to go on a date!

On September 13, 2022, Tiffany had her first and last Bumble date. One date turned into many more and the two fell in love. On a chilly February 10th evening in 2023, by a campfire at Lake Tapps, Reagan proposed to Tiffany.

Reagan moved in with his two sons and a hamster, joining Tiffany, her daughters and two cats, creating their own Brady Bunch-like household. Two teachers, each parents of twins, finally found each other....and fell in love. Isn't life amazing?