No photos yet
About this vendor
We don‘t know Audrey's Fine Baked Goods‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.
Details
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.8
out of 5.093 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 7
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
Upon The Old Field Club’s recommendation, we discovered Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods—a hidden gem. The tasting experience felt like royalty; each morsel was a sweet enchantment. But it wasn’t just about taste—the cake looked as divine as it tasted. Our simplistic vision materialized flawlessly, and our guests raved as well. Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods is where flavor meets artistry—a true delight for any celebration. 🍰✨👑
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods was used by our venue for our wedding cake. Not only was our cake delicious, but it looked amazing too. We had a vision for a beach themed cake and Audrey's delivered. We got so many compliments on the taste and look. The best part too: actual icing was used instead of fondant.
There are no words for how absolutely perfect our cake was. We wanted something outside the norm and Audrey’s team delivered 1000 times over and gave us the cake we wanted at a super affordable rate. Our venue included the basic cake so we got credit for that and with the up charge - we were prepared to pay so much more- but what Audrey’s actually charged was absolutely reasonable. Given the level of decoration we wanted on the cake we were so happy that Audrey’s was able to avoid doing the entire thing in fondant. the cake was equally delicious as it was beautiful! I was heart broken to have to cut it, but when we did it was equally amazing.
Our cake was PERFECT! So many choices at the tasting. It was beautiful and delicious. Audrey’s is so easy to work with and the whole process for our wedding was simple and easy. Thank you!
We used Audrey's for our wedding cake. Our venue included 3 choices for bakeries, and the decision to use Audrey's was so simple! From the tasting, to some extras along the way (surprise cupcake for the groom, personalized cake for my dad), Audrey's was so easy to work with. Neither my husband nor I are big cake people, but our cake was absolutely delicious!!-- and our guests agreed! Audrey's has become our go-to bakery!
The cake of my dreams! Katie was so easy to work with, and the variety of options you have for cake and fillings are incredible. We had three different flavors, and they were all delicious! We also got 2 birthday cakes that were delicious! Many people told me they didn't like cake but loved the wedding cake.
BEST WEDDING CAKE EVERR!! We had a 4 tier cake, 2 tiers were yellow cake with vanilla buttercream (husband loves vanilla) and 2 tiers were chocolate cake with chocolate fudge filling (I love chocolate), outside coating was vanilla buttercream. Not only did we think it was the most delicious wedding cake we’ve ever had, so did our guests!!! we also had assorted cookies on each table that were AMAZING! Highly recommend Audrey’s!!
Our venue provided our wedding cake from Audrey's. Our cake turned out beautiful, but more importantly, it was absolutely delicious! We got a vanilla sponge cake with oreo and chocolate mousse filling and buttercream icing. Excellent!
We got our wedding cake from Audrey’s and let me tell you they did not disappoint!!! Of course Audrey’s is a well known bakery so we had high hopes for the cake. We got a vanilla cake with Oreo mouse filling and buttercream frosting. It was absolutely delicious!! Our guests were raving about how good the cake was and some even asking for seconds. I’m a huge dessert person and feel like whenever I go to weddings most of the time the cake is dry and not very flavorful but that was not the case with our cake! Highly highly recommend!
Truthfully, I always viewed a wedding cake as a formality and it was never something I was excited about. HOWEVER, our wedding cake was truly amazing. I had several people tell me it was the best cake they had ever had at a wedding. We are so excited to have our leftover cake!
Our venue included a wedding cake that was a standard 3-tier cake provided through Audrey's. The bakery did such a great job. They were so patient and helpful during the cake tasting process. We were able to do different fillings for each filling layer and decided on vanilla cake with a layer of cappuccino mousse and a layer of cannoli cream with chocolate chips, and it tasted amazing! We got a lot of compliments and the cake looked great too!
