To arrive at St. John the Evangelist if traveling southbound on I-87, take Exit 17 for I-84 W(Scranton) and be sure to bear left for the Scranton/Stewart Airport ramp. Merge onto I-84W, proceed for 17 miles before taking Exit 19A for NY-17E toward New York City. In three miles, take Exit 122A for Goshen. In a quarter mile, make a left turn onto Fletcher Street. Continue for one half of a mile before turning left onto Golden Hill Road. In a quarter mile make a slight right onto Delta Place followed by a right turn onto North Church Street. Make a left turn onto Murray Avenue.

If traveling northbound on I-87, use the left two lanes to take Exit 16 for NY-17 toward US-6/Harriman. Continue on NY-17 W for 13 miles. Take Exit 124 toward NY-17A/NY-207/Florida/Goshen. In a quarter mile, turn right onto North Connector Road. In one half of a mile, turn left onto South Street. In one half mile, turn left onto South Church Street. Make a right onto Murray Avenue.