After a turbulent summer of different life events, including Ethan's breakup, Libby and Ethan found comfort while leaning on each other for support. At this time they realized their friendship was turning into something much more.

In December 2022 Ethan had planned to officially ask Libby to be his girlfriend when she took him through the light show (Making Spirits Bright) for the first time. However, Libby would not stop talking during the experience explaining every little detail as she is obsessed with the light show. Ethan decided to let her enjoy this moment and he would ask her on her birthday. On January 10th, 2023 Ethan took Libby to Legend Larry's for her birthday dinner. Afterwards, he took her for a drive by the Sheboygan airport so she could stare at the lights. This is her favorite place in Sheboygan County and where Ethan officially asked her to be his girlfriend!