Our wedding cake was phenomenal. The tasting was one of our favorite things we did in planning and Katie helped us pick out such an amazing flavor. The cake was so delicious the day of -- it took everything in me to not eat our top tier early! Thank you guys for being part of our day!
We ordered a standard four tier wedding cake and couldn’t have been happier with the design and the taste. I also surprised my fiancé (now husband) with a Real Madrid soccer cake - and it was executed phenomenally! I sent the bakery a picture I found from Pinterest and they made it EXACTLY the same. The groom’s cake was definitely the star of show! I would recommend them again and again and I couldn’t be happier with their products, or how easy they were to work with.
Was so happy with my wedding cake, it was absolutely perfect. Looked and tasted incredible. This bakery is a pleasure to work with - I would 100% recommend and will be going back for other events!
Audreys is the best! Our wedding cake was both stunning and delicious. Katie was so helpful and easy to work with. We also got apple cider donuts and various pies for our october wedding which were to die for. So many of our guests raved about the desserts. We’ve definitely found our new favorite bakery!
WONDERFUL WEDDING CAKE! My husband and I booked Audrey’s for our wedding. We met with Katie and completed our cake tasting. I explained my vision to Katie and we decided on the carrot cake with cream cheese filling. The cake arrived and it was absolutely beautiful, exactly what I wanted. The cake was FABULOUS. We got so many compliments on it and inquiries on where it was from. One of our guests had 3 slices!! Absolutely hire Audrey’s for your event!
Pay extra for the funfetti cake...you will not regret it! Tasted and looked amazing! guests got a real kick out of the fact it was funfetti, too!
This bakery is AWESOME!!! My husband and I were having a hard time with the bakery that works along with the venue we had our reception at, so we decided to just pay the extra cost of ordering a cake from another bakery. Luckily we found Audrey's bakery on the Knot. It was "the bomb" to work with them. Since the beginning, Katie helped us along the way and I couldn't have been any happier with the results! Our cake was gorgeous and deliciously tasty! Not to mention the fees were less than half of the cost of the other bakery. I definitely recommend Audrey's Bakery! They have great service, their baking goods are delicious and the prices are completely affordable!
Highly recommend!! Our wedding cake was delicious and looked amazing, our guests raved about it. Katie was so easy to work with, too. It was perfect!!!
Hands down the most delicious wedding cake I’ve ever had. Katie from Audreys was so easy to work with over the phone and made the process super simple. Our venue uses Audreys for all of their wedding cakes, but even if they didn’t I would chose them again. Due to covid, my husband and I weren’t able to go inside for a formal tasting but their to-go boxes were put together beautifully and we had such a hard time choosing flavors cause everything was just that good! Our final result was beautiful, and she even added on pastries for us since we are big dessert eaters.
Our wedding is *hopefully* planned for 10/16/2020 and we have been trying to plan as everything is still currently closed. Audreys was able to provide us with a curbside pick up cake tasting and it reinvigorated our wedding planning, we had the best time tasting cakes together and we are so thankful for them!
We found Audrey’s through our reception venue, Mansion at West Sayville and are so happy we did! Katie was really helpful during our cake tasting and very patient when we asked for extras to try. We ended up with a lemon sponge cake, lemon custard and raspberry preserves with a buttercream frosting. The cake was absolutely beautiful!! My father in law was shocked when he saw my mother in law had eaten her entire piece-she doesn’t eat cake! I’ll definitely return here for regular baked goods throughout the year as well!
Used Audrey's for our wedding cake and about 100 cupcakes. Everything was delicious. Working with them was a delight and more than a little filling!
Our cake was part of the package at our venue, so that’s how we found Audreys. We paid extra to have the unique design we wanted. It came out great. Katie was great to work with and very helpful throughout the process.
I cannot say enough about Audrey’s Bakery! They made the most delicious cannoli and chocolate mousse wedding cake for my special day. Everyone was raving about how yummy it was! Looking forward to having a celebratory piece of it on my one year anniversary.
