Awarded for Milwaukee's Best Cakes & Desserts!
Recently updated
This vendor updated their storefront within the last 15 days.
We travel within 45 miles from our bakery location
Service area
Deals
GiftPermanent
Free Anniversary Cake!
Claim Deal
Rachel Schmidbauer
OWNER
AWARD WINNER (12X)
Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
In 2017 Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop again won the award for creating Milwaukee's best wedding cakes and desserts - as named by voters for the Milwaukee A-list! Aggie's specializes in making the most beautiful and delicious wedding cakes. From tier cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, table cakes, sheet cakes and fine pastries - we have your dessert needs covered! We make our own made-from-scratch buttercream and use fresh, incredibly delicious cake that results in a cake that is just as delicious as it is beautiful - your guests will be sure to rave! Made from only the highest quality ingredients, our family developed recipes deliver superior texture and flavor. We are a 3rd generation family business that was established in 1977, and our passion is creating your dream wedding cake
Woman-owned Business
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Accessories
Cake Stands
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cake Tastings
Groom's Cakes
Awards and Affiliations
Any questions?
Meet the team
Rachel Schmidbauer
Owner
Rachel is here to make sure you have an incredible experience working with Aggie's Bakery and you absolutely love your wedding cake and/or desserts!
Reviews
4.8
out of 5.0494 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop receives high praise from reviewers for their wedding desserts, with a focus on the delicious taste and beautiful presentation of cakes, cupcakes, and pastries. Reviewers appreciate the reasonable pricing, ease of working with the staff, and the seamless delivery and setup services provided by Aggie's. The bakery's attention to detail, helpful customer service, and personalized experience during tastings are also highlighted as standout features, making Aggie's a highly recommended choice for wedding desserts in the Milwaukee area.Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
Ellen J
4.0
12/14/2025
We went to Aggie's Bakery for our wedding cake. Our experience was overall positive. They were quick to respond to emails and answered our questions thoroughly. The cake was beauti...
fully decorated and exactly what we envisioned. More importantly, the cake was absolutely delicious! We received many compliments from our guests.
The only issue we ran into was during pick up. We pre-arranged for my mom to pick up the cake the morning of the wedding. I provided my mom's name and pick up time to Aggie's, and they told my mom to provide our last names at pick up. At pick up, the staff weren't able to find our cake and became a bit snippy with my mom when she didn't know what type of cake it was. That shouldn't matter when our names were on the cake, and we had arranged ahead of time for pick up so they knew exactly when to expect us. Besides that little snafu, we would 100% go to Aggie's again and recommend them to friends/family. Thank you, Aggie's!
Natalie R
5.0
11/21/2025
Aggie's was simply phenomenal. We had a dessert table and a small cake from Aggie's for our wedding; both were delicious and looked so lovely! We got so many compliments on how how...
yummy our desserts were! Also, Aggie's was so transparent about pricing, unlike many other vendors we looked at, and they had super reasonable prices too! (Honestly, we would have paid a lot more for Aggie's desserts, but they're priced so reasonably we didn't need to!) They did dessert delivery and set up too, and placed a very heavy cake topper very nicely; also for a super reasonable cost. I can't say enough nice things about them!
Any questions?
Sarah V
5.0
11/18/2025
Aggie’s was wonderful helping us plan for our wedding. Since we’re from out of town it was hard for us to know where to start looking. They came highly recommended from our venue, ...
and when we went for our cake tasting we understood why. Everyone was so kind and made us feel so special during the tasting. Everything we tried was delicious and our cupcakes and mini pastries were a huge hit with our guests. They delivered and set everything up for us so we had one less thing to worry about. Highly recommend them if you need wedding desserts in the Milwaukee area.
Jenna H
5.0
11/09/2025
Delicious baked goods and great service!! My guests were raving about how delicious every treat was!! We had a variety of delicious treats from our wedding cake (that was beautiful...
ly decorated and beyond delicious!) pumpkin cheesecake bites, brownies and cupcakes!! Aggie’s was also very professional and easy to work with! I will be returning to Aggie’s for any baked goods I need in the future!!
nikki G
5.0
10/23/2025
Aggie’s Bakery & Cake Shop was the bomb. I loved the flavor of the cake. It melted in my mouth. All of my guests who attended my wedding were so happy that I chose Aggie’s Bakery a...
nd Cake Shop. This place is a top 10 they did a fantastic job I was in tears when I saw my wedding cake. So if anyone needs a wedding cake, birthday cake or Anniversary cake go to Aggie’s.
