The Cape has many air bnb and vrbo options to check out locally in Harwich and Chatham.
A few local options are listed below, but if you are looking for a traditional hotel, you should look in Hyannis.
2025 Rates not available yet. Multiple room options varying from ocean view, pool view, courtyard view. 2 night minimum but owner mentioned being able to accommodate single night stays due to it being off season for the Cape.
Single night reservations available, additional $20 for a single night stay.