Oh my sweet baby jesus! Our wedding cake was delicious. We still think about the cake and all of our guests absolutely loved the dulce de leche and vanilla buttercream. We had a "naked" cake design with red berries and black dahlias cascading down the front. It was so beautiful and not too sweet but fluffy and amazing! Thank you Audrey's for making our wedding cake! We used Audrey's through a vendor package with Mansion at West Sayville and I am so glad that we did!
Our wedding cake was both beautiful and delicious. Very easy vendor to work with!
It was lovely working with Audrey’s bakery, our cake turned out amazing! When we went in for our cake tasting, they were very helpful when we were choosing our flavors, especially because we had certain allergy restrictions that they took very seriously, which we greatly appreciated. The end design was beautiful and tasted delicious -everyone loved it!
The cannoli filling to our wedding cake was life changing. We ate it for 3 days before leaving for our honeymoon and it was still fresh. We also had them complete donuts for our exit station, although due to heat the frosting melted the donut was delicious and the perfect treat on the way out!
We used this bakery for our Wedding. They were included in our package, but we were so happy with everything. I also requested a groom cake as a surprise for my fiancé. I provided them with a picture of a detailed cake and they did an excellent job. He and our guests loved it!
We met Audrey's at a Wedding Show and tasted their cupcakes. I was blown away by the taste and knew that they were the ones to make our wedding cake. I have never been one to eat wedding cake. I usually think it's too dry or too sweet or too something. Audrey's vanilla cake with cookies and cream mousse is heaven on a plate. Katie took great care of us and we got so many complements on how great the cake was! I can't wait to go back for anniversaries and try all the cakes!
We were set up with Audrey’s through our venue Old Field Club, so we made an appointment for a cake tasting and everything we tried was absolutely delicious it was so hard to decide ! Not only did the cake taste great it was absolutely stunning, I was so worried that going with the fake flowers wasn’t going to give me the look I was going for but it turned out better then I could have imagined, they were even able to use a swatch to match my color perfectly ! I most definitely recommend Audrey’s for your wedding cake or any other events because they are amazing !
We got so many complements on our cake and it was beautiful!!
Our wedding cake was perfect! It looked amazing and it tasted great! We got so many compliments on the cake. I highly recommend Audrey's!
Our cake was beautiful and delicious - what more is there to say?! We chose a 4-tiered round funfetti cake (a little bit extra than the standard flavors, but SO worth it) with raspberry and chocolate fillings, alternating by layer. On the outside we did a buttercream frosting with a simple horizontal stripe pattern (we had reference photos, but they had one in their example book that matched). We put together our own fake flowers, which Audrey's made look incredible despite my amateur flower arranging skills. A lot of our guests told us it was the first time they've actually enjoyed wedding cake, so that says a lot! I think the funfetti was probably a big selling point, too - how do you see that and not dig in?!
During our tasting, we knew we wanted funfetti, so that was the only cake we tried, but the cake itself was the perfect texture and sweetness. Lauren allowed us to try as many fillings as we pleased and was very patient with all of our questions and decision-making. I also loved that their buttercream didn't taste like just chomping on a stick of butter like so many bakeries' buttercream does.
I can't wait until our 1 year anniversary to have another taste!
We used Audrey's for our wedding cake for our August 18, 2018 wedding. We ordered a four tiered, naked cake for 120 people. They were super easy and laid back to work with and delivery on the day of was on time and efficient. Their pricing is extremely reasonable compared to other bakeries and the cake was delicious. Our caterer saved the top portion of the cake for us and we enjoyed it all throughout the next week and it still tasted SO good. Definitely recommend them for a great cake that won't break the bank.
