Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop

We LOVED our cake and desserts from Aggie's! Our great experience all started with our tasting, which was so pleasantly well done and was so tasty. We got to try basically everything they had to offer. The way they did their tastings compared to other shops allowed us to really try everything. We were between Simma's and Aggie's. In the end, the cake was so much better from Aggie's, it made our decision easy. We decided to do a cake and a dessert table, we ordered an assortment of desserts for our table that were a HUGE hit at our wedding. In addition, whevener you get a wedding cake from Aggie's, they provide a free small cake to you on your anniversary, so no need to save in the freezer. Our experience was amazing, highly reccommend Aggie's for your wedding.

From the begining of the process Aggie's has been very clear and professional with everything. We completed two tasting and finally decided on the flavor and size of cake. On the day of the wedding Aggie's delivered and displayed the cake so beautiful my husband and I were taken back. It was beautiful and delicious. The process was so stress-free as well. They were very up front with pricing and due dates. Very satisfied with their business.

We had an extravagant vision for our wedding cake that Aggie executed so well. Not only did the cake look amazing but it tasted great too. Look at what they did!

We were so happy we chose Aggie’s for our wedding cake. The cake was delicious. Rachel was so organized & easy to work with. We needed to change our original order from a large tiered cake to cupcakes due to restrictions at our venue & Rachel made that transition easy. The small cutting cake we got was beautifully decorated. Since our original tasting, Aggie’s cakes have become a favorite in our family & we have enjoyed them at many birthdays & holidays.

Aggie's was a pleasure to work with! From the cake tasting to design process, everything was well laid out and Rachel was extremely easy to communicate with. Our cake was absolutely delicious, we got so many compliments on how yummy it was. The cake itself was beautifully decorated

We had a great experience with Aggie's! Rachel was fantastic to work with, everything was organized, and our tasting was really helpful and fun. We did a mini dessert table and everything looked at tasted wonderful. Happy to support this local business and looking forward to our complimentary cake for our anniversary!

I had a great experience with Aggies. I enjoyed the tasting- the flavors, variety, and the flexibility. We were able to mix and match and pick the perfect combo. Then I loved the cake design and flavor we chose, as well as the cupcakes. We had a variety for everyone to choose from. Everything worked out perfectly- delivered on time and as planned. Everyone was happy. Their other desserts are also amazing. I am so happy we went with Aggies and would recommend them to family and friends.

We absolutely love Aggie's. We would get holiday desserts from them and when we were planning our wedding, we knew it had to be them to do our desserts! They were super helpful during every step of the process. We ended up going with cupcakes for our guests and a cutting cake for us. Everyone loved the flavors, highly recommend!

10/10 Aggies was fantastic. We worked with Rachel for our tasting/consultation and she was so knowledgeable and helpful. They were truley so great to work with. Our cake was perfect amd so delicious! We were going to pick it up Friday but had a change in schedule and they were so accommodating and had no problem with us picking up the morning of the wedding and thats actually what they preferred they said.

Aggie’s Bakery was a delicious and incredibly flexible option for our wedding. We ended up getting about 8 different dessert types from them and there was no extra charges as long as you met minimum dessert amounts. Everything they made was outstanding and looked very presentable on the day! We got a lot of compliments about them and any time we go to the Milwaukee area from now on it’ll be a favorite stop for us!

We had a very positive experience working with Rachel at Aggie’s for our wedding. It was obvious that they are a very experienced vendor that operates very smoothly. The tasting appointment made the process very easy to understand all of the options, customization, and pricing. They really could do it all with wedding desserts! We got a small two tier cake for photo purposes that we served to the wedding party along with variety of mini desserts for the guests. To make it easy, we paid to rent a dessert stand and have Aggie’s deliver and set it up which made it stress free on the wedding day. A tray of mini cheesecake fell during setup so Rachel drove back to the store to get a replacement tray and re-delivered it all before the ceremony time! It’s clear they are dedicated to providing delicious wedding desserts and quality service for an important day like your wedding day.

Our cake was stunning and delicious! I made my cake order very late in the planning phase of my wedding, and even with time limitations Aggies Bakery created a gorgeous cake beyond my expectations. Staff was friendly, helpful, and understanding.

Our petite desserts for our wedding were absolutely amazing! Aggie's knew exactly how many we would need per person and we got so many compliments on how good they were. They were also extremely affordable! Our small personal wedding cake was delicious and they designed it just for us based on our wedding colors. 10/10 would recommend for your wedding desserts!

We recently had our wedding cake made by Aggie’s, and overall, we were very happy with the final product. The cake itself was absolutely delicious, and our guests couldn't stop raving about how fresh and flavorful it was. However, we were a bit disappointed in the communication during the design process. We had a specific vision in mind, and at times, it felt like our requests weren't fully acknowledged or clarified. It would have been helpful to have clearer and more proactive communication to ensure we were all on the same page. That said, the end result was pretty and tasty, and we're grateful for the hard work they put into making our special day.

When we did our tasting a year before our wedding, the flavors we tried were amazing. We live close to Aggie's so it was a no-brainer for us. We love this bakery. However, as we led up to the wedding, things started to get more difficult. First, when I reached out about scheduling a final details meeting or conversation to make sure we were all on the same page, I was confused with another client with the same first name and then there was an argument about the details and the wedding date and who I was. Once that was finally cleared up and we adjusted our numbers to our actual guest count which was below 70. We ended up paying for 93 slices of cake. We did not need that much cake whatsoever. In fact, we were almost pushed into sticking with the original 130. Second, we were asked to give a day of contact. The person we provided was never contacted. During the time I was trying to get ready in the bridal suite, I was interrupted by the woman who dropped off the cake on more than one occasion. If you need a day of contact, then that should be who is reached out to. Our contact was there waiting and never connected with. I would have preferred to not have been bothered while I was getting ready.

