"As a lot of the kids do these days," Kevin and Amy first connected via an online dating site in 2015. Amy had just moved to Rochester and wanted to pace herself in the dating world, especially since she had also recovered from double-jaw surgery and did not want to shock anyone with her remaining braces and limited diet. Even so, she could not help but send a message to the smiling face with a well-crafted profile that had popped up one day during a random search. Kevin was meticulous in choice of photos and did not shy away from expanding on his interests in television and video games. After several carefully worded e-mail exchanges with good intentions and comical undertones, they finally agreed to meet in person.

Kevin had suggested taking a walk by the Pittsford Canal. He smoothly added that "if things go well, we could get dinner." This caveat only daunted and intrigued Amy even more. After all, on "The Bachelor," contestants are only awarded an extension to their one-on-one date after receiving a rose, a sign of a satisfactory connection. With well-guarded poker faces, Amy and Kevin ended up walking in the rain (classic upstate New York) for hours. But unsurprisingly, both parties passed!

Amy was relieved and impressed when Kevin provided a list of options for dinner. They settled on Simply Crepes, the same restaurant that had catered his sister's wedding only a few months earlier. Kevin and Amy realized that they both shared a similar taste in cuisine as well as a propensity for seeking out the richest desserts. The night ended across the street at Pittsford Farms Dairy with a debate over the ending to "Falling Skies" over a shared dish of ice cream.

True to form and using a line Amy would come to mock unceasingly, Kevin waved and promised, "my people will call your people."