Audrey’s is amazing. They had us come in for a tasting and it was so fun! A lot of places don’t allow you to do tastings anymore. Even cuter was after our tasting we wanted to buy some things to show our appreciation and they gave us everything for free. After that we never met with anyone else. We knew they were the ones for us. Their desserts are delicious and they are so wonderful at working with your budget and creating your dream cake. Really wonderful and can not recommend enough. The best the best the best! 💗
We used Audrey's Fine Baked Goods for our wedding cake and couldn't be happier. When we went in for our tasting the staff were so inviting and gave my husband and I time to ourselves to enjoys the samples. Our three tiered yellow cake with cannoli filling was beautiful and delicious! I highly recommend using Audrey's Fine Baked Goods for your big day!
I would HIGHLY recommend Audrey's! We used them for our engagement party in July 2017 and our recent wedding at Pellegrini Vineyards on June 22, 2018. They are incredible to work with and produce the most beautiful and delicious cakes. They are extremely responsive and can make anything you want come to life!
As a frequent customer of Audrey's, I was a little sad. My two-tiered cake had indents all over the butter cream, the knot they made looked like it got ruined at some point. What made me want to cry is the fact my cake melted. All the pictures people took of our custom made cake topper shows how terrible the cake looked :(
Amazing just amazing!!!
We used Audrey's for our 10/14 wedding and we are so happy we did! We picked out a white cake with raspberry and lemon filling, which is one of their most popular combinations. The cake was absolutely beautiful and DELICIOUS. We planned to save the top tier of the cake for our anniversary, but our family convinced us to cut into it the next morning because it was THAT good. So many of our guests told us that they don't normally eat wedding cake, but ours was delicious. We can't wait to go back to Audrey's in the future.
Our wedding cake was absolutely beautiful! We brought in a picture of a cake with chocolate covered strawberries cascading down it. Audrey's did a fabulous job of recreating the cake to perfection. Not to mention it tasted AMAZING! Lots of compliments on how delicious the cake was. Highly recommended!
I gave the manager at Audrey's Fine Baked Goods a picture of a cake I wanted for my wedding. She said her cake designers could create it. She was so right! My cake was not only BEAUTIFUL it was also so good! My guests were already incredibly full from apps and dinner, but still couldn't help eating their entire slice of cake. I just loved the look of it, the colors. They really listened to what I wanted and made it happen. I highly recommend using Audrey's for your next special event cake.
My cake, not only looked freaking awesome, it tasted freaking awesome. I asked for a nautical theme with a kracken, and they exceeded my expectations. Will continue to do business with them.
Audrey's was so easy to work with. The cake tasting was set up beautifully and my wedding cake was everything I wanted. We had the really simple Maggie cake (ruffled buttercream). We got so many compliments. I definitely recommend the raspberry filling (especially with lemon or fudge). Can't wait for my one year anniversary to have more! Thanks Lauren for all your help!
I used Audrey's through the Mansion at West Sayville. Unfortunately what I wanted was to expensive for or budget so when I met with them again, I chose a more simple cake. The flavor chpices were great and everyone loved the cake. They also made a small birthday cake for my sister in law for the day of the wedding donde it was her birthday too. Definitely recommend them.
We had a beautiful and delicious wedding cake from Audrey's. I paid extra for additional design and i was very happy. Liz was very easy to work with and made the process simple and that to me was the best part...no stress! Thank you for creating a delicious and beautiful wedding cake for us !
Audrey's made our wedding cake for our fall 2016 wedding. Liz was easy to work with over email as we weren't local when wedding planning. They did everything to perfection and the cake was delicious! We were eating it for a few days after it was so good!
We had Audrey's make our cake and cupcakes and they were amazing and very reasonably priced! Everyone raved about the treats!!!
An Audrey's Bakery wedding cake was included in our wedding package from our venue. We made an appointment to have a tasting which was easy to plan and fun to
We picked out a butter cake with strawberry and fudge filling. They even took a swatch from my bridesmaids dresses to match! The day of our wedding, the cake was perfect! It looked great anday tasted even better! Usually I'm indifferent to wedding cakes, but Audrey's was delicious and we got multiple raves from our guests.