Had a cake tasting, it was wonderful. Very professional. Place my order for a beautiful cake . However, on the day of delivery of my wedding, my wedding cake did not get delivered to the venue. No cake for my special day. Wedding was on a Sunday, the company had some sort of miscommunication of delivery. Wasnt able to talk with anyobe as they were closed on Sunday. The very next day, Monday, they did call first thing when they were aware my cake was still at the store. They did their very best to try to make it up. they contacted me before I could contact them on that Monday so I was very impressed. They were very concerned about where they dropped the ball. and at the end, I was fully reimbursed for all charges. They also reimbursed me for a special cake stand I purchased else where. Delivered the cake to me so we could have our cake cutting with friends and family. Gave me a $100 gift certificate. I know it doesn't replace not having your cake at the your special day, however, it doesn't change the fact, we did get married and are Mr. & Mrs. I'm pretty sure that it was intended. Things happen.

We loved our cake from Aggie's Bakery. The cake was delicious and we had great service. Working with the owner to pick out our flavors and design was an easy process and we were able to show our inspo photos and get exactly what we were looking for.

We got married and used Aggies for a dessert table. They delivered all of the desserts and it was a seamless experience!

We truly enjoyed our experience with Aggie's Bakery, from the private tasting, to the seamless wedding cake and cupcake pickup, to the delicious taste of everything, along with the rave reviews from our wedding guests. Thank you, Aggie's, for playing an integral role in our wedding celebration! :-)

Our wedding cake was absolutely beautiful and everything I envisioned. It was perfect for us! It also tasted great and we had many complements on it. We love Aggies and will certainly be retuning for all of our dessert needs!

We couldn't be happier with our experience at Aggie's! From the moment we walked through the door, Rachel made us feel very comfortable and walked us through the tasting with ease. She guided us through every step with incredible patience and attention to detail, always keeping our aesthetic in mind. The cake itself was absolutely divine. It was almost exactly what we had envisioned and received countless compliments from our guests. And the cherry on top? A year later, we were delighted to enjoy a complimentary anniversary cake, which is a wonderful and thoughtful touch. Aggie's Bakery combines exceptional service with delicious, beautiful cakes. Rachel and her team made our wedding day even more special, and we’re so grateful for their expertise and generosity. Highly recommend!

With our first wedding anniversary coming up, I’ve been reflecting on what a special day it was. A big part of that special day was all the amazing vendors we had - one of which was Aggies. Not only was the cake delicious, but their staff was so easy to work with! I cannot recommend them enough!

Aggie's is hands down our favorite local bakery! We always go to them for our birthday cakes, but also had them make our wedding cake. They hit it out of the park every time!

Rachel was so easy to work with, plenty of options, great taste and for a great price. My guests raved about the cheesecake and eclairs and brownies. My cutting cake was absolutely 🥰

Our cake was amazing!!! Highly recommend!

Aggie’s has been a name in my family forever so it was an easy decision to stop in for a tasting. The tasting was awesome, we got to try so many different options and really sit and enjoy it! We ended up getting a cutting cake for us and cupcakes for our guests. The cake and the cupcakes turned out so delicious and we were only left with 5 out of 150 at the end of the night! They also are so sweet to work with when it comes to exactly how you want your cake and if you want to bring your own decorations for them to add (which we did). Plus, they give their clients a fresh cake on their one year wedding anniversary rather than having them freeze their wedding cake 🥹 They do offer delivery but we had a couple family friends pick up for us which worked out great! But without a doubt we would recommend Aggies to anyone!

We got our cutting cake from Aggies and mini desserts for our guests. We had so many complaints about the desserts and variety that we had. They were very affordable! The wedding coordinator, Rachel was always so prompt at answering my emails and was just great to work with.

Aggie's did a wonderful job. Fully professional and easy to work with. The cake was beautifully design with just a few ideas for inspiration. The cake was delicious with compliments from all our guests and constant inquiry of the bakery. I would highly recommend.

Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop was so great to work with. We were on a tight budget and never felt any pressure during the planning process to upgrade to anything more than what we were really looking for. And their cakes are AMAZING! Definitely recommend!

absolutely recommend! After taste testing multiple cakes, we were still sold on the cake from Aggie’s! Their consultation was so easy and helpful in figuring out what combination of cake/cupcakes worked best for us! The cake looked exactly as the images we had sent and tasted SO good! We were told all night about how good and moist our wedding cake was!

Our wedding cake was gorgeous and delicious!!! We had so much fun at our tasting and loved every single flavor! Guests loved the cake and went back for multiple pieces. Can't recommend them enough! Delicious and reliable.

Everyone at Aggies Bakery was really great to work with! The personal attention that we got was amazing! They were very willing to work with us on every custom detail we requested. All of the food was delicious! Some of our guests still rave about it! There was a little issue toward the end, but Aggies helped us work through it! The presentation was perfect and they matched the theme to our wedding! It was great working with Aggies Bakery and we recommend them to anyone that is looking at planning a wedding!

We used Aggies for our wedding reception desserts and were very happy with them. We worked with Rachel throughout the process and she was very efficient and detail oriented in all of her communication with us. We ended up getting a small cake to cut, and mini pastries for the guests. They both turned out very beautiful and delicious and our guests commented on how good the mini pastries were. The only thing that we had an issue with was that a tiered dessert stand we rented from them for the mini pastries was not stable and unable to be used at the venue. Luckily our wedding planner had their own dessert trays that they were able to use, so that problem went away. Rachel also was quick to refund the fee we had paid for the dessert stand so everything worked out. Thank you Aggies!