Reuben likes one of Lauren's Hinge pictures

Lauren, a notoriously slow texter, finally responded days later, thrilled that Reuben had included a dog photo on his profile (a classic yet effective technique). They then launched into an impressively unremarkable conversation

Lauren & Reuben have their first date at Variety Coffee Roasters on the Upper East Side in Lauren's old neighborhood. They spoke of comedy and architecture. The date was fine, but nothing to write home about

Lauren & Reuben have their second date at Drinkology in Astoria in Reuben's old neighborhood. They spoke of Chuck Norris and told each other inappropriate jokes. During this date, they had finally found that *spark*

Lauren & Reuben become an official couple

After a spirited evening at Reuben's company Christmas party, he tells Lauren he loves her

Lauren & Reuben say "I love you"—this time, sober

Lauren & Reuben move in together

This isn't a part of our story, Reuben just looks hot in this picture and you should all get a chance to see it

Reuben pops the question during a trip to Chicago! Lauren was surprised, Reuben was romantic, and the evening ended with a sketch/improv show at Second City. It was perfect.

OUR WEDDING! We remember it like it was tomorrow