Very disappointment by the cake that I received from Audrey's Fine Baked Goods in West Sayville, NY.Yes, the cake looked beautiful.
Yes, the cake tastes great. However, when a request of silver/grey cake is made and I pay almost $300.00, I expect silver/grey. In this instance, when I went to pick up my cake, I was faced with a cement white cake. When I advised that was the wrong color, the counter argument was that the lighting made it look different.
Folks. It was wrong and expected. Half of my correspondences I had with the bakery was correcting or clarifying the initial in-person consultation. Put simply: there is too many cooks in this kitchen.
If you want a cake designed for a special occasion, go somewhere else.Avoid this headache!
My wedding cake exceeded my expectations! Audrey's did an amazing job. I had a 3 tier white cake with cannoli and raspberry filling with a buttercream frosting. I remember cutting into it and my husband giving me the first bite (well really the second because I fed him first) but I thought "Wow! This is really good!" Everyone enjoyed it. I also loved the simple yet classy design I chose. It was beautiful. I can't wait to have another bite when I open my first tier on Valentine's Day to enjoy with my husband. <3 Thank you Audrey's!
My wife and I used Audrey's Bakery for our wedding cake and it was the most pleasant experience we could have imagined. We made an appointment with Jamie to visit the store in Sayville and had an opportunity to taste a number of cake flavors and potential fillings in a very relaxing environment. Everything was so delicious and the bakery smelled amazing! I loved their raspberry preserves and my wife loved their chocolate mousse, so Jamie said that combination would work very well together and the decision was made. Their selections and decoration styles were very clear and Jamie was so flexible with us as we chose our design and very upfront about the pricing. We paid at the store in cash less than 10 days before the wedding (picked up a few delicious pastries while we were there) and their crew took care of the rest. They delivered the cake to the venue (Bellport Country Club) on the day of the wedding and all our guests raved about how this was the best wedding cake they had in a long time. We wanted a memorable cake (looks and taste) and a seamless process and Audrey's did it all. We give them the highest level of recommendation!
I have always loved Audrey's cakes so when it was an option at our venue, I picked them without hesitation. I gave the bakery a picture of what I wanted and the price came back way over what I had expected. They worked with me and we were able to design a cake that was similar to the picture and it was included with our venue price so we didn't have to pay any additional fees. Everyone at the wedding raved about the cake! It was delicious. Chocolate cake with cookies and cream filling and vanilla cake with chocolate filling was amazing! Can't wait to go back to Audrey's once a year for our anniversary cake!
We got our cake from Audrey's via the catering agreement with the Mansion at West Sayville. We met with Jamie at the bakery for a cake tasting, where we picked our flavors and gave her swatches of our wedding colors (my dress was green). We also later sent her a picture of our cake topper so they could match the colors with that too. Our cake design was simple (this is all that is included with the deal), but they matched the detailing well, and we got many compliments on the cake itself at the wedding.
I'll keep it short - the cannoli cream cake was amazing. I had 3 pieces of it on my wedding day and another for breakfast the next morning!
The cake was included with the catering and was truly exceptional. We were given some suggested options and none of them disappointed. We decided on the Chocolate Decedant Cake with Chocolate Mousse and White Chocolate with Raspberry Mousse. Their selection of designs were creative, but they allowed us to create our own which came out exactly as pictured. Guests commented that they could not get enough of the cake, and it was the best one they ever had at a wedding. I just only wish I sat long enough to eat more than the one bite my husband fed me during the cake cutting. I cannot wait to have it again on our anniversary, and will recommend her cakes for events, not just weddings, in the future.
the look and taste of our wedding cake was scrumpcious! We were treated so nicely was a true pleasure working with Audrey's Bakery. Not only did the provide the cake but also cookies and pastries that were as yummy as they looked!
My cake was beautiful, breathtaking and DELICIOUS!! Audrey's is affliated with Flowerfield where my reception was and we chose an upgraded cake and it was worth every penny! When I first saw it I was literally in awe at how beautiful it was!
