Joe and Alexa got engaged in the same spot they had originally met, the Barnes and Noble bookstore downtown Naperville on January 20, 2024. Joe planned to propose just one day before the store closed! What was supposed to be a relaxing Saturday became a moment in time they would never forget. Alexa was in shock as Joe got down on one knee and proposed with a professional photographer waiting! She, of course, said yes! They proceeded to have a photoshoot downtown Naperville in just 10 degree weather! After their photoshoot, they went to have a steak dinner at Sullivan's steakhouse. Although most would think the night was over, there were guests awaiting Alexa and Joe's arrival at the Wunderlich household. Joe had planned a surprise engagement party with the mother of the bride, Michelle. The night was absolutely unforgettable!