Places to eat on Shelter Island.

Casual places to eat:

- Shelter Island Pharmacy Lunch Counter: A classic lunch counter with a retro vibe inside the only Pharmacy on the island. It is small but serves delish diner food and a pretty good lobster roll.

- Shelter Island Slice: Serving casual Italian food and pizza this is a great place to pick up from. A good less pricey take-out option.

- Maria's Kitchen: Located next to the Shelter island Brewery, Marias does take out Mexican food. Pro tip: get a drink at the brewery and order from Maria's for a chill dinner out and good vibe.

- Eccentric Bagel: The only bagel place on the island which is good for grab and go breakfast and lunch options.

- Marie Eiffel Market: A "fancy" market where you can get breakfast and lunch items. It is grab and go but also has seating on the water in the back of the market. Pro tip: This is a must visit (in the opinion of the bride) , but if you are looking to keep the price low may just want to grab a snack, coffee, and sit int the back on the water.

- Stars Cafe: A fave of the Berman's, Stars serves really delish breakfast and lunch. Good for grab and go but also has limited seating inside and outside.

- The Islander : Looking to keep costs lower? Want a place that serves all 3 meals with out door and indoor seating? The Islander diner is for you! Very casual and beachy vibe with classic diner food.

Sit Down Dining:

- SALT Waterfront Bar and Grill: If you are interested in waterfront dining this is your best option on the island. Open for lunch and dinner SALT serves delish food at a beautiful location (the same boatyard where the wedding is being held). Pro Tip: make a reservation and know that is on the pricer side.

- Isola: Located in the Shelter Island Heights area, Isola serves dinner with indoor and outdoor dining.

- 1901 Grill:

- Leon 1909: If you are looking for a fancy dinner with really really good food highly recommend checking this place out. Incredible vibe serving the best burger the bride has ever had. pro tip: Make a reservation way in advance!

- Vine Street Cafe: Another great option for a fancy dinner out. Pro tip: Make a reservation way in advance!

- Sunset Beach: Right on Crescent Beach, this restaurant is the most trendy place on the island and attracts celebs! Cool place to grab a drink or get dinner.

- The Terrace : Outdoor dining at a cool hotel on the island. Great place for dinner or a drink.

Transportation