Meghan L
5.0
10/12/2025
We had a great experience working with Aggie’s for our wedding cake. The tasting was perfect and helped us decide what we wanted. The customer service was wonderful, and we loved t...
he how the cake turned out!
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 10/13/2025
Thank you so much for the great review! I'm so happy you were pleased. We sure appreciate...
that you picked us for your special day!
Jena B
5.0
10/10/2025
My husband and I used Aggie’s for our wedding last October and could not recommend them enough. The entire process was seamless from our first tasting, to ordering, and getting the...
desserts delivered (and set up!) on our wedding day. Not to mention everything was delicious! Our guests raved about our dessert bar, especially the eclairs.
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 10/13/2025
We are so happy everything was a success! Thank you so much for the amazing review and for...
sending a photo - we appreciate you, and your business, more than you know. CHEERS!
Shamon H
5.0
10/07/2025
Had Aggies do our wedding cake. The cake turned out excellent. Wasnt to sweet or not sweet enough, it was just right. Many guest complimented the design and taste. Needless to say ...
all 3 layers were gone by the end of our reception. Thank you Aggies for making our wedding day special and memorable.
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 10/13/2025
Thank you so much for the kind review! I can't think of a better compliment than "everythi...
ng was gone." We're so happy you chose us to be a part of your big day.
Brooke L
5.0
9/13/2025
We hired Aggie’s to make our wedding cake for our May 2025 wedding. We got a 8-inch, 2 layer white cake with strawberry preserve filling with whipped frosting. The cake was delicio...
us and I dreamed of it since our wedding that I reordered the exact same cake for my birthday in August. Aggie’s was very easy to work with and were able to provide us with exactly what we wanted. We did order the cake sample plate to sample all the cake and frosting flavors prior to ordering. We will definitely be ordering from Aggie’s again for future events.
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 10/13/2025
Thank you so much for the review! I just loved the photos as the cake topper. So glad we...
could be a part of your big day - Congratulations!!!
Kendall S
5.0
9/13/2025
We loved our experience with Aggies from start to finish! Their tasting was not only delicious and informative but lots of fun. They made the process so easy, and helped us to make...
decisions on what we needed based on how many guests we had. They did a beautiful job setting up our cake and dessert table and coordinating with our florist to add flowers. Everything was beautiful and delicious!
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 09/15/2025
Thank you so much for the amazing review! I just LOVED the cute photos on your cake top. ...
We're so happy you chose us to play a part in our big day. We'll see you in the shop for your first anniversary!
Jovana R
5.0
9/08/2025
Aggies was nothing but the absolute best vendor to work with. They are on top of everything and not to mention they have the best cakes, pastries ever!!!!! i would hands down recom...
mend this place to anyone and I will continue buying cake and desserts from here.
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 10/13/2025
Thank you for the kind review, Jovana! So happy you were pleased with the process. Hope t...
o see you back in the shop soon!
Tiffany B
5.0
9/06/2025
Our experience with Aggie's is more then we could have asked for. They not only made amazing filled cupcakes, that were eaten up by our guests, but they also created not one but tw...
o cutting cakes for us. One was to celebrate our day but also a speacial 50th anniversary cake for our parents. They made our day extremely speical and the develiery and set up was so smooth. The only regret we had was not ordering more cupcakes because there were none left at the end of the night.
Alaina L
5.0
8/22/2025
Aggies was fantastic to work with. Couldn’t have asked for a better service or communication. The cake turned out absolutely beautiful. Would recommend to anyone.
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 08/25/2025
Thank you so much for the kind review, Alaina!
Hughie S
5.0
8/20/2025
Aggies
🌟 Aggie’s Bakery – A Sweet Dream Come True!
We ordered a 6-tier masterpiece from Aggie’s Bakery to celebrate my parents’ 50th wedding anniversary renewal and I’m still ...
in awe of the experience. Rachel and her incredible team were great in executing what we asked for. Their
attention to detail made the entire process seamless and joyful.
The cake itself? Breathtaking. Elegant design, flawless execution, and flavors that had every guest raving. It wasn’t just dessert—it was the centerpiece of our celebration and a true work of art.