My Husband & I couldn't stop eating this cake! When we cut the cake during the reception, we just kept eating it - it was delicious! Love them!
My wedding cake was DELICIOUS!!!!
GO AUDREY!
We loved our cake. We had a great variety of different cakes and toppings to choose from for our tasting and the cake came out perfect on our wedding day.
It was "the best wedding are ever". Having said that, we didn't get a wedding cake, we got 12! We used our cakes as our center pieces because we love them that much. A rude and very much in love guest texted me the next morning at 9 am to get the name of the bakery so she could go and get a cake. 9 am on my honeymoon!!!! And we saved money doing the 12 cakes vs a tiered cake they didn't mind loosing the money to please the bride. Great customer service. Can't wait for my birthday this month to have another excuse to get a cake.
When I went to flowerfield for the first time, they had these delicious rainbow cookies on a tray that we tasted that were from Audrey's bakery. From those cookies, I knew our cake would be great, but I had no idea that it would be as amazing as it was! When Steve and I did the cake cutting ceremony, we couldn't stop eating the cake because it was so delicious, and I usually don't eat cake at weddings. We enjoyed the cookies and cream filling, which was so unique and out of this world. The cake designer was asked to make a design similar to my invitation, which came out beautiful. We had some left over cake 2 weeks later and it was still as delicious as the wedding day. We can't wait to eat our 1 year anniversary/top layer of the cake next year!
While I didn't actually have a chance to eat my own wedding cake, save for the piece that gets shoved in your mouth during the cake cutting, I'm very happy with my Audrey's experience.
We have always relied on Audrey's for our baked goods, so we knew our wedding would be no different. We selected some strange pairings to make the cake more unique (banana mousse and peanut butter cake or oreo mousse with chocolate cake) and a lot of the guests commented on how delicious it was. Being one who loves baked goods but is often not impressed with wedding cakes, I was very happy to hear this!
One thing to note: I did the very bare minimum for decorations -- butter cream frosting, supplied my own accessories, picked the non-upgraded flavors, etc. There are several things that require an up-charge that we simply decided we did not want/need.
Looking back, I know we made the right choice in going basic, because my cake looked beautiful and tasted delicious!
Audrey's made the surprise groom's cake for my October 2012 wedding. I had hired a home-based baker back in November 2011 to make the groom's cake, but she ended up moving out of state in summer 2012 and so was unable to do it for me. None of the bakers she recommended to take her place were professional enough for my standards (one wanted me to drive to her bakery in Farmingdale on the afternoon of my wedding to pick up the cake myself, another told me that she guessed she could print out the e-mail I sent her and mail it to me to sign as a "contract type of thing" - um, what?!). I was left to scramble to find a replacement, searching the internet for a new baker, from Los Angeles, having never lived in Long Island or even been to a bakery there.
Our day of coordinator came to my rescue and told me she'd heard good things about Audrey's. I started corresponding with Nancy in their office via e-mail and immediately experienced the quality of service and competency that had been missing from all my other experiences. Initially I was going to go with another bakery due to price (Audrey's was quoting me twice what I had agreed to pay the home-based baker, which does make sense because they are a commercial operation and have higher costs than someone baking a couple of cakes a month alone at her house), but when that bakery flaked on getting back to me with a contract, I went running back to Audrey's. I have to commend them for their professionalism and excellent service standards.
Our groom's cake was a NY Islanders-themed cake for which I specified many design ideas - including a modeled hockey puck and stick, and writing on the cake board. It turned out perfectly (see the photo I added for the cake in all its glory at our reception). It was better than I envisioned. Inside was yellow cake with cannoli cream filling (to differentiate it from our chocolate and chocolate mousse wedding cake), and it was delicious! People were raving over how beautiful and fun it was. We couldn't take the leftovers back to Los Angeles, so all my inlaws' neighbors and co-workers got a great treat.