What impressed me most was how Rachel listened to every detail, offered thoughtful suggestions, and made sure the final product reflected the love and legacy of my parents’ milestone. You could feel the care baked into every layer.
I’ve since returned for goodies (because how could I not?), and each visit feels like a treat. Aggie’s isn’t just a bakery—it’s a place where memories are made and celebrated.
Highly recommend to anyone looking for something special, whether it’s a grand event or a sweet pick-me-up. Thank you, Aggie’s Bakery, for making our celebration unforgettable! 💛🎂✨
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 08/25/2025
Thank you so much for this amazing review! You were an absolute pleasure to work with and...
we had so much fun with this beautiful cake - you're parents deserved it!!!
Teandra D
5.0
8/17/2025
Our cake design turned out better than we imagined. It was so beautiful, we did not want to cut it. The delivery and set up was hassle free.
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 08/25/2025
Thank you so much, Teandra! We're so happy it was exactly what you wanted!
Anna S
5.0
8/15/2025
Aggies was amazing to work with, I would highly recommend!
They were easy to work with and very responsive. Our cake was delicious and beautiful! We were not local and they helped...
to make the process as simple as possible!
Angela K
5.0
8/15/2025
Aggie’s Bakery was fantastic to work with for our wedding cake! The team was friendly, responsive, and made the process so easy from start to finish. Delivery was smooth and on tim...
e, and the cake itself was absolutely amazing. It was beautifully decorated and delicious. Highly recommend!
Peter D
5.0
8/15/2025
Wow!! What an incredible job Aggie’s Bakery did for our wedding!
The cake was absolutely fantastic — our guests are still raving about how delicious it was! They perfectly replicat...
ed a beautiful, intricate design we found online, and the attention to detail was stunning. Delivery was flawless, and everything arrived in perfect condition.
What made it even more amazing is that we didn’t even have a tasting — we placed our order just 9 days before the wedding, and Aggie’s exceeded every expectation. Now, we’re picking up our anniversary cake for free, which is such a thoughtful touch.
From start to finish, the entire experience was incredible. I can’t recommend Aggie’s Bakery enough for any special occasion!
Kami H
5.0
8/09/2025
Aggie's Bakery was amazing to work with for our wedding. We kept having people say how great the cake was months after our wedding. They also made the process super easy. They walk...
ed us through all the options, the tasting was no pressure, and they were able to answer all of our questions. On the day of, they delivered the cake and got everything set which took away a lot of stress on our big day. Highly recommend choosing Aggie's Bakery for your wedding sweets.
Kathleen G
5.0
8/05/2025
My now husband and I were impressed by Aggie’s from the beginning. Our cake tasting was not only delicious, but informative, and we heard compliments from our guests about our chos...
en wedding cake. It’s clear that Aggie’s is experienced and a well respected bakery.
Ally H
5.0
7/28/2025
The best cake I have ever tasted!!! We worked with Rachel during the tasting process (free tasting which was a bonus) and she was so helpful and kind. We got three different flavor...
s of cake for our big day, and all our guests were raving to us how delicious it was! I couldn’t recommend Aggies enough, you will not be disappointed!!
Zoe P
5.0
7/20/2025
We got married July 20,2024. We had such a positive experience with Aggies Bakery. From planning to delivery! Our wedding cake was beautiful and so delicious!
Kelsey W
5.0
7/19/2025
We chose Aggie's for our wedding cake and mini desserts and were not disappointed! Rachel was so easy to work with. We came in for two tastings which were easy to schedule. Commun...
ication was great. Everything tasted amazing!
ANTHONY C
5.0
7/13/2025
Rachel was perfect we really really enjoyed her she was perfect she didn’t try to oversell or anything. One thing always bring out plastic and metal some people are still
Paranoid ...
about Covid. Other than that you were great and easy to get along with and choose options and explain them. Thanks again for everything Tashan and Anthony
Angela L
5.0
7/09/2025
We worked with Aggie’s Bakery for our wedding dessert and had an excellent experience. Even though we waited until the last minute to choose a dessert vendor, Rachel S. was able to...
get us in for a tasting quickly, and everything we tried was delicious. We chose a small 6-inch cutting cake along with a variety of desserts for the table. The cake and desserts were all super tasty, and we found the pricing to be very reasonable for the quality we received.
Brandy M
5.0
6/30/2025
Aggies was hands down the best choice for our June wedding last year. Our guest loved each flavor that we chose. We loved them so much that I had make my parent’s 50 anniversary ca...
ke this past March. If you’re looking for a great tasting cake at an affordable price, look no further.