I would definitely recommend Audrey's to anyone looking for a specialty or novelty cake, like a groom's cake, or anything with fondant work. I was so pleased.
Audreys was our house bakery for our hall. We picked all the layers for our wedding cake and had no idea how it was going to taste, well it was amazing, a lot of people commented on how good it was, and it looked beautiful!!! Thank you audrey's!!! Definatly would recommend!!
The cake came out beautiful. I went through reception hall to design. It also tasted great!
Audrey's made the most delicious cake for our wedding! Nancy was amazing in helping us to create the perfect cake for our wedding. She also helped to design two groom's cakes for us to use for the rehearsal dinner and for the wedding. The only thing that wasn't perfect was one of the groom's cakes was supposed to have a race track on it that curved and turned right and left, and instead it was a round track around the cake. Despite that, Audrey's cake was absolutely fantastic and everyone inquired who our baker was. We will definitely continue to use Audrey's for future cake needs due to their fantastic service.
Sorry, but it didn't seem like this bakery really cared about giving you what you wanted, listening to what you wanted, or being helpful. They get a lot of business, so maybe they don't care about new customers. Maybe they are great with classic decorated wedding cakes, but not much outside the box if you are looking for something different.
The cake was yummy and the decorations were beautiful !!!! Great job !
Best wedding cake I've ever had! The design was amazing! Not your traditional 3 tiered cake; we got a 'lopsided' one that they called the mad hatter! It was definitely a hit!
I only have positive things to say about our cake. It was hands down the yummiest wedding cake I have ever had and I know this because we ate the leftovers every day for a week ( I can't wait for our anniversary!)
They went above and beyond my expectations with recreating the picture I sent them. It was the perfect color with just the right details and the flowers on it were even more beautiful than in the picture (which I got from a Martha Stewart Wedding magazine. )
It couldn't have been more perfect!
Our wedding cake was perfect! I loved the fondant and the style they did on the cake. The cake was funfetti cake (my favorite!) and was absolutely delicious!
Our wedding cake was included in the vendor (Lands End). I went to price out a grooms cake and it was a little pricey ($450), just a bit too much for what I wanted to spend. In the end I did not get a grooms cake.
I met with Nancy at Audrey's (who was incredibly helpful and patient with my crazy ideas) and brought her a photo which gave her a basis for my idea. I told her everything I wanted on my cake and it was a very unique cake style. They drew me a picture of my design and I was amazed how they really listened. The photo blew me away. It was exactly what I had pictured in my thoughts and thensome. The cake was gorgeous and absolutly delicious! I highly recommend Audrey's for any occassion!
The cake looked beautiful & it tasted amazing. This is definitely a place to go if you actually want to eat & enjoy your cake - it's not dry, or too sweet - it's perfect.
Audrey's made our wedding cake and it tasted ever more delicious than I could have expected. I loved the icing and the design also. I would use them again and again.
used them for my rehearsal dinner cake. so great and delicious!
There is a bakery which our caterer used as their house bakery and it was included in our package, but after tasting quite a few samples, we were not impressed. We also were not happy with the fact that we had to buy samples (we got 2 samples free, but the rest you had to purchase) and that they don’t offer a tasting. On top of that, they wanted to charge us an extra $600 to upgrade to fondant icing. We were like “absolutely not”. So, we made an appointment with Audrey’s Bakery in Sayville about 3 weeks prior to the wedding. We met with Nancy and told her what we were looking for and the design we wanted and she asked us if we would like to try some samples. Sure enough, they came out with a tray of the different cake flavors and fillings that we were thinking about having. Everything was absolutely delicious. To top it all off, the price was beyond reasonable and we paid just a little more for a cake we wanted rather than paying for a cake we did not like. Our cake was Chocolate Devil’s Food with cookies and cream filling and the top tier had peanut butter filling for us to enjoy on our anniversary next year. Our guests raved about the cake and we had enough to take home for our bbq the next day, where the family ate the rest.