Jenifer D
5.0
6/24/2025
Aggies Bakery was such a pleasure to work with. The complimentary cake tasting before we committed to Aggies is what really sold us—such great customer service on top of the delici...
ous cake! Our cake turned out way better than I ever could have expected and we got many compliments from guests about how good the cupcake were. Aggies was friendly, profession, easy to work with, and overall 5 stars!
Courtney S
5.0
6/11/2025
Aggie's was a great choice for our wedding day cake! They were great with communication and easy to work with. The cake looked beautiful and was very well done for a 4-tier cake. P...
erhaps most importantly, it tasted amazing and very fresh!
Jacob K
5.0
6/03/2025
Aggie's did an amazing job with our wedding! It started with the tasting where it was extremely organized. We loved the layout where we could try all the cake, filling, and icing c...
ombinations without being overwhelmed with food. After the tasting, Rachel made it very easy to figure out how much cake we needed for our guests. Our cake tasted and looked great at our wedding, and all of our guests really enjoyed it. We would definitely recommend Aggie's!
Brittany K
5.0
5/29/2025
We love Aggies! All of our guests enjoyed the desserts. They were very easy to work with and we highly recommend them to everyone
Fritz V
5.0
5/22/2025
Aggie’s was spectacular. From our planning day with Rachel to the day of our wedding every detail was covered. Our wedding was downtown Milwaukee and they made coordinating the del...
ivery to our venue so easy. The cake tasted delicious and looked so incredible. Thank you so much!
Tiffany L
5.0
5/17/2025
Very friendly, delicious cake, delivered it promptly, and it was all beautiful and loved by all!
Allie S
5.0
5/07/2025
I cannot recommend aggie’s enough!
We did mini desserts and a cake for our wedding and everything was absolutely delicious. Our cake looked better than what I envisioned, and our ...
guests raved about the sweets table.
Stacy L
4.0
4/17/2025
Our wedding was 8 months ago and we keep getting comments about how good our wedding cake was from family and friends! The whole process of planning all the way through to wedding ...
day was easy and stress free. We really liked how there was nothing to return after the wedding was over since we went on our honeymoon right away. Our cake was beautiful and tasted even better!
Venisse S
5.0
4/03/2025
We had Aggie’s cake and cupcakes for our wedding last year. Rachel was really easy to work with and was very organized. She sent detailed notes after our call and it made it really...
easy for me during the planning process because I was able to refer back to those notes. Everything was clear in the contract. The cake was beautiful and delicious; we had sent inspiration photos and they were able to make it how we wanted it. We were on a budget and we found this place to be priced reasonably. I’m glad we picked this bakery for our wedding and I wish we live in state so we could have it all the time!
George N
5.0
4/02/2025
We knew we wanted a small cutting cake and variety of desserts. Aggie’s was the last place we tried and we signed the contract on the spot. All of the cakes and mini desserts taste...
d absolutely amazing and it was more affordable than other options we had tried. The wedding coordinator Rachel was so nice and easy to work with.
Samantha B
5.0
3/30/2025
Rachel was a pleasure to work with while we decided on cake flavors and all the different dessert choices. Everything tasted and looked great, and I would definitely work with them...
on another event!
Ashley F
5.0
3/07/2025
My husband and I booked Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop for our wedding last year, and I have no regrets! They offered us a free tasting that was so personalized and informative. Choo...
sing them and our desserts was an easy decision! They fulfilled our order quickly, made sure our desserts were delivered on time, and everything tasted amazing. Thanks, Aggie's!
Meaghan R
5.0
2/22/2025
Aggie's did a great job with our wedding cake! The cake tasting was fun and helped us pick the perfect cake for us. It was also really helpful to have our cake delivered and that w...
as an easy process. Our guests loved the cake and it was beautiful!
Amanda R
5.0
2/08/2025
We LOVED our cake and desserts from Aggie's! Our great experience all started with our tasting, which was so pleasantly well done and was so tasty. We got to try basically everythi...
ng they had to offer. The way they did their tastings compared to other shops allowed us to really try everything. We were between Simma's and Aggie's. In the end, the cake was so much better from Aggie's, it made our decision easy. We decided to do a cake and a dessert table, we ordered an assortment of desserts for our table that were a HUGE hit at our wedding. In addition, whevener you get a wedding cake from Aggie's, they provide a free small cake to you on your anniversary, so no need to save in the freezer. Our experience was amazing, highly reccommend Aggie's for your wedding.