Our cake came out great! We wanted it to be a bit different so we went with a sage green color cake with white accents. The cake decor was simple, elegant and beautiful. We also wanted to incorporate tiramisu (my favorite) and Audrey's was able to make our four tier cake with two different flavors (tiramisu and chocolate/vanilla). They were so accommodating and willing to work with us - a real pleasure to deal with. Not to mention that the cake was delicious!
All I can say is so tasty and so beautiful
We used Audrey's Bakery for our wedding on 9/26/10 since they are the house baker for Flowerfield caterers. Before we used them, we went for a cake tasting (what fun!) and that helped us to make the decision on what fillings to choose. They are very patient and are willing to work with you to get the cake of your dreams, all customized to your taste. I must say that typically wedding cakes do not taste as good as they look, however this cake was the best we ever tasted! It was so light and moist and not overly sweet. The filling was so fluffy and tasty and delicious. Even the fondant (which usually tastes like plastic) actually tasted more like marshmallow so the whole cake was just fresh and delicious. Highly recommend!!
Not only was our wedding cake awesome, but Audrey's also made a Tiffany's engagement ring in a box cake for our charm cake...from which single ladies pulled charms attached to ribbons. The ribbon/charm pull is a tradition practiced in Peru and in the American South, especially New Orleans.We got married at Land's End, so we didn't deal directly with Audrey's, but Land's End provided them with our cake designs, cake topper, ribbon/charms, and it all worked out beautifully.
awesome. do i need to say more? it was the most delicious thing i have ever sunk my teeth into and it's killing me that there's a chunk of it in my freezer that i can't enjoy for a year
If you can not pick a filling the chocolate moouse is the way to go with yellow cake. It was the hit of the wedding
Well all my friends, even some of the biggest skeptics who told me all wedding cake was alike had to eat their words.....we had a beautiful round 4 layer cake in an ivory with little shamrocks piped on the cake. Two layers were vanilla cake with lemon mousse and the other 2 layers were chocolate cake with cookies and cream mousse. I didn't get to eat my cake at the reception but the layer they sent us home with to "freeze" for our first anniversary never made it to the freezer! I had gotten my birthday cake there as well and was just blown away by the taste of the cake, as if it were made at home. None of that dry sheet cake feel....delicious! Cost of the cake was included in the reception package. The website showed examples of cakes which made it easier to decide which one to choose.
My cake was beautiful! Exactly how i pictured it to be! It tasted great too! It was included in timperpoint package.
Best cake ever. We got to choose every little detail and everyone ate their slice - in fact everyone wanted more even though they were full. Perfect fillings and delish to boot!
My wedding cake was exactly what I wanted it to be, both in looks and in taste. It was gorgeous covered in gum paste Lily’s and roses like my bouquet, and ribbons to go with the ribbons running through the entire wedding. The cake was yellow cake with raspberry and chocolate mousse filling. It was delicious. I got lots of compliments. Only negative was it was a bit pricey to add the ribbons and flowers. They also did my engagement party cake. I knew I wanted a double heart cake. I looked online for pictures and I couldn’t find the perfect cake. So I brought Audrey’s a few different pictures and had them create one for me. I told them I wanted it to be turquoise and pink. I was so excited when I saw it. It was perfect. It was exactly what I wanted it to be. It was also super delicious. We also got a ton of pastries and cookies from Audreys. I have to say, I have never in my life seen dessert go that fast at a party, especially cake. It was a huge cake and there was hardly any leftovers.
Dealt directly with the baker, super responsive over e-mail which was convenient for me, very helpful, creative, talented.;Can't think of anything.
my wedding cake came with the reception site but we ordered cakes from audreys. i ordered my husband a starbucks cup cae and he got me a louis vuitton cake. they both came out beautiully
Contact
231 Montauk Hwy, West Sayville, NY
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods's photos