Rita G
5.0
11/24/2024
From the begining of the process Aggie's has been very clear and professional with everything. We completed two tasting and finally decided on the flavor and size of cake. On the d...
ay of the wedding Aggie's delivered and displayed the cake so beautiful my husband and I were taken back. It was beautiful and delicious. The process was so stress-free as well. They were very up front with pricing and due dates. Very satisfied with their business.
Maria B
5.0
11/18/2024
We had an extravagant vision for our wedding cake that Aggie executed so well. Not only did the cake look amazing but it tasted great too. Look at what they did!
Edith M
5.0
11/09/2024
From the cake tasting to seeing our cake in person the day of everything was amazing! Everyone raved about the cake and I was absolutely blown away when I saw it on our wedding day...
!
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 11/16/2024
Thank you so much for the amazing review - we couldn't be more pleased that you were so ha...
ppy with the results on your big day!
Jessica H
5.0
11/07/2024
My husband and I are so glad we chose Aggie’s for our wedding day. We went with a small, 2 tiered cake to cut and cupcakes for our guests. The flavors were phenomenal and the displ...
ay was excellent. Aggie’s came onsite to set up our cupcake display and we rented the stand from them so it was super easy. Our guests raved about how good the cupcakes were. The detailing on our cutting cake was also perfect and exactly what we were looking for! We would recommend Aggie’s to anyone.
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 11/16/2024
Thank you so much for the great review, Jessica! We're so happy that all your guests loved...
the treats and that we could make the process smooth and easy. We appreciate you so much for choosing us!
Melissa M
5.0
11/05/2024
We were so happy we chose Aggie’s for our wedding cake. The cake was delicious. Rachel was so organized & easy to work with. We needed to change our original order from a large tie...
red cake to cupcakes due to restrictions at our venue & Rachel made that transition easy. The small cutting cake we got was beautifully decorated. Since our original tasting, Aggie’s cakes have become a favorite in our family & we have enjoyed them at many birthdays & holidays.
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 11/16/2024
Thank you so much for the great review, Melissa! I'm so glad that we could make it easy f...
or you - I know it goes a long way when you have so much to do. We're so happy you picked us and we're even more happy that we have become one of your favorites...it really means the world to us!
Shannon S
5.0
10/19/2024
It was a pleasure to work with Aggie's for our wedding cake! The cake was incredibly delicious and turned out exactly how we wanted it to.
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 11/16/2024
Thank you so much for the kind review, Shannon. I loved your cake too - clean, simple, el...
egant and perfect. Hope your entire day was amazing!
Nicole M
5.0
10/14/2024
Our cake was beautiful, delicious, and everything we wanted! Aggie's was so easy to work with, and reasonably costed. I loved that we could do different flavors for each tier!
Response from Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop on 11/16/2024
Thank you so much for the kind review and for posting photos! We appreciate your business...
more than you know and we're so happy you got everything you dreamed of!
Stephen L
5.0
10/13/2024
Aggie's was a pleasure to work with! From the cake tasting to design process, everything was well laid out and Rachel was extremely easy to communicate with. Our cake was absolutel...
y delicious, we got so many compliments on how yummy it was. The cake itself was beautifully decorated
Sydney S
5.0
10/07/2024
Aggies was so easy to work with from the tasting all the way to delivery. Great value. The cake was delicious and looked absolutely beautiful! We received so many compliments
Kim H
5.0
10/04/2024
We had a great experience with Aggie's! Rachel was fantastic to work with, everything was organized, and our tasting was really helpful and fun. We did a mini dessert table and eve...
rything looked at tasted wonderful. Happy to support this local business and looking forward to our complimentary cake for our anniversary!
Service area & Contact info
We travel within 45 miles from our bakery location
Typically included in the starting cost
Want to book a visit?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop
Rachel Schmidbauer
|
Owner
- Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
- Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
- Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
- For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.
By clicking "Request quote," you accept our Terms of Use and agree to The Knot creating an account for you. Your messages may be monitored for quality, safety, and security according to our Acceptable Content Policy. See our Privacy Policy to learn how we handle your data.
Wedding vendors in West Allis
Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure. Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place. Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go. For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.